Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
4 stars
Amazon
$39.99
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
5 Stars
HD Video Quality
5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
1.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Shane

Street Date:
August 13th, 2013
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
August 14th, 2013
Movie Release Year:
1953
Studio:
Warner Bros.
Length:
118 Minutes
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

"Shane! Come back!" The plaintive cry of a young boy beseeching his hero to return echoes across the Wyoming plains and the landscape of cinema history. Though first uttered 60 years ago, the memorable line continues to endure, and so does the film that spawned it. Flawlessly directed by the great George Stevens, 'Shane' sits on a rarefied plane, one of a handful of iconic westerns that both embrace and defy the genre. Substantive themes, textured characters, and a heart as big as the West distinguish this classic feature that, despite its period setting, remains relevant and relatable to contemporary audiences.

On its surface, 'Shane' resembles a host of other westerns, with its rugged, outdoorsy feel, raucous bar fights, and cattlemen versus homesteaders conflict. But beneath these well-worn clichés lies a deeply human story focusing on individualism, coming of age, courage in the face of aggression, and the family ties that bind. Presented simply, through the wide, impressionable eyes of a 10-year-old tyke, the film exudes a warmth and innocence that make its messages more powerful. Much like 'To Kill a Mockingbird,' which it precedes by several years, 'Shane,' at its core, is about learning what's right, doing what's right, when to lash out, and when to stand tall and silent. Such abstract ideas are difficult to present and make palatable, but Stevens never resorts to preachy tactics to put them across, relying instead on the power of the image to make his points. And like the film's eponymous sharpshooter, he never misses his target.

When the rugged loner named Shane (Alan Ladd) approaches the Starrett family homestead on horseback one bright morning, initial trepidation over his intentions is quickly eased by his relaxed manner, polite demeanor, and eagerness to help the pioneer brood. Joe (Van Heflin) and Marian (Jean Arthur) enlist Shane's aid around their fledgling ranch, much to the delight of their young son Joey (Brandon De Wilde), who sees the stranger as a mythic figure and soon begins to idolize him. Trouble brews, however, in the form of Rufus Ryker (Emile Meyer) and his marauding band of greedy cattlemen, who try to bully the peaceful settlers into abandoning their claims. With Shane's help, Joe and some of his neighbors attempt to stand up to Ryker, but when the conniving rascal brings in ruthless gunslinger Jack Wilson (Jack Palance) as a scare tactic, the conflict escalates. Marian, who harbors a latent attraction to Shane (it's unclear whether they share a mutual history), abhors violence, but after Wilson kills one of their friends in cold blood, it becomes clear brute force is the only language the gang of thugs can speak and understand.

Stevens, aided by A.B. Guthrie Jr.'s literate screenplay, tells the story of Shane and the homesteaders in a delicate, thoughtful manner that heightens its resonance. Yet when it's time for action, he goes full throttle, using his keen eye and editing acuity to choose interesting shots and angles. The fight sequences contain dozens of quick cuts that add impact and increase tempo, while in tense scenes Stevens slows the pace down, lingering on his subjects to draw out suspense. Unlike many of his peers, however, Stevens' style is largely invisible; his genius lies in his uncanny storytelling ability.

And that enviable ability produces several memorable scenes: Shane teaching Joey how to shoot and impressing the boy with his pinpoint accuracy; Wilson's showdown with one of the homesteaders on the town's muddy thoroughfare; the barroom brawl that escalates into a free-for-all; and, of course, the final, climactic confrontation between Shane and Wilson that leads to the touching, uncertain denouement and that oft-quoted final line.

Performances are first-rate, with Ladd contributing his finest portrayal as the soft-spoken stranger who impacts everyone's life. Somehow the role fit the modestly talented, journeyman actor, who gained popularity in a string of tough-guy, film noir parts and even portrayed Jay Gatsby in the 1949 adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic novel. Ladd works well with the always reliable and believable Heflin, who here projects a weary stoicism that's quite effective, and noted romantic comedy star Arthur, who makes her final film appearance in a change-of-pace role as the worried, conflicted mother who fears her son may be tarnished by the violence around him.

And yet despite such fine work, 'Shane' still belongs to young De Wilde, who provides the film with its emotional core and files one the screen's most natural and affecting juvenile performances. The 10-year-old was nominated for Best Supporting Actor for his intuitive, heartwarming portrayal (although his parents reportedly didn't tell him about the honor until four years later!), as was Palance (billed here as Walter Jack Palance), whose smirking, cocky triggerman remains one of the nastiest villains in western history.

Aside from its subdued artistry, meaningful story, and superior acting, 'Shane' is perhaps most notable for its subtly expressed anti-gun platform, a revolutionary stance for a mainstream Hollywood picture at that time. Once again, credit Stevens, who was deeply influenced by the senseless violence he witnessed as a documentarian during World War II, and sought to express his distaste for firearms by realistically depicting their tremendous force. With uncompromising grit, he shows how a single bullet shot from a .45 could catapult a body several feet, and by ramping up the sound of a firing gun to such a degree that it makes the audience jump, he further emphasizes its deadly nature. Shane tells Joey, "A gun is as good or as bad as the man using it," but Stevens, with supreme forethought, tells us we need to treat the weapon with respect and stop romanticizing and trivializing it.

In addition to the two supporting actor nominations, 'Shane' received four other Oscar nods, including Best Picture (it lost to 'From Here to Eternity'), Director, Screenplay, and Color Cinematography (the only Academy Award it won). Accolades, however, don't define 'Shane'; craftsmanship does. And though John Ford may well be the undisputed master of western cinema, George Stevens, with this one film, gives him a helluva run for his money.

The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats

'Shane' arrives on Blu-ray packaged in a standard case with particularly drab, generic cover art. Video codec is 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 and default audio is DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. Once the disc is inserted into the player, the static menu immediately pops up; no previews or promos precede it.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Shane' was originally scheduled for an early June Blu-ray release, but the reason for its delay actually dates back six decades to its 1953 premiere when the film was caught in the crosshairs of the widescreen revolution. George Stevens originally shot 'Shane' in the traditional 1.37:1 aspect ratio in 1951, but by the time the methodical director finished his meticulous editing of the movie, the widescreen process was poised to forever transform the motion picture industry, and no studio wanted to be left in the dust. So right before 'Shane' opened, Paramount cropped Loyal Griggs' gorgeous cinematography on the top and bottom of the frame so the film could be exhibited in the wider 1.66:1 format. 'Shane' thus became the first widescreen film of the modern era, beating by eight months the release of 20th Century Fox's highly touted CinemaScope epic, 'The Robe.' Only when 'Shane' premiered on television did viewers first see Stevens' original 1.37:1 version.

Rightfully, all home video editions of 'Shane' also used the original framing of the film, because it was ideally suited to 4:3 TV screens. But when it came time to produce a Blu-ray rendering of the classic western, 4:3 televisions had become obsolete, so Paramount decided to restore the 1.66:1 version of 'Shane' to maximize the widescreen real estate. The director's son, George Stevens Jr., who, as a 19-year-old, worked on the film as a production assistant, reviewed each shot for optimal framing, and, after the high-def transfer was struck, publicly stated he believed the restored 1.66:1 version would have met with his father's enthusiastic approval. Purists, however, cried foul, and the resulting online firestorm (director Woody Allen even voiced his objections) prompted Warner Home Video, which had since licensed the film from Paramount, to cancel the widescreen version and release the original on Blu-ray instead. While it would have been fantastic to have a 'Shane' edition featuring both aspect ratios (much like Criterion did with 'On the Waterfront,' which had three), WHV told Stevens, Jr. putting both versions on a single disc would not be possible.

Turning 'Shane' into a two-disc special edition would have been an expensive prospect, and I can understand WHV's reluctance. Though I would have loved to see the restored 1.66:1 version (and still hope to one day), my preference is always the director's original intent, and the 1.37:1 transfer scores such high marks it erases any disappointment. Without a doubt, this is how 'Shane' deserves to be seen, and even the most discriminating fan will be thrilled by this spectacular effort.

Lush, vibrant, and stunningly clear best describe the 'Shane' transfer, which maintains a lovely, but not obtrusive, grain structure that shows off Griggs' breathtaking, Oscar-winning cinematography to its best advantage. Contrast is pitch-perfect and accentuates the marvelous feeling of depth that distinguishes the sweeping vistas, which still look panoramic, even in the Academy ratio. Griggs used special lenses to make the Grand Teton Mountains look more immediate, and seeing the majestic, snow-capped peaks jut up behind the plateau's earthy landscape and sparkling streams is striking. Even utilitarian two-shots exude a hint of dimensionality that makes the drama feel more immediate. A master of composition, Stevens carefully and brilliantly constructed each angle to achieve the highest degree of impact (which makes it almost impossible to imagine the widescreen crop), and the transfer's color balancing and temperature beautifully complement his estimable technique.

Hues are rich and bold, but still appear natural and cohesive - not always easy when dealing with Technicolor. Blue skies, green fields, and varying shades of brown and gold keep the eye engaged, while deep black levels, rock-solid whites, and stable, true fleshtones tie nicely into the palette. The day-for-night scenes composing the bulk of the film's climax are dazzling in their clarity and presence, with not a hint of crush obscuring any details. Background elements are also crystal clear, and fabrics, from the fringe on Shane's vest to Wilson's ominous leather glove, flaunt appropriate grades of texture.

Close-ups look great, too, especially those of the fresh-faced and wide-eyed Brandon De Wilde. At age 51, Jean Arthur could pass for 10 years younger, but her tight shots are diffused - a typical way of photographing leading ladies in that era - and they constitute the only soft moments in an otherwise crisp and elegant presentation. Warner, as usual, treats its vintage product with the utmost respect, scrubbing away all print defects, such as marks or scratches, and shying away from any enhancements. Without question, this is an A-plus transfer that does this classic movie proud, heightening its raw power while stimulating our senses.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

George Stevens was one of the first directors to champion the narrative impact of audio and put sound on the same artistic plane as images. He became a sound pioneer of sorts in the 1950s, and his innovations more than likely contributed to the high level of audio we enjoy in movies today. For 'Shane,' Stevens wanted an explosive sound for each burst of gunfire, and went to great lengths - reportedly firing small cannonballs into trashcans - to achieve the desired effect. The first jolt, when Shane demonstrates his sharpshooting skills to young Joey, almost knocks you out of your chair, thanks to a potent DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track that supplies as much power as some of its 5.1 cousins. But the intermittent blasts also challenge the balance of the rest of the mix, which requires some volume tinkering to achieve a comfortable level. All in all, though, this track delivers solid audio, marked by bright, expansive high end tones and resonant lows, with plenty of ambient subtleties in between providing wonderful nuances.

Any age-related imperfections have been meticulously erased, leaving a clean, vibrant track that complements the frontier setting and tense confrontations well. In addition to the gunfire, accents such as shattering glass, fisticuffs, and splintering wood are remarkably potent, while Victor Young's pedestrian yet eminently hummable music score enjoys a high degree of fidelity and tonal depth, with the soaring crescendos nicely resisting distortion. Though there's not much in the way of stereo separation or opportunities for rumbling bass, the track possesses a full-bodied, expansive feel that belies its vintage roots.

The audio's biggest problem, unfortunately, is the dialogue, which occasionally sounds a bit muffled. This may well be an issue with the original mix, but the inability to comprehend certain lines somewhat hampers enjoyment of the film. Conversations also seem to be pitched at a slightly lower level than other elements of the track, but thankfully the discrepancy isn't very severe.

Despite this one caveat, the audio for 'Shane' is crisp and powerful, and Stevens would certainly relish hearing the gunfire in all its lossless glory.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Only a couple of extras flesh out this classic release.

  • Audio Commentary – George Stevens, Jr., who, as a 19-year-old, worked as a production assistant on his father's film, and associate producer Ivan Moffat provide a thoughtful, interesting commentary that seems to have been recorded for the movie's initial DVD release in the early 2000s. The pair shares many anecdotes and analyzes 'Shane' from almost every conceivable angle. We learn Montgomery Clift was Stevens' original choice to play Shane, and William Holden and Katharine Hepburn were considered for the parts eventually played by Heflin and Arthur. Stevens Jr. quotes from the film's screenplay and his father's memos and interviews to shed additional light on the picture, and the elder Stevens' obsession with authenticity and respect for his audiences is also examined. Moffat discusses working with Stevens, and how the war experiences they shared as documentarians shaped them both and influenced 'Shane.' Despite a few gaps and dry stretches, this is an enthusiastic and informative dialogue from a couple of men with first-hand knowledge of their subject, which makes it all the more fascinating, worthwhile, and a rarity for a vintage film.
  • Theatrical Trailer (SD, 2 minutes) – The film's original preview gives away too many plot points, but remains an interesting relic, especially as it shows the day-for-night shots without the necessary darkening effect.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are no high-def exclusives.

Final Thoughts

One of the all-time great western films, 'Shane' explores potent issues, acutely delineates character, and sustains a subtle emotional thread with simplicity, grace, and an artistry that was the hallmark of its acclaimed director, George Stevens. Iconic moments abound in this tale of courage, family values, and individualism that's far from a typical genre shoot-'em-up. Oscar-winning cinematography, excellent performances, a literate script, and inspired direction combine to create a film rich in meaning and spirit that never fails to touch and move us, no matter how many times we've seen it. Warner's Blu-ray presentation is top-notch, featuring a glorious Technicolor transfer and appropriately explosive audio. Thin supplements are the only stain on this otherwise impressive release that no classic film buff should be without. Highly recommended.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.37:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Stereo
  • French Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Theatrical Trailer

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Amazon
$39.99
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»

Related reviews