Blu-ray
Give it a Rent
3.5 stars
List Price
$12.98
Amazon
$9.99 (23%)
3rd Party
$6.00
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4.5 Stars
Supplements
2 Stars
High-Def Extras
2 Stars
Bottom Line
Give it a Rent

Surrogates

Street Date:
January 26th, 2010
Reviewed by:
Drew Taylor
Review Date: 1
January 26th, 2010
Movie Release Year:
2009
Studio:
Disney/Buena Vista
Length:
88 Minutes
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

For most of his career, director Jonathan Mostow has done feature-length 'Twilight Zone' episodes. They hinge on a simple but irresistible hook. In 'Breakdown,' it's the question of – what happens when your car breaks down and your wife goes for help and never comes back? With 'U-571,' it was – what would happen if a bunch of Allies got caught on a Nazi submarine and nobody knew it? Even Mostow's biggest directing gig, 'Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines,' has a gloriously gloomy 'Twilight Zone' ending. (He even spent years developing the decidedly 'Twilight Zone'-y 'The Game,' before David Fincher ultimately got the job.) But with 'Surrogates,' Mostow has directed his first extended 'Outer Limits' episode.

Based on a comic book series by Robert Venditti and Brett Weldele, 'Surrogates' takes place in a futuristic world where people don't leave their houses. Instead, they control, via psychic connection, 'Surrogates' – life-size robots who look a lot like their human counterparts, except younger, sexier, more toned. The central conflict arises when a wealthy young man, the son of the industrialist who founded surrogacy, is murdered while plugged into his surrogate. Usually, surrogates can be killed without any harm coming to their "driver," but this killed both the driver and the surrogate. So, FBI Agent Tom Greer (Bruce Willis, looking incredibly bored) and his partner Agent Jennifer Peters (Radha Mitchell) are on the case. And soon, a fairly complex web of intrigue is set up, as they investigate militantly anti-surrogate human The Prophet (Ving Rhames) and the father of surrogacy himself, Dr. Lionel Canter (James Cromwell).

Willis is unplugged fairly early on and gets to spend the rest of the movie as a man in the real world, investigating a crime in a fantasy one. He doesn't have any robo-special powers, he's older, paunchier, greyer, and looked down upon by all the beautiful, gleaming automatons. It's an interesting dynamic, except Bruce looks like he's counting down the seconds until he collects his paycheck and buys himself a new plane or something.

While you might think the 'Surrogates' set up has some incredibly interesting philosophical underpinnings, you'd be right. What, exactly, is reality when everyone communicates through these channels? Who is more real – the human or the surrogate? What happens when we make ourselves into robotic superheroes? What of surrogate-on-surrogate violence? And then there's the gender politics of surrogacy, since, as we see early in the movie, a fat slob has a supple young woman surrogate. Well, all of these moral and philosophical conundrums are left on the back burner (or never addressed at all), instead focusing on giant car chases and an increasingly convoluted whodunit plot which ends in an appropriately eerie note, but one that isn't milked for all of its dramatic and thematic potential.

This is a real shame, both because the mechanics of the plot suggest so much more, and because Mostow, as an incredibly savvy conductor of above average genre material, really could have invested in the world in a fundamentally deeper way. As it stands, it's a kind of above-average sci-fi flick that isn't bad if you're out of rental ideas on a Friday night. But for the kind of deeper, more sophisticated genre piece you'd expect from director Mostow, well, you'll be disappointed. 'Surrogates' is a movie that has a whole host of ideas laid out before it but refuses to engage any of them in a real way. Instead, it's just a bland, vaguely futuristic world (you can tell it's the future because everyone has weird lighting fixtures in their homes and offices) populated by robots (really just bored actors acting like robots) and not much else.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The MPEG-4 AVC 1080p transfer on this disc (aspect ratio: 2.40:1) looks pretty great, even if 'Surrogates,' on the whole, isn't a very handsome-looking movie.

The 'Surrogates' world isn't one of oppressive darkness or of overwhelming color. Instead, scenes are sort of glowingly hued: the "human" sections of the town are warmer, with a more golden hue; while much of the "Surrogates" world has the steely cold blue hue of an early James Cameron movie. Plus, the movie is chock full of unconvincing visual effects, with digitals effects (there's a lightning effect that looks like it was lifted out of 'Ernest Goes to Jail'), prosthetic effects and the post-production de-aging techniques (as seen in 'Wolverine,' with the weirdly angelic Patrick Stewart) all looking even phonier in high definition.

All that said, the transfer still looks pretty good. Oliver Wood (the 'Bourne' films) shot the movie, which has all the sheen of a typically slick Hollywood action movie. Skin tones look good when they're supposed to (on humans) and waxy when they're not (on the surrogates), the level of detail and texture is spot-on, blacks are deep. The movie looks noticeably "clean," without much in the way of grain, and the only glaring technical issue is a few distracting instances of noise. Beyond that, it's bug free.

Overall, it's a strong presentation of a movie that was only okay-looking to begin with.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

More impressive is the meaty DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix. Even though a major complaint about the film that it dissolves into a series of boom-crash-bang action set pieces, those boom-crash-bang action set pieces are brought to vivid life here.

The mix is immersive and atmospheric in quieter scenes, with dialogue crisp, clear and well prioritized. But all of this makes way for full-on, surround-sound shake the couch theatrics later on. There's a scene where a helicopter crashes and it's one of the more bombastic action sequences I've heard on Blu-ray. Elsewhere, the surround mix envelops you, as cars zoom across screen and secret plots are uncovered.

What's nice about this mix is that even the quieter scenes (which, granted, are few and far between) are awarded the same intense precision as the muscular action sequences. Some may feel the sheer outrageousness of the louder scenes overwhelms the quieter ones, but I disagree. This is a perfectly modulated mix, through and through.

Additionally, audio in French Dolby Digital 5.1 and Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 are included, as well as subtitles in English SDH, French, and Spanish.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

There are a fair number of special features on this disc, but very few of them are interesting or worth your attention.

  • Audio Commentary with Director Jonathan Mostow This track is actually fairly strong and engaging, with Mostow proving to be an exuberant and intelligent tour guide through the world of 'Surrogates,' providing a great deal of insight into the development and execution of the movie. It's just a shame, really, that he wasted his energy and considerable talent on a movie so half-baked. Still, if you liked the movie, you should definitely listen to this. Come to think of it, even if you didn't completely like the movie, this is still a worthy track.
  • Breaking Benjamin, "I Will Not Bow" Music Video (HD, 3:49) This is an awful song and an equally awful video.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are also a few HD-exclusive special features but, again, not a lot of note.

  • A More Perfect You: The Science of Surrogates (HD, 15:08) This brief documentary takes a look at the supposed 'Surrogates' world, with talking head interviews featuring most of the cast and crew, as well as specialists studying in the area of robotics. This may sound more interesting than it actually is, which isn't all that interesting. Still, you get to see some Japanese guy who has made a literal surrogate of himself, which is pretty freaky and weird. Also, we get to hear briefly from the great guys at the KNB Effects house, who did a lot of the makeup. Those guys rule. Otherwise, you can skip this baby.
  • Breaking the Frame: A Graphic Novel Comes to Life (HD, 6:30) This documentary, even shorter, features interviews with the creators of the comic book series that 'Surrogates' was based on – Robert Venditti and Brett Weldele. You also get to see a lot of the artwork from the comic book, which is considerably more dynamic than anything seen in the movie (the comic had a cool villain named Steeplejack too!) The 'noir' aspect of the story seems to have been played up in the comic book more, with Willis' character being a haunted private eye instead of a bland FBI agent. Ah, Hollywood. Is there anything you can't ruin?
  • Deleted Scenes (HD, 5:15) Some deleted scenes that try to flesh out the 'Surrogates' world but are, truthfully, pretty forgettable. Skip.

Final Thoughts

'Surrogates' offers just enough intrigue (and a genuinely gonzo performance by Ving Rhames) to give it a rental recommendation. The video is pretty good for a film that isn't all that striking visually, it's got a really great audio track, and a few extras that aren't all that interesting. Those looking for the bold science fiction fun of previous Bruce Willis outings like '12 Monkeys' or 'The Fifth Element' will be disappointed. Everyone else who is bored and wants an above-average episode of 'Outer Limits,' well, you've come to the right place.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Blu-ray Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English: DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
  • French: Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Spanish: Dolby Digital 5.1

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH, French, Spanish

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary with Jonathan Mostow
  • A More Perfect You: The Science of Surrogates
  • Breaking the Frame: A Graphic Novel Comes to Life
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Music Video

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$12.98
Amazon
$9.99 (23%)
3rd Party
$6.00
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»

Related reviews