Blu-ray
For Fans Only
3 stars
Overall Grade
3 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
2 Stars
HD Audio Quality
2 Stars
Supplements
0 Stars
High-Def Extras
3.5 Stars
Bottom Line
For Fans Only

Operation Petticoat (Olive Signature)

Street Date:
November 28th, 2017
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
November 30th, 2017
Movie Release Year:
1959
Studio:
Olive Films
Length:
122 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Needless to say, the world is a very different place today than it was in 1959, when Blake Edwards' naval comedy Operation Petticoat premiered to rave reviews and huge box office. In fact, the political and social climates at the time of this writing have turned dramatically toxic in just the three short years since this particular film was last released on Blu-ray. Although my general feelings about the movie haven't changed, certain parts of it seem even more uncomfortably dated at this particular moment in time. Fair or not, the context of how and when we watch a movie can have a major impact in our engagement with it.

I provided a typical plot overview and so forth when I reviewed the film in 2014. Rather than repeat myself, I'll just direct readers to that article. I stand by everything I said there. By and large, the Cary Grant/Tony Curtis vehicle remains a delightful comic adventure filled with witty dialogue, clever situations and terrific cast chemistry. Surprisingly devoid of slapstick, it's a very sophisticated early work for Edwards, later the director of almost the entire Pink Panther franchise. Reportedly, the filmmaker himself didn't think much of the movie, probably because it was a for-hire assignment early in his career rather than a project he'd developed for himself. Nevertheless, its success launched him onto the Hollywood A-List, and the majority of the film holds up remarkably well nearly six decades later – aside from one pretty glaring aspect.

I noted in my previous review that the film's attitudes toward gender may be seen as sexist by a modern audience, but I largely brushed that off as being a product of its time. While that excuse is still true, I have to admit that some scenes really made me squirm in my seat this time around. When handsome playboy Lt. Holden (Tony Curtis) aggressively pursues pretty young Nurse Duran (Dina Merrill) despite her telling him that she has no interest in romance, he forces himself into her space and won't take no for an answer. The scene culminates with him kissing her until her resistance melts. Caught in the act by a superior officer, Duran apologizes for leading him on (by merely being an attractive female in his general vicinity, I suppose), and genuinely seems to feel guilty about it. Back in 1959, this scene probably seemed perfectly innocent, even charming. Why shouldn't two beautiful people flirt and fall in love, even if one has to work a little harder than the other to make that happen? Watched today, in an environment where nearly the entire entertainment industry is melting down over numerous sexual misconduct scandals, Holden looks like a real creep, especially when we learn that the character is engaged to another woman the whole time.

This comes on top of other scenes where Lt. Cmdr. Sherman (Cary Grant) expresses his exasperation at the indignity of having a bunch of women on his ship, and some of those women (including Sherman's eventual love interest) are portrayed in very stereotypical ways as klutzy ditzes. Again, this surely played as harmless when the film was made and released. And maybe it is. I doubt that anyone who worked on the movie had ill intent when writing, directing or performing these scenes. In fact, in some ways, the film was fairly progressive for its day, in that the women ultimately prove themselves valuable additions to the crew and even teach the men a thing or two about running a ship. On the other hand, why should they have to prove themselves to the men at all?

I have terribly mixed feelings about all of this, both the content of the film and my reaction to it. I don't want to be a person who judges old movies by modern social standards that were simply different at the time. Audiences of 1959, both male and female, enthusiastically embraced Operation Petticoat. Men enjoyed the wartime adventure and naval hijinks. Women responded to the romantic fantasy of falling in love with a handsome and charming man in even the unlikeliest of circumstances. Who am I, a viewer in 2017 (and a man at that) to tell them that they were wrong?

What's more, who's to say that our view of the film won't change again over time, when the current climate eventually calms down and some form of normalcy (for better or worse) replaces it? Will some reader stumble across this review in twenty years and think I sounded ridiculous for fretting about all of this? Will I? Perhaps. I'm sure some of you out there feel that way right now.

As a reviewer, all I can do is offer my honest reaction to the experience of watching a movie. I still appreciate much of Operation Petticoat and value it highly overall. Its strengths greatly outweigh its weaknesses, and even those weaknesses are tame compared to other popular movies of its day. (Although oft ignored, James Bond basically rapes a woman at the beginning of 1965's Thunderball.) All the same, I have to acknowledge that some parts of the movie made me cringe this time around. Let's see how I feel about it in another few years.

The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats

Olive Films previously released Operation Petticoat on Blu-ray back in 2014 with a disc that I rated poorly on all technical levels and had zero bonus features. Three years on, the label has seen fit to reissue the movie as part of its premium Olive Signature line. To justify the double dip and $39.95 MSRP, the disc promises an improved video transfer and newly commissioned extras. One of these two things is true.

The Olive Signature edition comes packaged in a clear keepcase inside a slipcover. An included booklet reprints an essay also found on the disc itself.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The 2014 Blu-ray edition of Operation Petticoat was sourced from ratty film elements that looked like they'd been dragged across a gravel road before being scanned. The packaging for the new Olive Signature reissue boasts of a "New High-Definition digital restoration." Given that claim and the high MSRP, one might assume that Olive has either performed or licensed a new video master from a superior source. Unfortunately, no. This is clearly the same poor master with a small amount of new digital tinkering applied.

The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 image still suffers dirt, scratches and other very distracting damage throughout. If Olive (or Paramount, the content owner) has attempted any sort of digital clean-up for these issues, I couldn't tell. I was able to match up frames from both copies with the exact same scratches in the same locations. In addition to that, the picture is frequently swamped in nasty, heavy grain. Edge enhancement ringing is present in a number of scenes (fortunately not all), most noticeably in the movie's opening sequence. All in all, it looks pretty lousy.

Operation Petticoat - Comparison 1 2014 Blu-ray

Operation Petticoat - Comparison 1 2017 Blu-ray

The two Blu-rays are only slightly different. The 2014 copy was an open-matte transfer framed at a screen-filling 16:9 ratio. The Olive Signature version adds small letterbox bars to the top and bottom to bring the ratio to the theatrical 1.85:1. The image is just a smidge darker, and colors have been tweaked a bit. I doubt I ever would have noticed without a side-by-side comparison, but the old disc had a very minor blue tinge that has been removed or corrected here. I suppose these are all improvements, but they're incredibly small improvements, while the biggest problems with the master remain untouched.

Of its few positive attributes, the transfer generally has a decent amount of detail unmolested by Digital Noise Reduction. Black levels and contrast are pretty good. Scenes that were fortunate enough to skirt by without too much film damage look adequately watchable. I just wish the disc had more than a handful like that.

Operation Petticoat - Comparison 2 2014 Blu-ray

Operation Petticoat - Comparison 2 2017 Blu-ray

The Audio: Rating the Sound

As far as I can tell, the soundtrack on the Olive Signature Blu-ray is the same DTS-HD Master Audio mono track from the 2014 disc. The sound quality remains undistinguished. While dialogue is clear and robust enough, it slips out of sync for a good stretch during the middle of the movie. The musical score by David Rose and an uncredited Henry Mancini is thin and bright. Sound effects such as machine guns and explosions are extremely dull.

The disc is watchable despite these flaws, but I have no doubt that it could sound better with more care and effort.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

All of the bonus features on the Olive Signature disc are new and exclusive to the Blu-ray.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Considering that no previous DVD or Blu-ray edition of Operation Petticoat ever came with any extras, the new content that Olive produced for this edition is pretty impressive, and certainly the disc's only real selling point.

  • Audio Commentary – Australian critic and professor Adrian Martin delivers an informative if a bit dry audio lecture about the film, its director, and the two stars.
  • That's What Everybody Says About Me (HD, 12 min.) – Blake Edwards' daughter Jennifer Edwards and actress Lesley Ann Warren (who worked with him in Victor Victoria) reminisce about the director.
  • The Brave Crew of the Petticoat (HD, 20 min.) – Actors Gavin MacLeod (later star of The Love Boat) and Marion Ross (Happy Days) tell stories about working with Blake Edwards, Cary Grant and Tony Curtis.
  • The Captain and His Double: Cary Grant's Struggle of the Self (HD, 28 min.) – Author Marc Eliot paints Cary Grant as a very troubled, insecure man who hid behind a persona he created for himself. He discusses Grant's daddy issues, the tragic story of his mother's mental illness, the arc of his career, and his dalliance with LSD. Perhaps prohibited from talking about it further, Eliot casually calls Randolph Scott Grant's "boyfriend" but does not elaborate on the persistent rumors about their relationship.
  • Universal Newsreel Footage (HD, 4 min.) – A vintage clip shows footage of Cary Grant at the Radio City Music Hall premiere of the film.
  • Archival Footage (HD, 17 min.) – Silent except for the foleyed sound of a projector running, vintage 16mm footage shows the USS Balao (the real submarine that doubled as the Sea Tiger) at sea, at dock, and even in combat.
  • Essay – Also printed in the booklet that comes with the disc, critic Chris Fujiwara provides an overview of the film's production and financial success. Frustratingly, the on-disc copy of this essay automatically progresses from one page to the next too quickly to finish reading any of them. I recommend pausing at each page.


Operation Petticoat - Comparison 3 2014 Blu-ray

Operation Petticoat - Comparison 3 2017 Blu-ray

Final Thoughts

In terms of its sexual politics, Blake Edwards' 1959 hit Operation Petticoat has not aged particularly well, and some viewers may find aspects of it uncomfortable to watch today. Even as far as that goes, however, the film's problems are pretty tame. For the most part, it's still a delightful bit of entertainment.

Unfortunately, despite two tries, Olive Films just can't seem to do right by this movie. The new Olive Signature edition recycles the same crummy video transfer that looked awful when it first appeared on Blu-ray back in 2014, with only inconsequential tweaks. The disc is only worth owning for its new bonus features, but even those can't justify the premium pricing on their own.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc
  • Region A

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.85:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio mono

Subtitles/Captions

  • English Subtitles

Supplements

  • None

Exclusive HD Content

  • Audio Commentary
  • 3 Featurettes
  • Universal Newsreel Footage
  • Archival Footage
  • Essay by Critic Chris Fujiwara

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Related reviews