The Nightmare Before Christmas - 3D

When it was originally made in 1993, 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' was not a 3D production. The film was photographed in standard 2D format. However, for a theatrical re-release in 2006, Disney had the film digitally converted into 3D. This was in fact the first such attempt at a 2D-to-3D conversion for an entire feature film, and the studio obviously put a lot of attention and care into the process (more so than many of today's quickie 3D conversions). The results were so successful and popular that, for a few years, Disney made an annual tradition of re-releasing the 3D version to theaters around the holidays.

In addition to the obvious dimensionalization of the picture, the 3D version of the film features a few more (mostly minor) changes. The movie has new end credits to reflect the work done on the 3D version. Some twinkling stars and floating art cards have been added to the background behind and around the text, presumably to show off the 3D effect some more. During the early scene where Oogie Boogie's shadow over the moon transforms into a flock of bats, the wires holding up the bats (which were always previously visible) have been digitally erased. It's possible that other digital tweaks may have been made as well, but that's the only one that stood out to me.

The 1080p/MVC transfer on the Blu-ray 3D disc has been altered to a full-screen aspect ratio of 1.78:1, which is slightly cropped on the top and bottom in comparison to the pillarboxed 1.66:1 transfer of the 2D version. Purists may find this objectionable, but for all practical purposes, the new framing doesn't harm the composition noticeably. Although composed for 1.66:1, the photography was also protected for possible matting down to 1.85:1 in theaters.

The 3D conversion was very carefully and tastefully done. The 3D quality is pretty subtle for the most part. The majority of scenes have only moderate depth, and I didn't notice any pop-out effects that leap forward from the screen. Certain sequences that you might expect to really show off the 3D, such as the opening where the camera swoops through Halloween Town, are strangely some of the flattest of all. Static scenes tend to exhibit the most depth. Poor 3D conversions sometimes exhibit a warping effect that looks like a flat 2D image has merely been stretched and wrapped around a 3D object. I saw nothing like that here.

At its best, the 3D edition adds a palpable sense of layering to the image, such that you feel like you could step into the picture and interact with the environment. At its worst, the 3D is unobtrusive and hardly noticeable. Nonetheless, I was left with a feeling that the 3D was rarely needed. After finishing the movie, I went back and re-watched parts of the 2D edition, and found myself equally engaged by it and wrapped up in the story, if not more so. A nagging in the back of my mind keeps telling me that the conversion of old movies like this is a lot like the colorization of black & white films. I have no problem with modern 3D conversions like Tim Burton's 'Alice in Wonderland', so long as the movie was designed and intended for 3D all along. But 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' was never designed for 3D. This is a revision.

In any case, other attributes of the film's picture quality (colors, detail, etc.) are comparable to the previous 2D Blu-ray release, which looked pretty great. You can read that review for all the details. This is a different transfer, though. The aspect ratio has been changed, and other small differences exist. A few scenes, such as Sally's song around the 53-minute mark, are slightly grainier in the 3D transfer than in the 2D version. But these don't amount to much, and the overall impression is the same (aside from the 3D). Our star rating scores for 3D discs must take into consideration both the traditional picture quality attributes plus the 3D quality. For that reason, I'm knocking the composite score down half a point, primarily because the 3D effect is so modest.

The 2D disc in the set features the same 1.66:1 transfer as was previously issued on Blu-ray. The digital compression seems to have been re-encoded, presumably to accommodate some new trailers before the menu, but the results are visibly indistinguishable.

The Blu-ray 3D disc in the set has no bonus features at all. The standard 2D disc in the set carries over everything from the previous release.

• Introduction by Tim Burton (HD, 18 sec.) – Located on the disc only by selecting "Play" from the main menu, this is an extremely short introduction in which Burton makes note of how "incredible" he finds the Blu-ray edition. It lasts all of 18 seconds.
  
• Audio Commentary by Tim Burton, director Henry Selick, and music producer Danny Elfman – This track has been edited together from three separate recording sessions. Selick's participation sounds to have been culled from the commentary on the prior DVD. Nevertheless, this is an interesting listen with a lot of solid information about the making of the film. Elfman's comments about the music are particularly interesting. Burton has been hit-or-miss in past commentaries. He's pretty focused here, perhaps benefiting from his session being heavily edited.
  
• What's This? Jack's Haunted Mansion Holiday Tour – On Track Version (HD, 7 min.) – This promo for the theme park attraction based on the movie can be viewed either with or without a pop-up trivia track. The trivia jumps on and off the screen far too quickly. The exhibit itself looks kind of neat, but this short ad for it is pretty lame.
  
• What's This? Jack's Haunted Mansion Holiday Tour – Off Track Version (HD, 37 min.) – Much more interesting is this extended version of the promo, which incorporates numerous interviews from the Disneyland "Imagineers" explaining how they convert the traditional Haunted Mansion ride to a 'Nightmare Before Christmas' theme each year. (Note that the pop-up trivia is not available during the "Off Track" version.)
  
• Tim Burton's Original Poem (HD, 12 min.) – The poem that served as the inspiration for the film is narrated by Christopher Lee and illustrated with brand new animation based on Burton's original concept art. In this version of the story, Jack is much more of a Grinch-like character. This is a very cool feature.
  
• Frankenweenie (SD, 30 min.) – Tim Burton's 1984 short film stars Shelley Duvall and Daniel Stern as the parents of a young science whiz who brings his recently-deceased dog back to life through the miracle of electricity. The local townsfolk don't react well to the discovery. The black & white short is a little stilted in pacing, but is a clever tribute to 1930s classic horror films and demonstrates the promise of Burton's developing visual sensibilities. The Blu-ray contains the extended director's cut version of the film. The piece is preceded by a new video introduction in which Burton plugs his upcoming animated remake.
  
• Vincent (SD, 6 min.) – Another chestnut from the Disney archives, this early stop-motion animated short by Burton illustrates a poem narrated by Vincent Price. The influence on 'Nightmare Before Christmas' (as well as Burton's short-lived animated series 'Family Dog') is abundantly clear. In fact, keep an eye out at time codes 1:20 and 4:45 for a prototype version of Jack Skellington making his first appearance on celluloid.
  
• Deleted Storyboards (SD, 3 min.) – Storyboards for three deleted sequences (including an alternate ending) are presented with brief commentary by Burton explaining why they were dropped. All three scenes have temp music and dialogue (not by the main cast).
  
• Deleted Animated Sequences (SD, 5 min.) – Three scene extensions and one entirely new scene made it all the way through to completed animation but were eventually cut for time.
  
• The Making of Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas (SD, 25 min.) – A fascinating documentary that explains the stop-motion animation process and gives a good overview of Burton's designs, the music, storyboards, art direction, lighting, and how the puppets were manufactured. Unlike most "making of" featurettes available on home video, this one has some real substance to it and isn't just EPK filler material.
  
• Halloween Town – This section of the disc is devoted to still galleries filled with character designs and concept art, as well as some short animation test videos. The categories are: Jack; Sally; Oogie Boogie; Evil Scientist Igor; Lock, Shock & Barrel; and the Citizens of Halloween Town.
  
• Christmas Town – Designs and concept art for Santa and his Helpers.
  
• The Real World – More still galleries devoted to the poor townspeople Jack terrorizes with his Christmas shenanigans.
  
• Storyboard-to-Film Comparison (SD, 4 min.) – A breakdown of the Town Meeting sequence.
  
• Posters – A brief still gallery of five poster art designs.
  
• Trailers (SD, 4 min.) – One teaser and one full theatrical trailer. The teaser plays up the Disney tradition for innovation in animation and reveals that the film was originally planned for release under the Walt Disney Pictures banner.
  
• D-Box Motion Code (2D Disc Only) – Viewers with D-Box equipped furniture can load the disc into a PC drive to synchronize the shaking and jostling movements with the action on screen. The codes are also available for download from D-Box directly if you don't have a Blu-ray drive in your computer.
  
• DVD + DisneyFile Digital Copy – The third disc in the set provides a combination of DVD and portable video version of the movie. The Digital Copy is compatible with either Windows Media or iTunes. The file can be downloaded from the disc with an activation code provided in the packaging. (The DVD portion is new to this release. The previously Blu-ray had only a Digital Copy.)
  

Also included are some trailers for unrelated Disney titles.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are no exclusive features on this Blu-ray. In my earlier review, I had listed the introduction by Tim Burton in this section. However, since that feature has been recycled from the previous Blu-ray, I've moved it up to the main Supplements section.

The Cutting Room Floor: What Didn't Make the Blu-ray?

The Special Edition DVD from 2000 had an audio commentary by Henry Selick and cinematographer Pete Kozachik. Some of Selick's remarks were incorporated into the new group commentary, but many were not, and Kozachik was dropped entirely.

Back in the day, Disney released a deluxe Laserdisc box set for 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' that included some additional material that's never been seen again, such as a longer version of the "Making of" documentary (it ran 43 min.), some animated commercial bumpers and a short film that Selick made for MTV, and an even more extensive collection of still galleries. The Laserdisc also came packaged with a lovely hardcover book titled "Tim Burton's Nightmare Before Christmas: The Film, The Art, The Vision." The book shouldn't be too difficult to acquire separately, but it sure won't fit in this tiny Blu-ray case.