Worth a Look
3.5 stars
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
1.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
2 Stars
Bottom Line
Worth a Look

Independence Day

Street Date:
March 11th, 2008
Reviewed by:
Peter Bracke
Review Date: 1
March 7th, 2008
Movie Release Year:
Fox Home Entertainment
144 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

If ever a movie was sold by its theatrical trailer, it was 'Independence Day.' It only took audiences one look at that ominous shot of a UFO's shadow, towering over Earth and ready to blast us to smithereens, to trigger lines around the block. There seems to be no logical explanation for the enormous success of such a dim-witted film -- it's story was hardly new, the effects were good but not great, and the reviews were tepid at best. Yet 'ID4' grossed over $300 million in the US alone (even more worldwide), turning it into the biggest hit of the year. This is one of those movies that left me feeling totally out of step with popular culture.

On paper, 'ID4' should have been a slam-dunk for me. It takes two of my favorite cinematic guilty pleasures -- the disaster movie and alien invasion flicks -- and marries them to old-fashioned popcorn cliches and a glorious cast of B-level stars. Unfortunately, with phoned-in melodrama so bad even Irwin Allen couldn't have written it, those initially cool shots of aliens about to destroy us are all 'ID4' really has going for it. Once the movie gets the big explosions out of the way, it collapses under the weight of endless sci-fi cliches and its own sheer hokiness.

With a set-up right out of a '70s TV miniseries, the film begins by introducing us to an expansive cast of movie caricatures. (Look, there's Bill Pullman as the President! Will Smith as the cocky young fighter pilot! Jeff Goldblum as chaostician Ian Malcolm, er, scientist David Levinson!). Almost immediately, a sense of narrative irrelevance begins to nag at us, we know the film is only focusing on these one-dimensional characters because they are the ones who are going to live. All the dramatic interaction is just space filler as we mark time to the big special effects payoffs -- the money shots we've already seen in the trailer.

Still, these opening scenes of alien destruction do possess a certain majestic visual power. 'ID4' was directed by Roland Emmerich ('Stargate,' 'Godzilla'), and though he's always been a derivative filmmaker, there is still some fun to be had in watching all the Spielberg-esque shots of dumbstruck civilians staring up at the sky, right before a big blue alien death ray zaps them into oblivion. One has faith that even a chintzy pastiche-maker like Emmerich will follow up such a gangbusters opening with some substance, or at least some compelling plot developments.

Alas, once the alien invasion is over and the remaining survivors band together to defeat the enemy, 'ID4' completely falls apart. The script grafts in pop culture allusions that should have been cool but only end up feeling like second-rate 'X-Files' leftovers. The film is overstuffed with lame-brained plot threads (Area 51, government conspiracies, and even an alcoholic Randy Quaid flying a bi-plane all factor into the story), and while I can usually forgive a summer movie for the sin of well-intentioned stupidity, even I have my limits. By the time one of the characters created a computer virus to derail the alien's computer system (glad to know this superior race uses Macs), I just couldn't believe anyone would buy this jingo-ist nonsense, much less stand up and cheer it on.

It also bugged me that Emmerich totally overdoes the humor. The film is jokey instead of clever, and even the self-referential moments only undermine any hint of realism the film created in the first act. The acting doesn't help either. I really disliked the smug performance by Smith (who seems to be playing to the cheap seats with his loud, shouting line readings), and Pullman is also terrible as the President (has there ever been an actor with less charisma?). Goldblum is a little more appealing, but that's simply because he's doing another riff on Ian Malcolm. I know this is 'ID4' and not 'The Hours,' but the rules of good characterization still apply -- you gotta care about the people first, or you're not going to care what happens to them.

In hindsight, I must give some props to 'ID4' for capturing the zeitgeist of the time. In 1996, America was still dealing with the fall-out over the Gulf War, so a rah-rah movie like this (note how in the film the rest of the world just sits around, waiting for America to take action) certainly appealed to our need for a Reagen-esque return to mythic status. As a serious sci-fi film -- or even a decent entertainment -- 'ID4' has only suffered in the interim. Over ten years on, it feels like an artifact of another time, and quite frankly, it seems even stupider.

(Note: Fox presents 'ID4' on Blu-ray in its original 144-minute theatrical version, not the 153-minute cut that has been issued in several DVD incarnations. Added in for the extended cut were a couple of character-based exposition scenes, which are not included on this Blu-ray as extras.)

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Independence Day' hits Blu-ray with fan expectations high. It's fair to say that early adopters have long expected this to be a de facto demo disc, sight unseen, especially as previous video versions (namely the previous special edition DVD) have been somewhat wanting. I will say that I've always had mixed feeling about hailing 'ID4' as ideal for high-def, namely because the film was made before it was commonplace to polish transfers with computer-enhanced trickery, so I suspect those excepting an absolutely pristine presentation will be in for a disappointment.

Indeed, 'ID4' looks exactly like a 1996 film should. Although I was very impressed with the cleanliness of the print here (there's nary a speckle or blemish to be seen), there is considerable grain, particularly on some of the darker effects shots. This gives 'ID4' a film-like look I found pleasing, but do expect some fluctuations in the intensity of the grain, as well as some instances of bobbing contrast.

Otherwise, I was very happy with this 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode (which gets a BD-50 dual-layer disc in which to stretch its legs). Colors are easily the best I've seen in any video version of the film, especially the improved fleshtones and noticeably superior primaries. Detail is also very good, especially in daylight sequences, which often boast great depth and readily apparent dimensionality. Darker scenes are again comparatively disappointing in this regard, as they feel a bit flatter (though still look good), and all in all shadow delineation is above average for a film that is now over a decade old. I also appreciated the sharpness of the transfer, as it's ample but not marred with unsightly edge enhancement (which was a problem on most of the previous DVD versions).

I wouldn't rate 'ID4' an absolute five-star Blu-ray due to the inconsistencies between light and dark scenes, but otherwise I was very pleased -- in fact, it even looks a bit better than I expected.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Easily matching the video is this DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround (48kHz/16-bit, and French and Spanish 640kbps Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround dubs are also offered). It's a very dynamic mix that easily holds up to today's big-budget action spectaculars. Crank this baby up, because you're in for a treat.

I was immediately startled by the deep, powerful bass. Time is not always kind to the big event movies of our youth, but 'ID4' holds up very well. The first shots of the ominous spacecraft hovering over Earth are accompanied by some serious low tones directed to the subwoofer -- this one is a real couch-mover. Dynamics are equally strong, with a noticeable expansiveness between the peaks and valleys of the soundtrack that sounds great at high volume. Dialogue is likewise quite well-balanced (it was always understandable), though I would still have liked to hear it bumped up ever-so-slightly in the mix.

The only area where I was underwhelmed was with surround use. Certainly, the action is delivered with clear force -- the first act piece de resistance of the aliens blowing up treasured national landmarks is a whopper. Unfortunately, quiet scenes are lackluster. I longed for more sustained ambiance. The result is a bit of a Jekyll and Hyde soundtrack -- the action rocks, but the rest is bland. Of course, anyone picking up 'ID4' on Blu-ray probably doesn't care about sonic subtleties anyway, so I suppose few will mind such nitpicks.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

'ID4' is another one of those catalog titles that Fox has issued on DVD so many times I've lost count. Unfortunately, none of them ever impressed me all that much in terms of bonus features -- the documentary material was all mostly rehashed promo fluff and utterly forgettable.

So, ironically, that makes the fact that Fox has not ported over any of those extras to this Blu-ray edition good news, as now I don't have to wade through the tedium once again. Completists might complain, of course, and one still wishes Fox would spend some money and create a genuine special edition of 'ID4' someday (the film's box office grosses certainly seem to warrant it). In any case, all we really get here are a couple of audio commentaries, plus some high-def exclusives. (Note that there are no subtitle options offered on any of the extras, including the commentaries.)

  • Filmmaker Audio Commentary - Director Roland Emmerich and producer Dean Devlin sit down for a lively, engaging discussion. Even though I usually don't like the films the pair makes, I do like their commentaries. Emmerich in particular is full of enthusiasm for even the stupidest moments of 'ID4,' and he is sometimes so child-like that it almost makes me like the movie more. The pair is also open about the obvious influences that inspired 'ID4' (i.e, the countless other movies they ripped off), plus we get the usual backpatting about the cast (especially how great Will Smith is, yadda yadda yadda). A good, solid commentary that is certainly the best extra on the Blu-ray.
  • Visual Effects Audio Commentary - The second track features visual effects supervisors Volker Engel and Doug Smith, but it's a bit of a snoozer. The pair speak in low, measured tones, and all the tech talk begins to fold in upon itself. Since there are no before-and-after visuals to illustrate what the pair is saying, the track also suffers from additional tedium. I suppose those really into '90s-era effects will want to listen to this, but I quickly hit the fast-forward button once the big alien attack near the beginning of the film was over...
  • Theatrical Trailers (HD) - Fox provides a theatrical teaser and three different theatrical trailers for 'Independence Day,' all in HD (though the quality, especially on the teaser, is marginal). There are also HD spots for the Fox Blu-ray titles 'Alien vs. Predator,' 'The Fly,' 'I, Robot,' 'Planet of the Apes,' 'Predator' and 'X-Men: The Last Stand.'

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Fox hasn't reinvented the next-gen wheel with the exclusives on 'ID4,' but at least they've produced a couple of new features for Blu-ray fans.

  • ID4 Datastream Trivia Track - Another Fox graphic track, this one culls the majority of its info from the visual effects commentary. It highlights most of the key effects and offers basic factoids on how specific shots and stunts were created. Unfortunately, it's not all that exciting, and I found the small-ish text a bit hard to read, even on my 70" screen.
  • "Alien Scavenger Hunt" Interactive Game - Making use of the Blu-ray format's BD-Java capabilities, the game is a merging of basic interactivity and feature film playback. Rather than a stand-alone game, activate the "Alien Scavenger Hunt" and the film starts up, but now with an interface overlaid at the bottom of the screen, plus a "targeting crosshair" (aka cursor) you can control with your remote. The object is to find the objects on-screen that are listed in the overlay. As you "collect" the objects, they are added to your tally, and there are twelve objects in all to find. As a game, this is just plain weird, so I wonder who will have to patience to sit through the entire 144-minute feature film (though Fox does let you save your progress and return at a later date) when all you're doing is clicking on the screen a few times.
  • Bookmarks- Select your favorite scenes from 'ID4,' and store them for playback even after you eject the disc from the player.
  • Keyword Search - A bit a of useless feature if you ask me, but Fox has included a very extensive list of indexed topics ("Air Force One," "Fierstein, Harvey," etc.) that, when selected, take you to the relevant point in the feature.
  • D-Box - Finally, Fox has encoded D-Box motion control commands into 'ID4,' so if you have one of the company's custom home theater chairs, you can feel a little rumble every time one of the aliens blows shit up.

Final Thoughts

'ID4' was conceived in the grand tradition of stupid summer popcorn movie fun, and on that level it is hard to hate. Unfortunately, it is a pretty stupid film, and full of so many howlingly bad inconsistencies, contrivances, and hair-brained plot devices that it's hard to believe audiences didn't laugh it off the screen. In any case, this Blu-ray is easily the best the film has ever looked and sounded on home video. The extras are lackluster, but if you just want to watch the best version yet of 'ID4' on your home theater then this disc is worth checking out.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc
  • BD-Java Enhanced
  • D-Box Enhanced

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround (48kHz/16-bit)
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (640kbps)
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (640kbps)


  • English Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles
  • Cantonese Subtitles
  • Korean Subtitles


  • Audio Commentaries
  • Theatrical Trailers

Exclusive HD Content

  • Fact Track
  • Interactive Game
  • Content Search Index
  • Bookmarking

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.