Blu-ray
Give it a Rent
2.5 stars
Overall Grade
2.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
1.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
3 Stars
HD Audio Quality
2.5 Stars
Supplements
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Give it a Rent

The Jane Austen Book Club

Street Date:
February 5th, 2008
Reviewed by:
Peter Bracke
Review Date: 1
February 7th, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2007
Studio:
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
Length:
106 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

I have a simple test I use to judge any good chick-flick: Would I want to spend an afternoon at Starbucks with its main characters, sipping lattes and discussing Jane Austen? Seriously, likable protagonists are all that make most precious, self-absorbed weepies bearable, and daydreaming about imaginary conversations with imaginary people has gotten me through many a review screening. So the irony of using my chick-flick test on 'The Jane Austen Book Club' was not lost on me -- what an perfectly ideal match this was going to be! A modern romantic comedy about a multi-generational group of women, all Jane Austen lovers, sitting with me for two hours, discussing our favorite author? Fire up the cappuccino machine, baby!

My enthusiasm lasted for about the first fifteen minutes. What an utterly insufferable, thoroughly unbearable mawk-fest 'The Jane Austen Book Club' turns out to be. This is the kind of movie where all of the characters are so whiny, selfish, and generally unpleasant that you wish it was really a horror movie, so a masked maniac could appear and begin offing them, one by one. I'm already writing my own sequel -- 'The Stephen King Book Club.'

Adapted from the more impressionistic novel by Karen Joy Fowler, the film version takes an intriguing concept and dulls all the rough edges, creating the equivalent of a dumbed-down TV movie. The concept remains the same -- an interconnecting tale of five women and one man (who is -- shockingly -- not gay), all suffering through relationship woes, who decide to form their own monthly Jane Austen book club to help them get through their troubles. Yes, this movie really is that obvious, that contrived, and that shameless in milking the author's six classic novels in the worst kind of post-modern grave-robbing.

See if you can spot the Austen novels that have been cribbed. First there's Jocelyn (Maria Bello), a supposedly happily-unmarried dog owner who is playing cupid with two other members of the club, the newly-divorced Sylvia (Amy Brenneman) and the cheerful Austen-newbie Grigg (Hugh Dancy), but of course Jocelyn is repressing her own attraction to the young suitor (shades of "Emma," perhaps?) Then there is Prudie (Emily Blunt), aka Anne from "Persuasion," though separated from her Captain Wentworth not by class but by sports of all things -- he's basketball-loving jock while she's a meek bookworm -- she strikes up an affair with a randy high schooler (Kevin Zegers). Finally, there's Allegra (Maggie Grace, getting the short thrift in terms of screen time), the lesbian daughter of Sylvia, who seems to be channeling a little bit of "Pride & Prejudice" with her attempts to carve out a meaningful relationship in a world of stealth homophobia.

I'm not sure what I hated the most about 'The Jane Austen Book Club.' Perhaps it was the endless name-dropping and references to famous characters in Austen's books, done in that obnoxious, self-serving way in which you overhear insecure blowhards discussing fine art at museums? Or the bizarre use of multiple-perspective narration, so we are allowed to get "inside the heads" of all the characters in the most coy and obvious way imaginable? Or maybe it was the way each "quirky" character has a basic romantic predicament that mirrors the plot of a famous Austen novel? These narrative conceits are oh-so-cute, but oh-so-not-clever. This is the kind of obvious, heavy-handed screenwriting they teach you to avoid in film school. Even Oprah would gag.

'The Jane Austen Book Club' is also a visually clunky affair. Unlike films that transcend the dreaded "chick-flick" tag, such as 'The Devil Wears Prada' and 'Bridget Jones's Diary,' there is little sense of flair or pizzazz to the photography or editing. Granted, the nature of the material is akin to watching a bunch of people at an AA meeting (I lost count of the number of scenes of characters siting in chairs, pontificating about literature), but even director Robin Swicord's directorial choices (mostly involving placing her good-looking actors in front of good-looking backdrops) do little to stir the imagination. There just isn't any real creative spark here.

Is there anything to recommend about 'The Jane Austen Book Club?' Yes -- Emily Blunt. This underrated, evolving actress first came to the attention of American audiences with her scene-stealing turn in 'The Devil Wears Prada,' and she again steals every scene here. She is the only one in the ensemble who is able to elevate her one-dimensional character to something recognizable and relatable, and she becomes the film's de facto lead by sheer force of her charisma. Sadly, however, even Blunt can't save a film that never comes to life on its own. You're better off going to your local library and picking up an Austen novel than sitting through 'The Jane Austen Book Club.'

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

Sony presents 'The Jane Austen Book Club' in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video, framed at 1.85:1. Unfortunately, I wasn't a fan of the weird, washed-out look of the transfer, and I'd say this is one of the weakest efforts from Sony I've seen in a while.

Right off the bat, contrast just doesn't look right. The high end of the scale is too dull, and the mid-range is stretched out, leaving the whole affair is as flat as styrofoam. Colors are likewise either bland, or slightly overpumped (particularly fleshtones), so the transfer somehow manages to look both over- and under-saturated (quite an accomplishment). Detail and depth to the image are simply mediocre, at least for a new release. The image never boasts the kind of visible fine texture of the best high-def. There is also a bit of noise present here or there (though no major artifacts). At least the source is pristine, but that's about the best I can say about this one. A disappointment.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

'The Jane Austen Book Club' features Dolby TrueHD tracks in English and French (both 48kHz/24-bit), plus Spanish, Portuguese and Thai Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround dubs (448kbps). Unfortunately, the TrueHD audio is little better than the weak video. I'm not superstitious, but is 'The Jane Austen Book Club' cursed!?

The big culprit is the lousy volume levels on the dialogue. I had to jack up the volume just to hear much of the mumbly voices, which meant that whenever one of the annoying lite-pop/rock songs jumped on the soundtrack, I felt as if I was being aurally beaten. It's really irritating. The rest of the presentation is likewise uninspired. Surround use is meager at best, with little activity in the rears aside from a little score bleed but not much else. Dynamics are nothing to write home about (granted, this is a chick-flick), with not much oomph to highs and lows, nor much in the way of noticeable subwoofer action. Had the dialogue levels at least been normalized I could have tolerated the bland sound design, but combined, 'The Jane Austen Book Club' is hardly a sonic delight.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

For a film that was not a box office hit, 'The Jane Austen Book Club' gets a pretty extensive batch of supplements. Sony has not skimped on the features here in terms of quantity, so fans of the movie should be pleased. (All of the video-based extras are presented in 480p/i/MPEG-2 video only. Subtitle options on all of the extras [including the audio commentary] are Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Korean, and Thai.)

  • Audio Commentary - This screen-specific group chat is quite a party, featuring writer/director Robin Swicord, editor Maryann Brandon, producer Julie Lynn, and stars Hugh Dancy and Maggie Grace. The track is actually what the movie wishes it were -- funny, charming and entertaining. The pace is rapid fire, with the partcipants struggling to get their words in at times, but the info is extensive, covering everything from the low budget to the use of "quirky" music, to various cameos by friends and family of the filmmakers. I don't think this track is worth a listen if you're not a fan of the film, but it's certainly the best extra on the disc.
  • Featurette: "Behind the Scenes of 'The Jane Austen Book Club'" (SD, 18 minutes) - This formulaic featurette is far too promotional. We get glossy on-set interviews with all the main cast and crew, and tons of film clips and plot recap. Only worth a watch if you haven't actually seen the film.
  • Featurette: "The Real Jane Austen" (SD, 21 minutes) - The best of the featurettes, this is a straightforward if informative history lesson on the life of the famous author. Swicord is joined by Austen historians Joan Klingel Ray and Claire Bellanti (founder of the Jane Austen Historical Society), and if they are a bit talky, there are enough rare archival stills and location footage to keep the pace from lagging. Diehard Austen scholars will not discover anything here that they don't already know, but all-in-all it's a nice primer.
  • Featurette: "The Book Club Deconstructed" (SD, 12 minutes) - Boy, is this pretentious. Swicord returns for what is essentially a one-on-one interview where she details the creative decision-making she made in adapting the original Karen Joy Fowler novel for the screen. Unfortunately, Swicord is completely serious about her "process," and rarely does she cut beneath the obvious -- it's like a narrated digest version of the movie, complete with film clips. If you've listened to the commentary, you can skip this one.
  • Featurette: "Walking the Red Carpet " (SD, 3 minutes) - Not really a featurette, this is just three minutes of red carpet EPK interviews with the cast and crew, saying how great it is.
  • Deleted Scenes (SD, 7 minutes) - There are seven scenes in all, but they are mere extensions (and quite short, too). There's nothing here beyond random extra character bits (and a steamy little lesbian kiss) that add next to nothing to the movie. There is also no optional commentary or descriptive text to give the scenes context.
  • Theatrical Trailers (HD) - Rounding it out are full high-def trailers for the Sony Blu-ray releases 'Across The Universe,' 'Catch & Release,' and 'Saawariya,' plus the current theatrical releases 'Persepolis' and 'The Other Boleyn Girl.'

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are no high-def exclusives.

Final Thoughts

'The Jane Austen Book Club' is a film whose title says it all -- it's just a bunch of annoying characters sitting around and discussing famous literature, all the while whining about their own vapid lives. The whole thing just made me want to turn off the Blu-ray player and go read a Jane Austen novel. This disc is pretty marginal as well, with disappointing video and audio. At least the supplements are fairly extensive for this type of release, but it's not enough to really recommend 'The Jane Austen Book Club.' Rent this one only if you're a real glutton for chick-flick punishment.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc
  • Region A/B/C

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4
  • 1080i/480p/i/MPEG-2 (Supplements Only)

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.78:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit)
  • French Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit)
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (448kbps)
  • Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (448kbps)
  • Thai Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (448kbps)

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • English Subtitles
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles
  • Portuguese Subtitles
  • Chinese Subtitles
  • Korean Subtitles
  • Thai Subtitles

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Featurettes
  • Deleted Scenes

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Related reviews