Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
4 stars
List Price
$19.99
Amazon
$11.99 (40%)
3rd Party
$6.15
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
5 Stars
Supplements
1.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
3 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Prometheus

Street Date:
October 9th, 2012
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
November 6th, 2012
Movie Release Year:
2012
Studio:
20th Century Fox
Length:
124 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated R
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Portions of this review also appear in our coverage of 'Prometheus - 3D.'

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

While I enjoy the first two 'Alien' movies, I'm no fanatic of the series. My opinion of 'Prometheus' is based solely on 'Prometheus.' If you still have not yet seen 'Prometheus,' rest assured knowing that my review is mostly spoiler-free. I will not explain the reveals.

Having seen the movie or not, if you know about 'Prometheus,' you know that it is a prequel – of sorts – to the 'Alien' franchise that Ridley Scott kicked off in 1979. The more you know about the 'Alien' movies, the more that you will see it as a prequel – but if you know nothing about the franchise, if you haven't seen a single of the 'Alien' or 'Alien vs. Predator' movies, you can still watch 'Prometheus' and follow it with ease. It carries the ability to function as a 100 percent stand-alone film. Not a single element of 'Prometheus' hinges on you knowing the 'Alien' movies – but the more you know about them, the more you'll enjoy revisiting the franchise from an angle you've never considered.

The first time I watched 'Prometheus,' I saw it functioning just as much as a remake as a prequel. The manner in which the story unfolds originally seemed similar to that of the first 'Alien,' but after four viewings (once theatrically on a standard 3D screen, another time on an IMAX 3D screen, on a standard 2D Blu-ray and also on Blu-ray 3D), I no longer view it that way. I have put a lot of thought into this film (especially after watching it four times and seeing all seven-plus-hours of special features that appear on the 3D Blu-ray release – not this one) and realized that it's a completely original formula with ties and imagery connecting it to 'Alien.' With each viewing, I learn something new about it, something that makes me appreciate it even more – so much more that I have been tempted to boost my original rating up to five stars. Perhaps I'll be inclined to do so on my fifth viewing.

Like all good science fiction, 'Prometheus' is a story about the morals of science. When science fiction films exploded in the early days of film, many of them were cautionary tales disguised at entertainment. Think about it. I'll use 'Godzilla' as an example. Think of what was going on at the time that Godzilla was made. Man invents the atomic bomb – this horrible weapon whose fallout is atrocious, immoral and inhumane. The radiation – something that scientists barely knew anything about at the time – resulted in mutations. This was taken to the far end of the spectrum in 'Godzilla,' the result being a monster of enormous size. Who created it? Man. What does it do? It destroys man. Science was scary in those days. It held unknown consequences. Many people thought that perhaps we were playing with something that we should not have been playing with.


While 'Prometheus' is an ensemble film led by Noomi Rapace's character Elizabeth Shaw, when you look at it in terms of themes, there are two groups of characters: Shaw and her boyfriend, and everyone else. The story of Shaw focuses on religion, creation, the beginnings of human life. In some ways, her story is like that of The Tower of Babel in the Old Testament. She's seeking God and just-so-happens to find a way to get to him – but we all know how well that turned out for the Babylonians.

The story that belongs to the remainder of the characters is brilliant. Peter Weyland (Guy Pearce), the old tycoon who is funding Shaw's deep space mission, has sent a few of his own employees along with Shaw and her boyfriend. The most important and interesting of them all is David (Michael Fassbender), a humanoid robot. (If you know the 'Alien' movies, then you know already know this type of character.) The story that David commands is not unlike that of 'Godzilla' – man, or a robot in this case, is toying with science, unsure of what the consequences will be. When these two stories collide, 'Prometheus' fires on all levels.

Four months after it's release, 'Prometheus' is still sitting pretty with a 74 percent Rotten Tomatoes rating – but it seems to be pretty polarizing between those who like it and those who do not. While it's apparent that more people like it than dislike it, those who dislike it really dislike it. A few of my family members and friends who I thought would love 'Prometheus' ended up hating it. A few who I thought would dislike it, wound up loving it. Knowing this, no matter how you perceive it prior to seeing, this is one of those films that you need to see for yourself because not a single person can judge how you're going to take it based on your taste and preferences. Considering how damn amazing this Blu-ray release is, you definitely deserve to give it a shot.


The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats

I may be wrong, but I believe that this is the first 3D Blu-ray release to feature a massive bonus disc that isn't included with the 2D release. Seeing a title get same-day basic and "special edition" Blu-ray releases isn't anything new, but so far as I know, this is the first time that a 3D Blu-ray release has been given an extra disc that's unavailable in the standard 2D Blu-ray packaging. In this instance, you pay for what you get and the $5 difference between the two releases is well worth it – but we'll get into that below.

The 2D Blu-ray release of 'Prometheus' consists of one Region A BD-50 and a dual DVD/Digital Copy disc found in an average blue Elite keepcase. The artwork for the 2D release is different from that of the 2D release (see below - the 3D release is on the left, 2D on the right). The same artwork is featured on the glossy, metallic and reflective cardboard slipcover.


The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer of 'Prometheus' is astounding, doing perfect justice to the film's beautiful style. If you find the visuals as breathtaking as I do, then get ready for your next demo disc.

The video quality is crisp, clear, sharp, and detailed. Textures abound, from the smooth movements of the life-destroying black oil to the slimy skin of a ginormous face-hugger. The skin-tight "away team" space suits that the crew wear contain defined texture. When wicked winds pelt the ship and crew with metallic rocks, you can clearly see each of the thousands of rocks that blast across the screen. From CG to practical images, details aren't an issue. Despite being set in mostly dark locations, through creative and well-planned lighting and rich black levels, these details don't waiver. There is always an object or a set of objects on-screen worth gazing at. This, of course, is due to the amount of clarity and sharpness within the image. The massive sets are elaborate, especially within the bridge of the juggernaut.

Compression errors don't arise either. Bands, aliasing, artifacts and digital noise are absent. Edge enhancement and DNR are not applied.

My only complaint with the Blu-ray release is a personal gripe. On IMAX screens, the frame was opened up from the standard theatrical 2.40:1 ratio to 2:1. Because 'Prometheus' is such an epic film on a grand scope, more is better. My wish is that at least one of the two 'Prometheus' Blu-rays would have featured the IMAX 2:1 ratio – but neither do.


The Audio: Rating the Sound

If I could give 'Prometheus'' 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track a rating higher than 5 stars, I would. Hearing it cranked up on a 7.1 system, I heard sounds that I never recognized during my theatrical viewings. The first time I screened 'Prometheus,' I was immediately reeled into the film by the beautiful score overlaying breathtaking landscapes during the opening credits. Hearing the score via this mix is just as wowing. It establishes a grand tone equal to that of the movie that you're about to see.

Once the film takes us into the flight deck of the Prometheus ship, the mixing of the effects makes itself apparent. The effects emitting from every channel are clearly audible. As quiet as some might be, you can easily hear them all - sensors beeping behind you, controls being toggled to the side of you, thrusters outside the ship causing a low bassy rumble. When we're taken to exterior shots of the ship cutting its way through the atmosphere, those same thrusters combined with the atmospheric friction create a deep and resonant LFE that will shake your theater room. One of my favorite sounds in the film is that of the LV-223 storm rolling in. The gusts blast small pieces of metallic rock through the air. As they collide with one another mid-flight, the high-pitch clanking sounds amazing. One thing that I never noticed until listening to this 7.1 mix was that when Prometheus lands on the surface of LV-223, the downward thrusters kick up that same metallic gravel and those same sounds can be heard.

The imaging effects of this mix are seamless and astounding. Take, for example, this same storm sequence. It's obvious that it was shot with the audio in mind because every shot of the storm shows the rocks blowing from left to right. Not a single frame shows it any other way. This causes the wind to relentlessly throw debris in that same direction. It's furious and never lets up. The non-stop left-to-right sound is unnerving. I found myself wanting the shot to switch angles just so that the left-to-right motion would let up. The level of detail put into these imaging sounds is phenomenal. It sounds as if you can literally track these individual blowing rocks from one side of the theater to the other – and there are hundreds, if not thousands, of them.

The vocal detail of this mix is also worth noting. The character that warrants the most attention vocally is David. Fassbender's voice resonates with a rich, deep bass. There's one effect applied to a certain character's voice that I'd like to explain to you, but I cannot because it would reveal a major plot point. (If you want to know, ask me in the forums.) Just like I did with the effects mixing, I heard vocals in the Blu-ray mix that I didn't know existed during my theatrical viewings. They say that no one can hear you scream in space; well, we can surely hear them scream on the surface of LV-223. I didn't hear the many screams Rapace and Charlize Theron let out throughout the film until now.

If you can't watch 'Prometheus' with the audio cranked up because the kids are in bed, don't watch it. This lossless 7.1 mix deserves to be heard as loudly as possible.


The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Disc 2 - DVD

  • Main Feature (SD)

  • Digital Copy

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Disc 1 – Blu-ray with 2D Main Feature

  • Commentary by Director/Producer Ridley Scott - One thing that I especially love about this release is that while most films steer clear of referencing and explaining the early versions of the screenplay, these features use them to explain how they ultimately lead to the evolution of the final product. Scott openly offers that information in this commentary, but it's also found throughout the rest of the special features. His commentary is strong, talking about every aspect of production, the challenges he and his crew faced, and even tosses in a few hints at connections to the other 'Alien' films. The only odd bit is where Scott goes off on a tangent about how we'd have terraforming in present day if Kennedy wasn't assassinated.

  • Commentary by Writer Jon Spaihts and Writer/Executive Producer Damon Lindelof - Considering Spaihts wrote the first few drafts of 'Prometheus' only to be replaced Lindelof, you'd think that a commentary containing the two would be strange – but both understand how necessary it was in the long run, so it never feels like there's a proverbial elephant in the room.

  • Deleted and Alternate Scenes (HD, 37 min.) - Having seen the drastic differences between Ridley Scott's Director's Cut and the studio-forced theatrical cut of 'Kingdom of Heaven,' I have learned that he only stamps something as having his cut of a film if it really enhances it. While rumors of a 'Prometheus' director's cut have spread since it opened theatrically, after seeing the 37 minutes of deleted and alternate scenes, I'm perfectly content with the theatrical cut. There are a total of 14 scenes in this feature. The option is presented to watch them individually or collectively and with or without the commentary from the film's editor and VFX supervisor. From the menu, if you scroll over the titles of these deleted scenes, a box will pop up explaining a brief synopsis of each scene. The scenes that I wish could have remained in the final cut include an extended opening scene with the sacrificial Engineer, David communicating with the awakened Engineer and a longer final battle with Shaw and the Engineer. The other 11 scenes are not all purely deleted or extended takes, but completely different versions of scenes that appear in the theatrical cut. The takes shown in the film were wisely chosen over their alternate versions that appear here. Most of those contained in this special feature change the tone of the film, the relationships between the characters or have the character react in ways that go against the character.


  • The Peter Weyland Files (HD, 19 min.) - If you watched the four viral videos that Fox released prior to the theatrical release of 'Prometheus,' you'll be glad to see that they made it onto the Blu-ray. "Play all" or watch individually, you can see 'Quiet Eye,' Shaw's plead for Weyland to fund their expedition; 'Happy Birthday, David,' the Weyland Corporation's infomercial for their human-like robot; 'Prometheus Transmission,' a long random bit of footage from the pre-mission crew; and 'Ted Conference, 2023,' where we see young Weyland's witty acceptance speech.

  • 'Prometheus' Mobile App - Although you can download the free Weyland Corporation app and view all of the additional content that it offers without having the Blu-ray, it's not nearly as cool without the Blu-ray interaction and functionality. This is the first of the "second screen" apps that I've ever played with. Most Blu-rays that possess this feature aren't ones that I'd care to dig deeper into (like 'Real Steel'). Being a 'Prometheus'-lover, I had to give it a shot. Using this app while watching the movie made me feel like Tom Cruise in 'Minority Report.' If your phone/tablet is connected to the same wireless network as your Blu-ray player, then the two auto-sync to create a fluid enhanced viewing experience. As the movie plays, the app shows you set photos, artwork, diagrams and clips that coordinate with what's on-screen. Each time you select to play a featured clip or deleted scene, the Blu-ray will automatically pause while you place you attention on your device. Like dragging the content from your tablet through the air to your television a la 'Minority Report,' some videos will play off the Blu-ray disc on your television instead of your phone. (Hint: if you were hoping for an extended cut of 'Prometheus,' this is the way that you can watch most the film with most of the deleted scenes added back into it.) I only had time to re-watch 35 minutes of 'Prometheus' with this app running, but what I experienced was pretty unique and I will see it through to the end. I suggest giving it shot while watching the film with a commentary track running. I wouldn't recommend using this for your first viewing of 'Prometheus.'


Final Thoughts

Here it is, folks – my new favorite demo disc. Watching the film itself is a journey that I wish I could take again for the first time. Upon reflection and analysis, it only gets better with each viewing. Sure, there are those who loathe 'Prometheus' – and I've carried on extensive debate-like conversations defending the arguments – but I stand by my opinion that this is one of the very best contemporary science fiction films, a more-than-worthy chapter in the 'Alien'-verse. The video and audio qualities are perfect, not a single flaw to be found. Both offer environmental enhancements that take you deeper into the world of the film than you can imagine. Although I personally prefer the 3D release – not only due to the great 3D main feature presentation, but because of the several extra hours of bonus features – if I was strapped for cash, didn't have access to a 3D set-up or didn't care for bonus features, this 2D set would still be worth it. Highly recommended.


Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray/DVD/Digital Copy
  • BD-50

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Russian Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Hindi Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Ukrainian Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Tamil Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Telugu Dolby Digital 5.1

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH, Spanish, Portuguese, Danish, Finnish, Hindi, Russian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Ukrainian, Norwegian, Estonian, Swedish

Supplements

  • DVD Copy
  • Digital Copy

Exclusive HD Content

  • Commentary by Director/Producer Ridley Scott
  • Commentary by Writer Jon Spaihts and Writer/Executive Producer Damon Lindelof
  • The Peter Weyland Files
  • Deleted and Alternate Scenes that include an Alternate Opening / Ending
  • Prometheus - Weyland Corp Archive Second Screen App

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$19.99
Amazon
$11.99 (40%)
3rd Party
$6.15
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»