Give it a Rent
3.5 stars
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3 Stars
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Give it a Rent

City Island

Street Date:
August 24th, 2010
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
August 23rd, 2010
Movie Release Year:
Starz/Anchor Bay
104 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Everyone has their secrets. Even though in many instances, confiding in our family is probably the safest prospect, we often find ourselves wanting our families to be the last people on earth to learn about some things. That's the case with the Rizzo family. They all have something they're hiding. Some secrets are embarrassing, others are life changing, but the clan is being torn apart because none of them will reveal what they're hiding.

Vince Rizzo (Andy Garcia) is a prison guard in New York. His family lives in a little fishing town in the Bronx called City Island. (Editor's Note: Mild spoilers to follow.) Vince is hiding something from his wife and family that he'd rather not discuss. No he's not having an affair, although that's what his wife thinks as he's sneaking around to "poker games" every night. Hardened New Yorker, Vince Rizzo, is dying to become an actor. He spends nights at an acting class, mimicking his hero Marlon Brando. He claims that his wife Joyce (Julianna Marguiles) simply won't understand why he wants to become an actor. She already gives him enough grief that he never finished college. Joyce is still smoking, even though the rest of the family thinks she quit. A funny running gag throughout the film is that everyone in the family smokes, but they don't want anyone knowing that they do.

The Rizzo family has a couple children. Vivian (Dominik García-Lorido) is a stripper and has been expelled from college. Obviously telling her parents that she takes off her clothes for money is out of the question. Perhaps, the funniest and most endearing secret is harbored in their young son Vince Jr. (Ezra Miller). To put it bluntly, Vince Jr. likes fat chicks. There's just no other way to say it. He's got a plus-sized fetish, and watching him try and find the perfect girl online is hilarious.

Secrets build upon secrets in this movie, in clever and humorous ways. I was impressed that 'City Island' didn't stoop to any clichéd misunderstandings. You can see this playing out the exact same way in real-life if your family was as high-strung and as insecure as the Rizzos are.

After Vince brings home a convict from prison, to take care of him, things begin to unravel. The secrets each character is holding begin to reveal themselves, crashing into each other. All of this culminates into an ending you can see coming from a mile away, and yet you're still surprised how it all plays out. What a perfect climax for a movie like this.

'City Island' isn't the perfect family comedy/drama, but it's filled with heart, real emotion, and genuine laughs. Finally, it's great to see Andy Garcia in something where he doesn't drive me crazy with cardboard acting. Everyone here is superb, the writing is quick-witted, and the narration of the plot – weaving in and out of everyone's secrets – is well constructed. 'City Island' is enjoyable on a variety of levels. I've got a secret to confess, I loved it.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

For this kind of film (low budget and low key), 'City Island' boasts a nice looking 1080p transfer in a VC-1 encode.

First off, you'll notice that detail is nicely rendered, giving the picture a great sense of depth and dimensionality. A few softer shots persist, normally during wider, scene-setters. Colors are vivid, especially as the camera pans over the colorful seaside village of City Island. Blues and various grays dominate the architecture of the beachfront homes. The shimmering blues of the harbor, jump off the screen. Skin tones are natural looking, even during darker scenes. Blacks are consistent, but never as deep as they could be. Noise is an occasional annoyance as white specks pop up from time to time. Nighttime scenes are, at times, rampant with blips and flecks.

Being a low budget film, I wasn't expecting much from this transfer. Thankfully, detail is well done and so are the wide variety of colors. 'City Island' looks good on Blu-ray. Not demo-quality, but it's a video presentation that you won't find much to complain about.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

'City Island' features a Dolby 5.1 PCM soundtrack. Since the movie is very talkative, obviously you will won't to know how the dialogue sounds. I'm glad to say that the dialogue here is superb, with even hushed tones and voices coming through the center channel clearly audible. As expected, there is little to no need for LFE, so the sub woofer stays fairly silent throughout. Also, surrounds leave a little to be desired, as crowded streets and bars fail to give off that surround sound ambiance that is present on truly engrossing tracks.

For what it is, 'City Island' features a serviceable soundtrack that produces clean dialogue, but little else. This isn't a soundtrack that will drag you into its own world, but at least the dialogue sounds nice and clear. That's all that really matters.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

  • Audio Commentary – Writer/ director Raymond De Felitta and Andy Garcia sit down to give us a full-length commentary on the film. De Felitta and Garcia have great chemistry and talk about how the film evolved and what went into getting in filmed. It's a light, breezy commentary track, which is a must listen if you're a fan of the film.
  • Dinner with the Rizzos (SD, 16 min.) – Part of the cast, along with De Felitta enjoy a meal together as they talk about the movie, the motivations of their characters, and a few memories about the filming.
  • Deleted Scenes (SD, 15 min.) – Eight deleted scenes are contained here. Some of them were rightfully deleted, but I would have liked to see the breakfast scene included in the final cut of the film. Oh well, at least you can see it here.
  • Trailer (HD, 2 min.) – The trailer is included.
  • HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

    There are no HD exclusives.

    Final Thoughts

    'City Island' was a nice surprise. I usually don't find Andy Garcia all that entertaining or even watchable, but he proved me wrong here. When given good material, he can do it. 'City Island' progresses thoughtfully and is full of humor all the way up until the predictable, yet wholly enjoyable ending. Anyone in the mood for a funny drama about the inner-workings of family life should give 'City Island' a rent. I'm only recommending a rental here, because I don't think that the movie really has replay value. It's great the first time around, but I'm not sure it will be something you'll revisit after that.

    Technical Specs

    • 25GB Blu-ray Disc

    Video Resolution/Codec

    • 1080p/VC-1

    Aspect Ratio(s)

    • 1.78:1

    Audio Formats

    • English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound


    • English SDH, Spanish


    • Audio Commentary with Writer/Producer/Director Raymond De Felitta and Producer/Actor Andy Garcia
    • “Dinner With The Rizzos” Featurette
    • Deleted Scenes
    • Theatrical Trailer

    Exclusive HD Content

    • Digital Copy

    All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

    Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

    Related reviews