Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
4 stars
Amazon
$9.99
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
3.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3 Stars
Supplements
4.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Robot Chicken: Star Wars III

Street Date:
July 12th, 2011
Reviewed by:
Nate Boss
Review Date: 1
July 12th, 2011
Movie Release Year:
2011
Studio:
Warner Brothers
Length:
44 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

After the Blu-ray debut of the 'Family Guy Star Wars Trilogy,' there were just two holes in my collection waiting to be filled: the actual 'Star Wars' films themselves, and what I consider the better parody series, featuring a familiar voice: the 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars' mini-features. Operating in the same fashion as the Adult Swim non-sequitur show that has four seasons to its credit, the animated action figures that I grew up with come to life on screen, with random behind-the-scenes explanations, running gags, and no lack whatsoever of farcical irreverence, all at the expense of some very familiar characters and settings.

The third film in this "saga" is a bit less scattershot than your traditional 'Robot Chicken' episode, as Emperor Palpatine reflects on his life while plummeting to his death aboard the Death Star II. As he ponders why exactly he chose a sniveling snot-nosed slave boy to be his apprentice, we see what made the man go into politics, how he feels about important moments in his life, and his role as the ruler of the galaxy. At the same time, witness Gary the Stormtrooper's ascent through the ranks, as he, much like Forrest Gump, finds himself in important places and times as the Rebellion aims to take down the Empire.

Sure, there's more to this third installment than just a Stormtrooper, Darth Vader, and Palpatine, but they're the recurring threads, the constant fallbacks. 'Robot Chicken' proves, unlike that other parody series, how much love the creators of the show have for 'Star Wars,' with their constant attention to detail putting the focus on some of the lesser known characters in the saga. Ever wonder what happened to Max Rebo and his band when Jabba's barge went down? What about Boba Fett, why was his assault on Luke and Han aboard that Skiff so unsuccessful, and what happened to him after he fell into the Sarlaac pit? What exactly was the prophecy, what does it say?!? What in the hell is a Prune Face, and what languages does C-3PO not count among his six million forms of communication?

It's a pleasure to watch a show like this, because even when it isn't at the top of its game, it's still relatable, as Seth Green and Matthew Seinrich are much like the rest of the fans of George Lucas' brainchild. Sure, it's easy to hate on Jar-Jar Binks, but how can the character be properly utilized? Since his original purpose was for comic relief, why not actually make the incompetent Gungan actually... funny? Why not poke fun at the shortcomings of the Prequel Trilogy that aren't related to the Ahmed Best voiced reject, like the multitude of ridiculous, implausible Jedi, or the massive proliferation of lightsabers in a saga where the originals only featured a total of three characters (four if you count Han's brief moment) wielding the crystal powered blades, with never more than two on screen. Why not utilize the existing state of the series where every brand product has utilized the series for its own benefit, like the LEGO video games?

The 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars' specials have fit the bill for what fanboys have always wanted, with humor about the galaxy far, far away being more than just none-too-clever wordplay or mish-moshings of characters for no good reason whatsoever. While some vignettes fail at their purpose, the majority of the show connects, with a very rude yet astute sense of humor. The changes in characters aren't always ridiculous, implausible reaches, and numerous gaps in the saga, moments that just don't quite gel, are filled in with a genuine, loving spark. Sure, 'It's a Trap!' had a better Darth Vader death gag, but that particular part of the saga (ie, all of 'Return of the Jedi') is just begging for improvement. We get a pretty damn sweet disco remix of the iconic 'Star Wars' theme, even if it means we have to witness a pointless dance sequence. It's worth it, though, sitting through the misfires to get to the gems, as we witness Vader trying to figure out what all his buttons do, or his magical transformation from an old dude to a young scruffy haired nerf herder ghost, much to the chagrin of the older Jedi ghosts.

Never before has a Wampa been given such an amazing, touching moment as the one we witness when Luke has to reflect shamefully upon his cruelty towards the creature, at the life he forced it to live from then on. Never has Padme's blatant prick teasing of Anakin in her lakeside apartment been more truthful, and never, until now, has the meaning behind the orders other than the infamous Order 66 been revealed. 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars III' runs the length of two episodes, and surely falls a bit short of its intergalactic sketch comedy predecessors, with few truly laugh out loud moments (like the brilliant Ponda Baba and Evazan gag in the first installment). It still readily delivers the goods, though, with far more hits than there are misses, and perhaps the most coherent arrangement of gags in 'Robot Chicken' history. It's rude without being utterly foul, it's insightful without being overly analytical and boring. Best of all, it's packed to the brim with bittersweet ironies, juxtapositions, and outright lunacy featuring the beloved characters of 'Star Wars' lore. 'Robot Chicken' is a winner, even when it's off its A game. Failed 'Star Wars' scenes become successful 'Robot Chicken' parodies more times than you can say "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO" in forty five minutes flat.

The Disc: Vital Stats

Warner brings 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars III' to Blu-ray on a Region A/B/C BD25 disc, with no packaging frills. Unlike the 'Family Guy Star Wars' releases, which gave consumers the chance to buy previously released films on Blu-ray for the first time, Warner has only released the third special in this series. Be sure to stick around, as there are a few more gags in the show once the credits begin!

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

I didn't have high expectations for 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars III' going in to the viewing, and perhaps that's why I'm so satisfied with this transfer. Warner gives the toy-laden animation a VC-1 1080p encode that looks far better than any viewing of this show I've ever seen on cable or home video.

The textures, the random fabrics and cloths making up the costuming for characters is just a pleasure to look at, far more so than the awesome construction paper layout of 'South Park' Blu-rays. The picture is constantly a real pleasure to look at, as detail levels are pretty great, where applicable (some moments in the show are naturally somewhat bland in animation, so that didn't bother me). The picture depth is actually really good, even if this type of animation doesn't normally lend itself to such, especially with the flat panel mouth animations. Colors are quite solid and not the least bit dull, while contrast is absolutely pitch perfect.

I will say I noticed some ghosting in the stormtrooper escalator gag, with screens looking just fine (as well as the Emperor), but the fast motion of the white armored clones creating a visual distraction. There is also some artifacting to be found here, most noticeably in the black interior sections of the Jedi council or the skiff bar beneath the bartending EV9-D9 droid. If you have to look up that name, you lose geek street cred.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

The audio for 'Robot Chicken: Star Wars III' was disappointing, even with lowered expectations as this show debuts on Blu-ray. The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track is simply lacking.

The light movement effects are nice, even if they're too few and far between, while the localization is accurate, and a fun little add in to keep the full room engaged as dialogue sometimes circles. Sadly, bass is the killer. Explosions are way too light, and some musical segments have no oomph beneath them whatsoever, in places where it would be the most fitting. The Order 67 gag and one Boba Fett spot had some light roar, which was nice, but when your film features a THX sound gag that has no rumble, and extremely limited range, something is wrong.

This track just feels limited, restrained, and that's not a good thing.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Five bonus ways to view the film. Five. That right there clinches a huge score by itself. The rest? Bonus awesome sauce.

  • Audio Commentaries - Four commentary tracks grace this disc. The Actors 1 (Abraham Benrubi, Ahmed Best, Keith Ferguson, Seth Green, Matthew Senreich, and Billy Dee Williams) track features the guys laughing and just talking about random stuff. It's always funny to hear Best trash Binks, Green talk about french kissing Binks and the legend and aura of Boba Fett, or Williams not knowing about all the stuff sold featuring his character. This track is full of as much laughter as there is info, but there are some fun jokes and moments here. Actors 2 (Bob Bergen, Donald Faison, Seth Green, Breckin Meyer, and Matthew Senreich) features Meyer talking about his first New York experience and odd racial tensions, Meyer talking about Mark Paul Gosseler's ass, and Meyer dominating the track with his wacky random ass anecdotes. He's a one man show, and everyone just eggs him on. Writers (Matthew Beans, Mike Fasolo, Dan Milano, Tom Root, Hugh Sterbakov, and Zeb Wells) focus on writing, naturally, and hit more behind the scenes, omitted type notes. It's not as entertaining as the other two tracks, for sure. Lastly, the Crew (Cameron Baity, Christopher Covel, Trisha Gum, Alex Camer, Cam Leeburg, Chris McKay, Jeanette Moffat, and Rob Ronning) track talks about technical details, cameras, effects, movement, that sort of thing. It's a nice listen, since the show is pretty darned unique looking, but they have a hard time keeping up with explaining scenes, so entire segments get ignored. Watch this track to learn the tricks of the trade, but not much else. After a while, the tracks all seem to mention a lot of the same things when they actually comment on the film, so be sure to not marathon these commentary tracks. Spread 'em out over time.
  • Chicken Nuggets - A pain in the butt to control "PiP" track that branches off to random footage at times, away from the film. Keyword: branches. Not seamlessly. This feature has more visible seams than Frankenstein's monster, and is twice as awkward and imposing. This is just a really difficult way to watch the film, as we watch a few seconds of the show, and blam, another explanation by people on couches. I now know where on the chicken the nuggets are found, since this is just shit.
  • Featurettes (HD, 22 min) - Six features, playable one by one or all as a whole. For the Love of Toys covers the crew's love of 'Star Wars' toys. God bless 'em. Or curse them for bragging about getting a vintage AT-AT for ten cents. Either way. For the Love of 'Star Wars' has the same random crew members discussing their love of the film. For the Love of Filmmaking has the guys, again, talking about how they got into film, and a lot of those stories involve 'Star Wars.' Not to be a dick, but I wonder how many children growing up on the Prequel Trilogy grow up to be mass murderers. Behind the Scenes: Writing has the guys in the writing room talking and WHY IS THERE A 'WHAT A GIRL WANTS' POSTER IN THE BACKGROUND?!?! Anyways, this is a roundtable bit of footage just talking about the good and the bad with some scenes. Behind the Scenes: Voice Acting has looks at the acting for the show. Yes, that says Zac Efron. Yes, Zac Efron is in this film. But so are a bunch of former 'Star Wars' actors. This is a fun watch. Behind the Scenes: VFX is the final one, and it's pretty neat, as you see where the show had green screen add-ins, and see the individual elements before composite, including the Endor tree sequence. This has to be seen to be believed, it's really pretty cool, even for someone who's seen these countless times before.
  • Robot Chicken Skate Tour '09 (HD, 21 min) - Comic Con meets roller skates. The 501st make a brief appearance here, as we see some random footage from a less-than-ten tour stop involving the show and an archaic locale and activity that's more dried up than Sarlaac nookie. This is just random footage of the crew and random people having fun, not much more.
  • Deleted Scenes and Animatics (HD, 25 min) - Twenty six bonus goodies, here, playable one at a tie or all together, with additional video introductions (that look horrible). The animatic scenes include full voice acting, so their humor is retained, thankfully. It's somewhat bizarre, really, that I had to pause this feature a few times due to laughing so hard, as some of these scenes are just infinitely more funny and random than what made it into the final cut. Obi-Wan's "chosen one" turning out to be a bad choice is just...epic, so very epic. Ahmed Best gets murdered, Mara Jade (!) shows up in a less than funny spot, Chewy gets a redundant gag, Stormtrooper predictability is poked fun at, and Porkins (the fat X-Wing pilot) gets mocked, more than once. Additionally, Chewy's loyalty is questioned, Jessica returns, Yarna d'al' Gargan gets her turn being mocked for being fat and Dengar gets his turn for his questionable fashion choices (in a word: hilarious), Vader's sales abilities are questioned, Luke's obliviousness is pointed out, 'Spaceballs' gets a fun little reference, and to wrap it all up, there's an Aristocrats joke (look it up, folks!)! The variety of jokes here is great, as it isn't just the same gag over and over, and we get a much greater scope of comedy and parody. After viewing this reel, you'll find yourself wishing more than a few of these exclusions were in the final product, that's for sure.
  • Skywalker Ranch Premiere (HD, 4 min) - Footage of the crew attending a screening on Lucas' homefield.
  • Star Wars Celebration V Robot Chicken Panels (HD, 7 min) - The crew sit down and talk to a crowd about the show. Really, that's pretty much all this is. The upcoming animated 'Star Wars' show is teased, but it's all studio speak.
  • Gag Reel (HD, 3 min) - Cast mess around while recording lines or around the "sets." Not your typical gag reel, and I don't know if that's a good or bad thing.
  • Trailers (HD) - Three varied trailers for this special, and one for a video game. Let's just say they're pretty damn awesome.
  • Sunday in the Boardroom with George Lucas (HD, 8 min) - The writing crew for 'Robot Chicken' sit down with Lucas and...waste time. They ask what exactly Jar-Jar Binks was banned from Gunga City for (I still don't get it, either), Lucas asks if he destroyed their childhood, Ahsoka Tano's fate is not revealed, and Lucas acts like a class act. It's hard to hate on Lucas's Prequel Trilogy after hearing him mock his own work at times here.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

As advertised on the sticker on the shrink wrap, there are two bonus goodies here not found on the DVD. No, it doesn't say which ones, but some digging for reviews on the DVD leads me to believe it's these two:

  • Time Lapse (HD, 7 min) - A feature showing sped up photography showing what all it takes to get the"characters" to move for a single scene. You will not envy the crew after watching this.
  • Animation Reference (HD, 8 min) - Seth Green acting out scenes for reference for the animators. Basically, just being a fool.

Final Thoughts

'Robot Chicken: Star Wars III' is made with love. A bunch of guys and girls playing with toys, spawning a show that features said toys taking over and recreating, to better effect, some of the odder moments of the series. This third installment may not be the best of the bunch, but it is easily the most coherent, with an actual plot to the story, as a whole. Warner's release of the show fares better than one would think, and it's loaded to the hilt with bonus goodies. This one comes with the highest of recommendations. It's short, but it can be quite sweet.

Technical Specs

  • BD-25 Blu-ray Disc
  • Region A/B/C

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH

Supplements

  • Audio commentary
  • Deleted scenes
  • Behind the scenes
  • Making of featurettes
  • Gag reel
  • George Lucas feature
  • Chicken Nuggets track

Exclusive HD Content

  • Time Lapse
  • Animation Reference

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.