Blu-ray News and Reviews | High Def Digest
Film & TV All News Blu-Ray Reviews Release Dates News Pre-orders 4K Ultra HD Reviews Release Dates News Pre-orders Gear Reviews News Home Theater 101 Best Gear Film & TV
Blu-Ray : Recommended
Sale Price: $7.83 Last Price: $ Buy now! 3rd Party 3.66 In Stock
Release Date: March 24th, 2009 Movie Release Year: 2009

Watchmen: Tales of Black Freighter & Under the Hood

Overview -

Contains two full features: "Tales of Black Freighter," and "Under the Hood"

Rating Breakdown
Tech Specs & Release Details
Technical Specs:
Region All
Video Resolution/Codec:
Aspect Ratio(s):
Audio Formats:
English Dolby Digital 5.1
English SDH
Special Features:
Release Date:
March 24th, 2009

Storyline: Our Reviewer's Take


If masked vigilantes and super powers existed in the real world, what would the comic books then be? Artificial adventures or dramatizations of real life heroes and villains, compilations of real heroes whose exploits are still fiction, or tales of themes long gone, though still riveting and mysterious? Alan Moore's subversive and innovative tale of a flawed world inhabited by flawed (read: more realistic) heroes needed a counterpoint, something to draw comparisons to the world in which we live, and what better way for a comic to show a world much like ours, than to have its youths idolize and dream over fictional characters and tales of heroics, rather than the costumed heroes that may already be ingrained in their minds, present for every waking minute of their lives?

'Tales of the Black Freighter' is the comic book within the comic book, the tale within the tale. After an attack on his ship, the Captain (voiced by Gerard Butler) is thrown out to sea, the corpses of his crew mates littering the water. Washing ashore on a small island, he is troubled with the thought of his wife and children being attacked by the same pirates who destroyed his ship, those aboard the Black Freighter, the thought instilled in him by the corpse of one of his dead crew members. He must build a raft, and survive the journey home, though his greatest obstacle is his own wavering sanity.

Originally planned to be filmed using real actors, using the same technique as "Watchmen' director Zack Snyder's previous film, '300,' the idea was scrapped due to budgetary and run time concerns, and has instead been crafted into a short animated piece, and while the thought of seeing this tale in live action makes me salivate beyond belief, what we are given instead is far better than most consolation prizes out there.

'Tales of the Black Freighter' is as dark as they come, an analyzation of the human psyche and what it takes to drive a man insane. The thought of losing one's entire family, with no ability to stop it, is certainly a motivating force that can undermine the sanity of most men, especially those surrounded by death and decay. The way it plays out is golden, the actions taken by the Captain are very realistic for his situation, the byproduct of what he feels has already happened, the equal and opposite reaction to the action he has perceived.

The 'Black Freighter' itself, a pirate ship much like the more recognizable Black Pearl from the 'Pirates of the Caribbean' series, is a fantastic embodiment of the dark and cruel possibilities that the world may bring, manned by embodiments of evil and death (much like the Pearl), a foreboding doom like a cancer or plague. The fact that this entire story line directly parallels one found in the actual 'Watchmen' tale is just the icing on the cake, something like a dark prediction for the future.

Short (clocking in at a mere 25 minutes) and ever so sweet, 'Tales of the Black Freighter' is more than just a beautiful companion piece, it is a work of art with a touch of black humor that's sure to infect its viewers (or readers) with a sense of despair. Definitely not for children, or the weak of stomach.

Video Review


'Watchmen: Tales of the Black Freighter' arrives on Blu-ray in a 1080P, VC-1 encoded transfer, and it looks quite nice, though it's limited by it's own aesthetic.

The striking colors only band slightly, despite the existence of countless shades of crimson fading overhead and underfoot throughout the feature, bearing great depth, popping right off the screen. Reds replicate beautifully, whites are bright but realistic. Detail is restrained by the inexpensive two dimensional animation design, with somewhat thick lines detailing characters, while not giving much room for finer features. On the downside, there were quite a few jagged lines to be found, and aliasing is evident on occasion.

Audio Review


The audio for 'Tales of the Black Freighter defaults to a lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, and since the feature plays without menu prompt, it's easy to forget to switch the track over to the lossless Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix that is quite respectable.

Surrounds are active and alive (more so than the victims of the Black Freighter), from the very start, with flames roaring and crackling all around. Ambiance is present with some great water splashes against the raft once at sea. Directionality is great, with the bow of the ship cracking and falling across the room, waves crashing right at you, and wind sweeping to and fro, while rain fills the entire room in the few scenes present. The bass has a nice understated presence, accenting the feature rather than defining it, though the cannon fire sequence has an excellent thud. Gerard Butler's narration is clear over every element, raising in volume appropriately, raising in severity along with any moment of increased score presence.

Special Features

  • Under the Hood (HD, 37 min) - A feature longer than the headliner of this release, which can be considered part of the movie portion rather than just an extra. This mockumentary is yet another piece of the 'Watchmen' tale that didn't quite make it into the movie, though, like 'Freighter,' it is alluded to quite a few times. Under the Hood is a mock television news program (The Culpeper Minute), replete with commercials, that discusses the origins of the heroes (and their predecessors) found in the film, via an interview with the author, Hollis Mason, the original Night Owl. This feature has a wonderful commentary on the infectious nature of the sensational, how there were no heroes one year, yet entire groups of them in under a year. Under the Hood is presented in the 1.33:1 ratio, with an obvious feel imitating classic television. Dirt and scratching are prevalent, as are vertical moving lines and a hefty grain. Colors are exaggerated, blacks are intentionally lame, creating a soft and fuzzy level of detail. The audio will default to the lossy track if you immediately switch features on the menu, but if you watch 'Tales of the Black Freighter' with the DolbyTrueHD mix, it will be the default for this feature as well. There isn't much to say for the audio, which has an extensively front heavy mix to mimic the old fashioned television reports, dumbed down and intentionally dirtied up in the same fashion as the video.
  • Story within a Story: The Books of Watchmen (HD, 25 min) - The cast and crew, along with many DC luminaries, discuss the sub-stories from the graphic novel, ranging from the ideas of stories within the story, how they make sense in the world of the Watchmen, to an analysis of the characters involved in these tales. The importance of Under the Hood is shown in great deal here, explaining why it is even the slightest bit relevant. A very strong feature that will help make sense of these side stories to those who just don't get it.
  • Watchmen Motion Comic, Chapter One (HD, 25 min) - The first part of the Motion Comic release can be found in the extras here. A nice bit of advertising, and a great way to sample the style of the release before purchasing it.
  • A First Look at Green Lantern (SD, 10 min) - A sneak peek at the Green Lantern DC animated feature. I've always found the character to be an interesting one, with some amazing positives and ridiculous negatives, and he's one of the first superhero characters that I got into. The history of the character is given much thought, including the era he was created in. The full length feature is available in stores now, so this feature/commercial is already incredibly outdated.
  • Digital Copy - A digital copy is included on disc two. Newer pressings of this release do not include this second disc, or the slipcover that came with first pressings.

There's a tale or two within the tale of 'Watchmen,' and they're just as interesting and relevant as the main piece. Fans already know that the upcoming double dip on the 'Watchmen' will include 'Tales of the Black Freighter' in the main feature, but for those who want to keep it separate, this is a great release, with solid extras (even if you don't consider 'Under the Hood' an extra like I do), and great audio and video qualities. Recommended.

All disc reviews at High-Def DVD Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.