The Simpsons Movie
- Street Date:
- December 18th, 2007
- Reviewed by:
- Peter Bracke
- Review Date: 1
- December 16th, 2007
- Movie Release Year:
- Fox Home Entertainment
- 87 Minutes
- MPAA Rating:
- Rated PG-13
- Release Country
- United States
The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take
The odds seemed to be against 'The Simpsons Movie' from the start. Years in development, the script for the movie went through a reported hundred-plus drafts and so many different concepts and iterations that even its creators publicly stated that it might never see the light of cinema screens. On top of that, the television series has been running for nearly twenty years now, and even its biggest fans will admit that its glory days are over. So what were the chances that audiences would pony up to see Homer, Bart and the rest of the Simpson clan on the big screen, when most weren't even bothering to watch them on TV for free?
Turns out, there plenty of people who still care about The Simpsons. Their long-in-gestation epic finally roared into theaters this past summer, and it was an unqualified blockbuster. With grosses that took even Simpsons creator Matt Groening and Fox executives by surprise, the film has raked in over half a billion dollars worldwide, and still counting. Anyone concerned that Homer might have run out of dough for those donuts need not have worried.
Still, despite the film's success, I have to wonder if the audience appeal of 'The Simpsons Movie' was simply the thrill of finally seeing such iconic, beloved characters on the big screen. Indeed, it's almost impossible not to smile while seeing a bright, shiny Simpsons logo flash by in panoramic widescreen dimensions, as the familiar strains of the theme song burst forth in Dolby surround. But watching the film for the second time now on Blu-ray, I've come to the harsh realization that for much of its thrifty 87-minute runtime, 'The Simpsons Movie' feels like little more than an overlong episode of the TV show.
Make no mistake -- there is an actual plot, and it's quite global in scope. After Homer accidentally pollutes the Springfield's water supply, the town is encased in a gigantic dome by the Environmental Protection Agency (yes, Al Gore and Arnold Schwarzenegger are involved, and even Green Day, too). The Simpsons are soon declared fugitives by EPA head Russ Cargill, so Homer hatches a plan to move the family to the more family-friendly confines of Alaska. But when Cargill pronounces Springfield salvageable, and schedules it for destruction, Homer, Bart, Marge, Lisa and Maggie must go on a rescue mission to save Springfield and, potentially, the entire planet.
The story of 'The Simpsons Movie,' like any episode of the show, is really just an excuse to string along a host of pop culture references. It's always been a hit-or-miss affair, with one's enjoyment of any particular gag depending on how well the writer's allusions happen to connect. Happily, the success ratio is quite high here. I laughed throughout the movie -- often heartily -- even at the lamer material. (At one point, the movie even parodies 'Titanic' -- ten years after the fact.) If the filmmakers tamper not one iota with the established formula, at least they give the audience exactly what they want.
Unfortunately, at the same time that makes 'The Simpsons Movie' an entirely safe proposition. Too safe, in my opinion. Aside from the PG-13 rating (which allows Groening and company to give us slightly "racier" fare, including lots of jokes about pedophilia), I found the movie's overall lack of ambition disappointing. Where the makers of, say, the "South Park" movie really pushed beyond the boundaries of what they could say on TV, as well as toying with a more creative narrative structure, 'The Simpsons Movie' doesn't take any such risks. For a show that's long prided itself on skewering everyone and everything (including itself), you'd hope for a more self-aware, post-modern vibrancy -- it's almost as if the makers were so exhausted by developing the movie for so many years that they forgot to consider what the point was in taking the show to the big screen in the first place.
Still, if you're a Simpsons fan, there is absolutely no reason not to see this movie. It's a testament to the show's unique sensibilities and the amazing resiliency of its characters that watching Homer and Bart on the big screen elicits such emotion. They may be animated, but they are now firmly and irreplaceably a part of our shared American pop culture family, so it's impossible not to cheer their first trip to the big screen. 'The Simpsons Movie' may not be all that it could have been, but it's certainly a fun way to spend 87 minutes.
The Video: Sizing Up the Picture
I have to admit walking into this one with relatively low expectations. Visually speaking, "The Simpsons" is certainly a step up from "South Park," but let's face it -- the TV show is a far cry from Pixar. However, the creative team behind the 'The Simpsons Movie' clearly put a lot of effort into upgrading the show's visuals for the big screen, and the results are often downright eye-popping. Likewise, this Blu-ray presentation looks way better than I expected it to.
Fox presents 'The Simpsons Movie' in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 video. The most striking aspect of the presentation is certainly the colors. Hues are wonderfully vivid and smooth, with bold uses of primaries and subtle shadings and gradients that far exceed anything seen on the TV series. As you would expect, the source is immaculate, with not a whiff of grain or any other imperfections. Blacks are rock solid, with contrast expertly modulated across the entire grayscale. This image really pops with depth and detail, and it's sharp as a tack. I was continually surprised at how three-dimensional it all looks -- even "dark" scenes have a richness of texture that's faultless. Finally, despite the bold animation style, I noticed no posterization or macroblocking.
I'm going to go out on a limb and award 'The Simpsons Movie' a five out of five stars for video. Not because I think this one replaces 'Ratatouille' as the greatest animated movie yet to hit high-def, but simply because I can't find a single thing wrong with this transfer. It appears to be a perfect representation of the source material, and you just can't get any better than that. So don't have a cow, okay man?
The Audio: Rating the Sound
The video quality of 'The Simpsons Movie' may have exceeded my expectations, but the audio doesn't offer any such surprises. Although this is a fine mix overall, the film's sound design is not nearly as creative as it might have been, and as a result this Blu-ray doesn't offer much in the way of a overwhelming aural experience.
Fox offers up another of their DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround tracks (48kHz/24-bit), and it certainly handles the source material with ease. This is a bright and bouncy mix, with the familiar Simpsons theme and score sounding punchier than ever before. There is not tremendous bleed to the rear channels, but it is nicely opened up from the small screen. There's also a fair use of discrete effects, but atmosphere is not consistently engaged so envelopment remains sporadic. Dialogue is very crisp and very nicely balanced. Dynamics don't overpower, but this mix certainly sounds clean across the entire frequency range, and there is even a little bit of oomph to the low end.
Again, don't expect to have your socks knocked off, but considering the content, this is a perfectly satisfying presentation.
The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff
'The Simpsons Movie' is hitting Blu-ray day-and-date with the standard-def DVD, with both releases receiving a matching set of extras. The good news is that Fox has bumped up the video on this Blu-ray edition to full 1080 high-def. The bad news is that despite the extra gloss, this assortment of throwaways feels like a bit of a rush job.
- Two Audio Commentaries - Normally, I list multiple commentaries separately, but since there's a lot of overlap between these two, I'm breaking
that rule. The first (and superior) track features series creators James L. Brooks and Matt Groening, writer/producers Al Jean and Mike Scully, director David
Silverman, plus stars Dan Castellaneta and Yeardley Smith, while the second track is dominated by production folk, including Silverman again, plus writers/producers Mike B.
Anderson, Steven Dean Moore and Rich Moore. Both tracks spend an inordinate amount of time discussing the approximately 152 different drafts and rewrites that the script went through on its very long journey from small screen to to the local cinema. It's all quite interesting during the first track (and the good-natured ribbing between the participants is very entertaining), but by the time I got to the more serious second track (which covers a good deal of the same ground), I couldn't help but tune out. The cool thing about the first commentary, too, is that it's pseudo-interactive, meaning that at various points in the track, Brooks and Groening will "pause" the flick (it turns black & white) to go over important points that otherwise would have been missed. Cute.
- Deleted Scenes (HD, 5 minutes) - Writer/producer Al Jean introduces seven scenes in all here (including an alternate ending), but as we learn in the commentaries, a great deal more was ultimately tossed out of the finished film. I can't help but wonder if the other scenes are being held back for the inevitable double dip, or whether they were just never finished (all of these are fully completed with final animation and sound). In any case, the scenes we do get are only mildly amusing, although Simpsons fans will certainly enjoy that favorites Patty and Selma make an appearance in one of the scenes.
- Special Stuff (HD, 4 minutes) - Wow -- a whopping four minutes of TV fluff and throwaway shorts. Here, you can enjoy excerpts of "Homer's Monologue on The Tonight Show" (2 minutes), and "Homer Introduces
American Idol"/"The Simpsons Judge American Idol" (less than 2 minutes combined), plus a twenty-second "Let’s All Go to the Lobby" parody of the classic intermission films that used to play at drive-in movie theaters.
- A Lot of Trailers (HD) - Rounding out the package are five spots -- four theatrical trailers, plus one teaser.
Thanks to our reader Alan T., we've discovered multiple eggs (so far) on 'The Simpsons Movie.' These are tricky to maneuver, so some trial and error may be required...
The first set of eggs can be found on the disc's pop-up menu. Once you've activated it, highlight the first option on the left, which is "Play Movie." Then hit down on your remote, and the command will underline. Hit enter, and be treated to the first of three "Visual Developments" vignettes, each for a different character -- Lisa's Boyfriend, Russ Cargill and the Multi-Eyed Fish. You can accessing the remaining vignettes by hitting the next two options on the pop-up menu ("Audio Setup" and "Special Features"). Highlight each, then hit left on your remote. Once the option is underlined, hit enter, and be taken to the respective vignette.
The last egg can be activated by going to the "Audio Setup" submenu, From there, select the "English DTS 5.1" option, but don't press enter. Instead, press up, and a donut icon will appear. Highlight it, then press enter to enjoy a 'Simpsons' spoof of the THX trailer.
Twenty years in the making, 'The Simpsons Movie' finally hit movie screens this past summer and was an unqualified blockbuster. Although the spectacle of the experience loses a bit of its luster when viewed again outside of an actual movie theater, there are certainly enough belly laughs here to satisfy any Simpsons fan. This Blu-ray is very nice in the technical department -- it looks as fantastic as a Simpsons movie possibly could, and the soundtrack isn't bad, either. The only real disappointment is the cobbled together supplements package, which screams "double dip." Otherwise, this is an easy recommend for Simpsons devotees and more casual fans of the series alike.
- BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc
- 1080p/AVC MPEG-4
- English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit)
- French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (448kbps)
- Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (448kbps)
- English SDH
- Audio Commentaries
- Deleted Scenes
- Animated Shorts
Exclusive HD Content
All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More
about our gear.
Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.