Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
4.5 stars
Overall Grade
4.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
2 Stars
High-Def Extras
4.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

The Breakfast Club (Criterion)

Street Date:
January 2nd, 2018
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
January 9th, 2018
Movie Release Year:
1985
Studio:
Criterion
Length:
97 Minutes
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Portions of this review also appear in our coverage of the 30th Anniversary Edition Blu-ray

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

What separates the John Hughes' teen films from the countless others released before his directorial debut with Sixteen Candles is the genuine respect he showed for the adolescent characters being portrayed and the young audience watching his films. The people occupying the fictional town of Shermer, Illinois act like real teens, with legitimate concerns about those awkward years between childhood and the world of adults. His plots are infused with a general understanding and experience many viewers can relate to. Hughes' films don't treat teenagers condescendingly or portray their emotional lives as superficial or shallow plot devices. In his films, teens are allowed to speak their minds with a unique, authentic voice all their own. No film demonstrates this better than The Breakfast Club, a movie frequently celebrated for defining teen culture.

The structure of the narrative is near brilliant. The film commences with a comedic atmosphere that subtly and cleverly establishes each character's stereotype and social group, including that of Principal Vernon (Paul Gleason). Andy (Emilio Estevez) is the school jock with a great future as long as he does what he's told. Claire (Molly Ringwald) is the popular girl, the princess, everyone thinks is perfect. As the brain and the youngest of the bunch, Brian (Anthony Michael Hall) is seen as the most innocent and harmless. Allison (Ally Sheedy) is the basket case with little to say and who doesn't seem to care what others think. Bender (Judd Nelson) is the troublemaker, a future criminal, who might just be trying to appear tough.

30th Anniversary Edition (bottom)

Once Hughes has our attention, the story slowly turns into a serious and somewhat unexpected drama about the modern teenager. Their relationships with their parents are shown in the first few minutes. It's no accident that Bender is seen walking to campus by himself, and Allison's parents just drive away without even looking at her. When the characters sit down, they do so according to preconceived notions of each other. It doesn't matter if anyone in the audience has ever directly experienced a Saturday detention like the one put on screen. The point is to confront the social hierarchies of high school and discover their similarities, and Hughes does this by locking a group of kids up in the library. It's a space where they will eventually have to talk and face up to their stereotypes — not just of each other but also of themselves. "In the simplest terms and the most convenient definitions."

Their shenanigans and tomfoolery during those eight hours is more a consequence of their growing openness and letting down of their guards. With each moment that they reveal more about themselves and their inner thoughts, they also become more rebellious and less fearful of acting according to their prescribed social circles. If we're being just as honest as these kids, then we should admit that cliques are ultimately an effect of fear — afraid of being alone and unaccepted because it's easier and more comfortable to be a part of a group. To resist that pecking order requires at least a small bit of rebelliousness. Of course in one very intimate scene towards the latter part of the story, they admit that come Monday morning high school life will resume as before, suggesting that as much as we are aware of the hierarchies, we continue to abide by them into adulthood. The principal and Carl (John Kapelos) are proof of that fact.

Hughes clearly did something right with The Breakfast Club, since kids today are still watching and enjoying the film. They continue to find a connection with the characters and dilemmas of high school life. In many respects, the 80s teen classic appears to be an accurate portrait of adolescence, a film that doesn't feel condescending or artificial. It digs deeper into what concerns kids most — a desire to talk, be heard, and make friendship, and because of this, The Breakfast Club remains incredibly influential and respected.

Vital Disc Stats: The Blu-ray

This Blu-ray edition of John Hughes' The Breakfast Club comes courtesy of The Criterion Collection (spine #905) on a Region A locked, BD50 disc and housed in their standard clear keepcase. Accompanying the disc is a 24-page booklet with an insightful essay entitled "Smells Like Teen Realness" by author and culture critic David Kamp. There are no trailers or promos before being greeted by the distributor's normal static menu screen and options.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

30th Anniversary Edition (bottom)

According to information in the accompanying booklet, the AVC MPEG-4 encode was struck from a brand-new remaster of the original 35mm camera negatives at 4K resolution. This is great news and very much appreciated since the comedy classic deserves the best possible treatment. However, the results unfortunately don't yield the sort of night and day difference one would have hoped for when compared to Universal's 30th Anniversary release from a couple years ago, which reportedly was also struck from a new restoration of the original elements. This is not to suggest there are not any visible improvements because there are. Even though the difference is relatively mild and near negligible, it is enough to say this is the best the movie has ever looked on home video to date.

What this transfer also reveals to us is that the cinematography will likely always be the limiting factor in all future releases. The only other possible improvements imaginable could come from the higher dynamic range and wider color gamut provided on the Ultra HD format, but we'll have to wait and see if studios want to spend the time and money on that. For now, this HD presentation delivers the same warmer gamma as before, showing brighter, deeper reds and oranges, giving facial complexions a more natural, rosier glow. Contrast remains the same and well-balanced with crisp, clean whites. One of the better improvements is the brightness levels, displaying inky and full-bodied blacks without reaching the point of crushing the finer details, and the very minor banding from the previous release is now gone.

A majority of the 1.85:1 image falls on the softer side of things, suggesting this is inherent to the original photography. Nevertheless, this version definitely shows better definition and resolution overall without any the pesky artificial touch-ups and sharpening seen on the last Blu-ray. Here, minor blemishes and small wrinkles are exposed, and the entire frame is consistently awash in a very fine layer of natural grain, giving the presentation a lovely film-like quality. Viewers can also better appreciate the smallest detail in the background, and the threading and stitching of each outfit are sharp. All things considered, and in spite of yielding negligible improvements, owners of previous editions have reason to purchase the film again, as this is probably the most faithful representation we're likely ever going to see.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

30th Anniversary Edition (bottom)

The accompanying booklet also mentions the soundtrack was remastered from the same 35mm elements used for the video, and Criterion presents it here as an uncompressed PCM 2.0 monoaural track. A DTS-HD Master Audio option is also available and appears to be identical to that heard on the Universal Studios Blu-ray. As for the mono version, audio purists will be incredibly happy with the results, displaying excellent clarity without the slightest hint of distortion. Dynamics and acoustics maintain superb detailing within each note and instrument, providing every song selection with palpable fidelity and outstanding sense of presence. Low bass is equally robust and hearty so that each song carries an appreciable weight and depth. Of course, this being a character-driven comedy, dialogue is given top priority, delivering exceptional intonation in every emotive line and distinct clarity in the slightest change of pitch and inflection. Although the DTS-HD track is equally enjoyable, it's nice to have a first-rate audio track such as this as an option.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

30th Anniversary Edition (bottom)

Audio Commentary: Stars Judd Nelson and Anthony Michael Hall team up for this commentary track. The discussion is full of some cool tidbits and stories surrounding the production, and their friendly banter is quite enjoyable and full of memories, just nothing we would call technical. Overall, it's a cool listen and comes with plenty of smiles.

Sincerely Yours (SD, 51 min): This documentary is actually broken into 12 segments that can be watched separately or in sequence. It features interviews with cast and crew reminiscing on the production and working with the late John Hughes. A few of the segments are character-oriented, where actors talk about preparation for the role and motivation. Other interviews mull over the cultural impact and legacy of the film. This is a nicely done and comprehensive doc for fans to enjoy, but my one nitpick is the fact that Diablo Cody participates in the discussion. Personally, she's quite distracting and terribly feels out of place. 

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Cast & Crew (HD, 1080i/60): A nice collection of interviews chatting about various aspects of the production. The first is a brand new interview made special for this release while the rest are vintage promotional material.

            Molly Ringwald and Ally Sheedy (19 min)

            Judd Nelson (12 min)

            Ally Sheedy (15 min)

            Irene Brafstein (9 min)

            Paul Gleason (11 min)

John Hughes (HD): A pair of excellent vintage audio interviews with the filmmaker talking about his career, story origins, writing the script, the characters and the music.

            American Film Institute, 1985 (47 min)

            Sound Opinions, 1999 (16 min)

Electronic Press Kit (1080i/60, 24 min): An assortment of promotional material with more cast & crew interviews, BTS footage and the original theatrical preview.

This American Life (HD, 16 min): An episode from the radio program showing Molly Ringwald's reaction to the film decades later with her 10-year-old and describes her experience of it as a parent.

Describe the Ruckus (HD, 12 min): Produced exclusively for this Criterion edition, this video essay features Judd Nelson reading John Hughes notes written at the time of production, revealing his thought process.

Today (1080i/60, 10 min): A pair of video excerpts from the television program interviewing the cast.

Deleted & Extended Scenes (1080i/60, 52 min): A long collection of exercised scenes sourced from VHS.

Final Thoughts

The Breakfast Club is arguably John Hughes' most celebrated motion picture, often viewed as defining the 80s youth culture. The teen classic is a smart film which provides its adolescent leads with an authentic voice and doesn't treat them like caricatures. The immensely influential movie arrives courtesy of The Criterion Collection with a generally satisfying audio and video presentation that honestly doesn't improve much from the previous release, but a treasure trove of new supplements will definitely tease fans. Taken as a whole, it's a strong package, and fans of classic 80s cinema will surely be happy with the purchase.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.85:1

Audio Formats

  • English LPCM Mono
  • English DTS-HD MA 5.1

Supplements

  • Audio commentary from 2015 featuring actors Anthony Michael Hall and Judd Nelson
  • New interviews with actors Molly Ringwald and Ally Sheedy
  • New video essay featuring director John Hughes’s production notes, read by Nelson
  • Documentary from 2015 featuring interviews with cast and crew
  • 50 minutes of never-before-seen deleted and extended scenes
  • Rare promotional and archival interviews and footage
  • Excerpts from a 1985 American Film Institute seminar with Hughes
  • 1999 radio interview with Hughes
  • Segment from a 1985 episode of NBC’s Today show featuring the film’s cast
  • Audio interview with Molly Ringwald from a 2014 episode of This American Life
  • Trailer
  • PLUS: An essay by critic David Kamp

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.