Blu-ray: Skip it
3.5 Stars out of 5
Sale Price $19.96
List Price $49.99
Buy Now
3rd Party $15.95
Usually ships in 24 hours
Release Date: October 26th, 2010
Movie Release Year: 2003
Release Country: United States
COLLAPSE INFO -

Elf: Ultimate Collector's Edition

Review Date November 16th, 2010 by
Overview - Buddy (Will Ferrell) is different from all of Santa's other elves. For one thing, he's "a cotton-headed ninny muggins" when it comes to making toys. For another, he's 6'3". And the real clincher: he's human! So one special December, Buddy sets off on a holiday adventure to New York City in quest of his real dad. How buddy finds his father (James Caan) and the meaning of Christmas is a joyous, jaunty, sweet-as-a-candy-cane gift for everyone who loves bright contemporary comedy - and timeless all-family classics.
  • Editors Note

    This contains portions of the review for the original 'Elf' Blu-ray, which is exactly the same as this edition, but without a cheap cookie tin.

OVERALL
Skip it
Leave A Comment
  • Editors Note

    This contains portions of the review for the original 'Elf' Blu-ray, which is exactly the same as this edition, but without a cheap cookie tin.

  • TECH SPECS & RELEASE DETAILS
    Technical Specs: Tin Packaging (with soundtrack sampler, stocking, gift tags, magnetic picture frame),BD-50 Blu-ray Disc,Region Free
    Video Resolution/Codec: 1080p/VC-1
    Length:95
    Release Country:United States
    Aspect Ratio(s):1.85:1
    English Descriptive Audio: English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround Sound,English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,German Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound
    Subtitles/Captions: English, Spanish, German
    Special Features: Audio commentaries
    Featurettes
    Trivia track
    Deleted scenes
    Karaoke
    Theatrical trailer
    Movie Studio: New Line Cinema
    Release Date: October 26th, 2010

Story Review Storyline: Our Reviewer's Take

4 Stars out of 5

Will Ferrell makes me weak in the knees. There, I said it. I know his tried-and-true schtick gets under some people’s skin, but I just can’t get enough. Whether he’s flailing across a racetrack covered in imaginary flames, rubbing his junx on his step-brother’s drums, or locking himself in battle with a rival news crew, the SNL alum makes me laugh every time he looks at the screen or injects a character with raging egomaniacism. I’ll be the first to admit he’s starred in a few disappointing duds (‘Bewitched’ and ‘Semi Pro’ anyone?), but for an actor who’s been criticized for playing the same character in every film, Ferrell continues to surprise me again and again.

When an orphaned baby boy crawls into a strange bag on Christmas Eve, he inadvertently earns a free trip to the arctic with an unsuspecting Saint Nick (Ed Asner). Once discovered at the North Pole, the human infant is adopted by a kindly elder elf named Papa (Bob Newhart) and raised to believe he too is an elf. Buddy (Will Ferrell), as the new larger-than average man-child comes to be called, grows up to work in Santa’s shop, but is soon told why he’s so different than his co-workers. While revealing his origin, Papa explains to Buddy that his real father, a wealthy publishing executive named Walter Hobbs (James Caan), is alive and well in New York City. Determined to reconnect with his own blood, Buddy heads to the Big Apple to investigate his roots. While in the city, Buddy must convince Walter of the truth, adjust to a new job in a department store, and win the affections of a fellow employee (Zooey Deschanel).

It would be easy to dismiss ‘Elf’ as a fairly formulaic family flick (which wouldn't be far from the truth), but to do so would be to overlook a holiday gem that manages to surpass the sappy conventions of its subgenre with quick wit, inventive physical comedy, and a slew of loveable characters. Ferrell’s Buddy is so naïve, that his interactions with new friends and situations is a constant source of comedic gold. Buddy’s encounters with a department store Santa, a diminutive author, and a warm-hearted arctic guide are effortless in their execution and thoroughly memorable in their delivery. I would even go so far as to say director Jon Favreau (‘Iron Man,’ ‘Zathura’) has made a near-perfect family film in that it will appeal to both children and adults. I couldn’t stop my son from bouncing up and down throughout the movie even though he’s probably too young to quite understand what was happening in the story. His excitement was infectious. I found myself laughing at the more involved humor in the film and even enjoying the more clichéd sight gags that sent him into fits of laughter.

The only time ‘Elf’ doesn’t feel like a breezy Christmas classic is when it has to wrap up every loose end in the third act and allow Buddy to emerge as a holiday hero to a variety of people. There are so many things for Buddy to accomplish -- reconnecting with his real father, winning the girl, saving Christmas, inspiring belief in children, and more -- that Favreau is forced to resort to familiar genre resolutions on more than one occasion. Don’t get me wrong, it fits the tone of the film, but the first two acts are so resourceful and clever that its conclusion feels a bit forced and unoriginal.

Even so, 'Elf' is the sort of holiday flick I’ll pull out again and again, so I can plop down on the couch with my son, and munch popcorn with him until the credits roll. Not only is the film one of Ferrell’s more reliable comedies, it manages to exude heart without feeling insincere or artificial in its unabashed love of the Christmas season. If your family is craving high-def holiday entertainment, you can’t go wrong with ‘Elf.’

The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats

A few weeks ago, Warner gave us the repackaged editions of Harry Potters three and four and now they're giving us just about the same thing with this new edition of 'Elf.' This is the exact same transfer and audio that was on the last disc. In fact, these are the exact same discs they've been selling ever since 'Elf' was brought to the format, only this time they've been packaged in a holiday themed collectible tin with some junky goodies inside, exactly the same thing they did with the "ultimate" editions of 'A Christmas Story' and 'Christmas Vacation.'

It's almost a waste to go through and describe the few trinkets here and there you'll get for purchasing a Blu-ray that wasn't redone or given any new special features, but here it goes. The new collectible tin is big, bulky and oddly-shaped. I know people love to display tins, but this one will really take up a lot of needless shelf space. Inside you'll find the same Blu-ray copy of 'Elf' that's always been sold. You'll find a cute little Buddy-style stocking to hang on your fireplace. Also included is an 'Elf' soundtrack sampler CD, a magnet frame for your fridge, and "To/From" gift stickers to put on presents once Christmas rolls around. That's it.

It's too bad that this is just a repackage edition, because 'Elf' really did need a new transfer to fix the ugly DNR that was used. Shameful or shameless, take your pick.

  • TECH SPECS & RELEASE DETAILS
    Technical Specs:
    Tin Packaging (with soundtrack sampler, stocking, gift tags, magnetic picture frame),BD-50 Blu-ray Disc,Region Free
    Video Resolution/Codec:
    1080p/VC-1
    Length:95
    Release Country:United States
    Aspect Ratio(s):
    1.85:1
    Audio Formats:
    English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround Sound,English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,German Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound
    Subtitles/Captions:
    English, Spanish, German
    Special Features:
    Audio commentaries
    Featurettes
    Trivia track
    Deleted scenes
    Karaoke
    Theatrical trailer
    Movie Studio: New Line Cinema
    Release Date: October 26th, 2010

Video Review

3 Stars out of 5

Bright, colorful, and oozing holiday spirit, ‘Elf’ features a 1080p/VC-1 transfer that renders the vibrant hues of the North Pole workshop and the vivid lights of the New York cityscape with ease. Not only is the palette strong and steady, contrast is spot on, and black levels are deep (albeit uneven at times). In fact, compared to the standard DVD, the film looks more stable, three dimensional, and sharp. Aside from a few questionably soft shots, fine detail is fairly crisp, textures are decent, and on-screen hair and stitching are pretty well defined. For the most part, the Blu-ray transfer also isn’t haunted by the significant artifacting, banding, and edge enhancement that frequently appeared on the DVD.

I’d like to say Warner’s transfer offers the best rendition of the film imaginable, but lingering problems hold this release back from perfection. Shadow delineation is inconsistent, a few night scenes are hindered by noise, and skintones occasionally appear flushed with reds and oranges. It also doesn’t help that brief bursts of artifacts and thin slivers of edge enhancement still pop up from time to time (although, to be fair, their appearances will only be noticed by the most discerning viewers). Worst of all, DNR is a definite and noticeable issue throughout. Ultimately, ‘Elf’ looks pretty good in its high definition debut, but some extra polish, a more natural picture, and another pass altogether would produce a more refined BD transfer.

Audio Review

3.5 Stars out of 5

Sidestepping the standard Dolby Digital pitfall that’s ensnared so many Warner releases of late, ‘Elf’ arrives on Blu-ray with a faithful, fairly impressive Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track that offers a slight upgrade from its DVD counterpart. While a few lines still get lost in the holiday hustle and bustle, dialogue is generally clean and well prioritized, LFE support is strong considering the tone of the film, and rear channel aggression is consistent enough to keep scenes in the department store sounding busy and alive. Immersion is hindered a bit by the film’s limited sound design, but once you get past the inherent nature of the comedy’s straight-forward sonics you should be more than pleased with the track’s smooth pans and convincing directionality.

Alas, family films and comedies rarely offer standout sound design and ‘Elf’ falls into both camps. Warner’s TrueHD mix is true to its source, but underwhelming when compared to other high-def releases on the market. As it stands, fans won’t find much to complain about, but audiophiles will wish the track had as much seasonal punch as the film’s best gags.

Special Features

3.5 Stars out of 5

The Blu-ray edition of ‘Elf’ features all of the significant content that appeared on New Line’s 2004 Infinifilm Edition DVD. While I was disappointed to find that the features are merely presented in standard definition, the supplemental package is quite extensive and loaded with content for adults and kids alike.

  • Audio Commentaries -- First up are a pair of informative audio commentaries, one with director Jon Favreau and a second with actor Will Ferrell. Both offer plenty of on-set anecdotes and production details, and each one seems genuinely pleased with the way the film turned out. I do wish Ferrell’s track was funnier and that both men sat down together to record a single, chattier track, but the existing commentaries add quite a bit of value to the Blu-ray’s supplemental package.
  • Production Featurettes (SD, 39 minutes) -- “Tag Along with Will Ferrell” follows the comedian on a typical day of shooting, “How They Made the North Pole” looks at the design and implementation of the arctic sets, “Lights Camera Puffin” examines the use of animation and special effects in the film, and “That’s a Wrap” explores the various post-production work and efforts of the filmmakers.
  • Kid-Friendly Featurettes (SD, 51 minutes) -- “Film School for Kids” is an entertaining and revealing behind-the-scenes documentary that never talks down to its declared demographic, “Kids on Christmas” introduces a group of kids who talk about aspects of the season, “Deck the Halls” focuses on extreme Christmas decorations and the people who cover their homes in holiday paraphernalia, “Santa Mania” looks at the big guy in red, and “Christmas in Tinseltown” introduces traditional Hollywood celebrations. Adults won’t get much out of these features unless they have their arm around a son or a daughter, but my kid (and, as a direct result, me as well) enjoyed every sugar-coated minute.
  • Deleted/Alternate Scenes (SD, 12 minutes) -- Eight cuts and extensions don’t amount to much material, but it’s an amusing collection that will give fans a few additional laughs.
  • Elf Karaoke -- A trio of Christmas songs, karaoke style.
  • Trivia Track -- A text based fact track about the holiday season, its associated myths, and the production.
  • Focus Points (SD) -- This interactive feature provides access to brief featurette clips and behind-the-scenes info any time an icon appears on screen. However, it's comprised mainly of repurposed material and doesn't come close to delivering the same experience as a PiP track.
  • Theatrical Trailer (HD, 2 minutes)

Final Thoughts

It's true that when Ken reviewed 'Elf' for the first time he gave it a recommendation. Here I can't give the Ultimate Edition that kind of praise. It's a repackage of the same old movie that could have really used a facelift today. Instead, Warner thought that if they packaged it with a cute stocking and a soundtrack sampler then we'd all of a sudden want to run out and buy this set. Not so fast. It isn't worth your money because there are no audio, video, or special feature upgrades whatsoever. Skip it or buy the cheaper original edition.

Sale Price $19.96
List Price $49.99
Buy Now
3rd Party $15.95
Usually ships in 24 hours
See what people are saying about this story or others
See Comments in Forum
  • Editors Note

    Portions of this review also appear in our coverage of Dunkirk on Blu-ray. This post features unique Vital Disc Stats, Video, and Final Thoughts sections.

  • TECH SPECS & RELEASE DETAILS
    Technical Specs:
    Tin Packaging (with soundtrack sampler, stocking, gift tags, magnetic picture frame),BD-50 Blu-ray Disc,Region Free
    Video Resolution/Codec:
    1080p/VC-1
    Length:95
    Release Country:United States
    Aspect Ratio(s):
    1.85:1
    Audio Formats:
    English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround Sound,English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound,German Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound
    Subtitles/Captions:
    English, Spanish, German
    Special Features:
    Audio commentaries
    Featurettes
    Trivia track
    Deleted scenes
    Karaoke
    Theatrical trailer
    Movie Studio: New Line Cinema
    Release Date: October 26th, 2010