Blu-ray
For Fans Only
4 stars
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
2.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
5 Stars
Supplements
2 Stars
High-Def Extras
3.5 Stars
Bottom Line
For Fans Only

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 3D

Street Date:
November 11th, 2011
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
November 14th, 2011
Movie Release Year:
2010
Studio:
Warner Bros
Length:
0 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Portions of this review also appear in our coverage of the 2D disc!

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

I enjoyed 'Half-Blood Prince' when it came out, but it always seemed like it was missing something. The movie felt anti-climatic and bogged down with too much teenage, wizarding angst. Too much soap opera stuff going on with the young Hogwarts students trying to find love in all the wrong places. Imagine my surprise when I found out that the sixth movie did indeed leave out a lot of the action that took place in the book. That's exactly what the movie was missing, and that's exactly what 'The Deathly Hallows: Part 1' makes up for.

Harry and his friends are now facing a very real threat of being killed by the Dark Lord. Voldemort is closing in on Harry's whereabouts, but Harry's colleagues are willing to help him try and escape. The sequence where Harry's friends drink Polyjuice Potion in order to turn into replicated Harry's is one of my favorite scenes of the entire series, and it really sets the tone for this seventh movie. It's light and humorous, but it's also the first time where the 'Harry Potter' films have actually made it feel like Harry and the people around him were in immediate danger.

Whatever action was missing from 'Half-Blood Prince' is well represented here. As Harry and his friends who now look like him fly through the air, the Death Eaters intercept them. Pluses of energy blast from wands as a wizarding dogfight takes place above London. It's a fun and intense scene. Director David Yates know his way around an action scene. Sure there are a lot of quick cuts, but it's still easy to see what's going on.

Harry has tasked himself with finding the remaining Horcruxes so he can destroy them and once and for all rid the world of Voldemort. He's joined by Ron and Hermione as they search for the items that hold bits of the Dark Lord's soul. They infiltrate the Ministry of Magic in a pulse-pounding scene that is one of the best 'Harry Potter' moments ever, and it doesn't even star the big three. They sip down some more Polyjuice Potion and sneak into the Ministry disguised as three adult employees. Watching these up-until-now unknown actors shuffle around the Ministry is simply hilarious.

Still, 'The Deathly Hallows: Part 1' does have a fault that many of the other movies have had. If you haven't read the books, you'll find yourself lost during many of the scenes. What is that shard of glass Harry keeps looking into? How did Harry know that he had to open the locket to destroy it if he never tried doing that when they were shooting it with their wands? Why isn't the Elder Wand protected at all? Why did Hermione erase her parents' memories? Why does Harry fly through a wall of an old house into a child's playroom? All of these questions and more, I'm sure can be answered by the books (although my wife assures me that the playroom scene is out-of-this-world weird, because it isn't in the books).

'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1' picks up where the sixth movie left us wanting. It's a magic-packed, action thrill ride with quite a few engaging action scenes. It's fraught with danger and destruction, and has done away with most of the doe-eyed teenage lovey-dovey stuff that almost ruined the last movie.

Vital Blu-ray Statistics

'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1' came to Blu-ray in two flavors, with a loaded three disc edition and a movie only version that skimps out even the first disc's worth of goodies. Now, to coincide with the release of the final film in the series, Warner is triple dipping this film, now with a bonus Blu-ray 3D disc, packaged in a fat pack four disc case along with the contents of the original loaded edition, under a lenticular slipcover. The new disc is a BD50, with no pre-menu content. All of the extras are on the 2D discs, and the Digital Copy off the old disc is replaced with a new UltraViolet edition.

For the time being, Best Buy stores across the country are the only retailer selling this disc. Better still, just two weeks after this set streets, the store will be including this exclusive in their Black Friday ad!

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Harry Potter and the Lack of Anything Happening Whatsoever: Part 1' arrives on Blu-ray 3D after being scrapped for theatrical release. That's always a good sign, when a 3D release is so half baked that they don't even try to make a buck on it theatrically. What's really shameful here isn't the fact that the 3D is mediocre, but that it's actually miles better than the 3D in the second part of this final chapter.

Now, don't get me wrong, this is still a pretty haphazard disc. The muddied, banded looking faces that are two toned with no gradient are still here, although they clear up as the film rolls on, while aliasing and jaggies on the arms of glasses or across the lengths of entire wands still remain. Random flatness, particularly on Mr. Lovegood, pops up from time to time, while there are more than a handful of shots that feature no 3D effect at all, including the awesomely animated Deathly Hallows sequence, which would have been a real stunner. Backgrounds are routinely blurry and non-destinct, and there are plenty of hard focus shots that leave backgrounds in even worse shape, if that were possible. Textures are the epitome of the word fail, while the number of dark sequences featuring little detail whatsoever are troublesome, again being a huge issue for any scene featuring Snape, who looks like his mortal enemy Bruce Willis due to the way his hair disappears frequently.

So, that all sounds pretty awful, right? The thing is, the bar was set so low, that what we have here still is appreciable. Ghosting does pop up here and there, but it's very infrequent, and never massively annoying or eye catching. Random shots have actually very workable, appreciable 3D, like the empty house Harry grew up in, as it really does sell the loneliness in that scene. The escape by flight sequence, as dark as it is, it works, really well, in 3D, and is clearly visible. Low lit sequences maintain visibility, unlike in the sequel/second film, even if non-lit shots still bite. The wedding party scene glows with the amount of added depth it receives, as it may be the highlight of this disc.

Look, I'm not happy with what we have here. I'm really not. I don't want to sound like I'm patting Warner on the back and telling them "good job, guys. Keep up the good work!," because, really, I'm beyond disappointed in both 'Harry Potter' 3D releases. I just want to make it clear: this is bad, it has little 3D pop, it has plenty of non-3D sequences, and it isn't all that great in 3D. It is still miles ahead of 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2: The Quest for More Money.'

The Audio: Rating the Sound

The video has what can be described as maybe a few minor, negligible faults, but the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 presentation is perfect on ever level. This is an engaging, immersive mix that sucks you right into the dark world of magic looming around Harry and his friends.

You'll notice right off the bat, as the rusted WB logo slowly floats forward on screen, how great this track is going to be. The clink and clank of rusted metal smoothly pans from the center speaker, filling out the front speakers, and then traveling through the rear channels as the logo passes by. After that experience you know you're in for a great sonic ride. The battle in the sky over London is filled with zooming, whooshing brooms as they fly in and out of frame. The front and center channel handle these lightning quick pans with perfect clarity. The rear channels are constantly alive with the frenzy of magical action going on all around. LFE thunders as bolts of magic explode in the distance. From the opening scene, until the end, it doesn't seem like the subwoofer ever takes a break. There's always some sort of attack or intense scenes that need the attention of well-placed low frequency sound.

Other audio-tastic scenes of note include whenever someone dissapperates, when the big three jump into the green transport fires in the Ministry of Magic, and when the lifts in the Ministry shoot off into the distance with a resounding low frequency boom.

Dialogue is given a wonderful stage to shine front and center. Nothing gets lost in this chaotic mix of high-flying action, coupled with intensely dramatic talkative scenes. This is the kind of track that makes you glad you have the ability to play a lossless track. 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Part 1' is as demo-worthy as they come.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Disc 1

  • The Last Days of Privet Drive (HD, 2 min.) — A short featurette about how the movie is saying goodbye to Harry's house on Privet Drive and the Durselys.

  • Hagrid's Motorbike (HD, 4 min.) — This featurette talks about the opening scene where Harry and Hagrid ride the enchanted motorbike through the air. They talk about the special effects that went into the sequence, and how they had seven different motorbikes to use for different parts.

  • Magical Tents! (HD, 2 min.) — Here the set designers talk about designing the different tents for the movie, like the giant wedding tent used at the beginning.

  • Creating Dobby and Kreacher (HD, 4 min.) — Just your standard bit of outtakes while filming.

  • The Return of Griphook (HD, 4 min.) — Actor Warwick Davis talks about the many different characters he's played over the course of the series.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Disc 1

  • Maximum Movie Mode (HD) — Actor Jason Issacs hosts this Maximum Movie Mode. Many other crew members pop up along the way. Producer David Heyman comes along near the beginning to talk about a deleted scene between Harry and Dudley and why they had to cut it. This scene is included in the additional scenes, but it's nice to have someone close to the film explain why it was cut and what purpose it served. The production designer Stuart Craig stops by to tell us about the movie's dark and ominous look and also lets us in on a secret that they studied 'Citizen Kane' for the look of this movie. Tom Felton comes along every now and then to explain more about what is happening by reading passages from the book. These are invaluable to a person who hasn't read the books. I really enjoyed this part of this Maximum Movie Mode. Even though there are quite a few dead spots without any Maximum Movie Mode events happening, this is a great companion to the movie. It explains much more in-depth information about the movie and talks about where deleted scenes would have been inserted. Issacs comes along every now and then with interesting tidbits of trivia about the 'Harry Potter' universe. Overall, this isn't just for fans, it's for anyone who wants to know more about the movie and its source material.

Disc 2

  • The Seven Harrys (HD, 5 min.) — The special effects for the Polyjuice Potion scene at the beginning are explained. They show exactly how the entire scene was created and how everyone in the room was turned into Harry.

  • On the Green with Rupert, Tom, Oliver, and James (HD, 13 min.) — The actors who play the Weasley brothers go over the fun times that they've had together on set, and we also follow them on a golf trip.

  • Dan, Rupert, and Emma's Running Competition (HD, 3 min.) — The big three talk about how much running they do in the movie. Specifically they talk about how the scene where they're running from the Snatchers in the forest and the competition they had between each other.

  • Godric's Hollow/The Harry and Nagini Battle (HD, 6 min.) — Shooting Godric's Hollow and the battle between Harry and Voldemort's snake is discussed here with the cast and crew.

  • The Frozen Lake (HD, 4 min.) — The lake scene where Harry finds himself being strangled by the locket is discussed here. You're able to see exactly how they filmed it and what it took.

  • Additional Scenes (HD, 11 min.) — Eight scenes are included here. As a person who hasn't read the books I enjoyed the simple scene used to explain the radio that Ron carries around with him. I also really liked the scene between Harry and Mrs. Drusley who has a rare special moment with Harry. There's a funny scene that involves Ron and Harry disguised as Ministry workers who take an elevator ride with Mr. Weasley. Most of the scenes here would have been nice to have in the movie for Harry Potter dummies like me. They're good filler scenes that help explain more about certain objects and help explain character's motives.

  • 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1: Behind the Soundtrack (HD, 4 min.) — The original music for the movie is discussed here. A few of the movie's producers talk about how vital the original composing was for this film.

  • The Wizarding World of Harry Potter – Promotional Trailer (HD, 6 min.) — The Universal theme park in Orlando shows off the opening of their new Wizarding World of Harry Potter complete with a full Hogwarts castle.

Final Thoughts

It was big news when Warner Bros scrapped the theatrical 3D release of 'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1,' giving 3D haters plenty of ammunition, and making fans wonder why a studio that has made billions off of this franchise couldn't get it right or invest the proper money to do the film justice. This viewing option is finally available, on Blu-ray 3D, found exclusively at Best Buy, and it's actually not all that bad. It's also not all that great, either. The 3D here is pretty mediocre. For the price, this set isn't that bad, but chances are fans already bought this set when it first came out, making it an expensive double dip. As such, this one remains for the most ardent of fans only, those willing to be disappointed.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 3D/2D combo pack
  • 2- BD50 discs, 1-BD25
  • DVD + UltraViolet Digital Copy

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/MVC

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH, French, Spanish, Portuguese

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.