Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
4.5 stars
Overall Grade
4.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
1 Stars
High-Def Extras
3 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Moana - 3D: Ultimate Collector's Edition

Street Date:
March 7th, 2017
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
March 10th, 2017
Movie Release Year:
2016
Studio:
Disney/Buena Vista
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

FWI, portions of this review appear in our coverage of 'Moana' (2D Blu-ray + DVD + Digital HD). The Vital Disc Stats, Video, and Final Thoughts portions are unique to this review.

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

See the light where the sky meets the sea
It calls me
And no one knows how far it goes
If the wind in my sail on the sea stays behind me
One day I'll know
How far I'll go

As parents, we set boundaries to keep our children safe from harm. Ultimately, this is a necessary, but impossible task. There's no such thing as a life without bumps and bruises and broken hearts. Yet we strive onwards, guiding and teaching as we try to soften the world until the day comes when our children face the world entirely on their own.

Disney's 'Moana' is an adventure set on one such day.

A young woman destined to be chief somewhere in the South Pacific, Moana lives in paradise. She loves her island, her people, her family... and yet, something deep down inside is calling her away. Calling her beyond the safety of the island's reef.

Beyond the boundaries set by her father.

'Moana' is the story of a young woman who wishes she was happy with her life, but in faking her happiness, is denying her truest self. Turns out Moana is special -- chosen by the ocean itself to find and escort a rascally demigod, Maui, across the sea so he can return the stolen heart of an island. If Moana fails, her island will die along with everyone she knows and loves.

It's also a musical that manages to honor the rich tapestry of Oceana voyager culture while featuring a stupid chicken sidekick, a shapeshifting demigod who argues with his living tattoos, pygmy pirates, a lava monster, and a ginormous crab with a fondness for sparkling treasures.

Like 'Frozen' and 'Tangled', 'Moana' is a modernist Princess story. Our female heroine is fully realized, imperfect, on a journey of her own making, and actually crucial to the story's climax. I loved every minute of it, from the rich visuals to Lin-Manuel Miranda's culturally-infused songs to Moana's relationship with her Grandmother to The Rock act like a selfish dick to the playful action sequences to the beautiful climax where our female lead finds strength in -- spoiler -- avoiding violence.

After stumbling to transition between hand-drawn and CGI animation in an era ushered forth by Pixar and DreamWorks, Disney Animation Studios is on a creative run right now that harkens back to the company's first and second golden eras (and quite honestly is far more inventive than Pixar's release schedule of just-okay sequels). From a cultural standpoint, I love how they're diversifying their princesses while giving girls stories of strength and perseverance and self-reliance.

Visually, 'Moana' is like taking a vacation to the south pacific. Rich in detail and fine textures, it's not quite as technically precise as Pixar's best, but this world feels realized, awash in sumptuous tropical aesthetics. This story is efficient, thematic, and smartly crafted. The catchy musical numbers strike a nice balance of emotion, character, and story. Maui's 'You're Welcome' invites viewers into a world of living tattoos and tribal art, while Jemaine Clement's (as Tamatoa) 'Shiny' blends action and tension with a lounge singer act that builds to a phosphorescent fever dream (all while pushing the story!).

Speaking of the action. While not quite Spielbergian in its control over cinematic language, the set-pieces are a lot of fun and visually grand. Example: I didn't expect to see coconut-wearing pygmy pirates that look a bit like 'Mad Max: Fury Road' extras, but now I don't know how I ever lived without them. The climax too blends furious danger with just enough humor to engage but not terrify the little ones

Is there anything I'd change about 'Moana'? Perhaps. I'm not a huge fan of destiny stories, so I wish the ocean -- represented by a playful wave -- was less helpful when Moana and Maui were in jeopardy. The first act is also a little choppy -- I wholeheartedly admire the efficiency of the way the beats are laid out, mind you, but at times it feels like it could breathe a touch more. I also see how the tonal variations might not play for some audiences (for example, the 'You're Welcome' and 'Shiny' musical numbers, for example, don't match the style of Moana's songs), but this wasn't a problem for me.

Juggling visuals and tones and multiple character arcs and the way it establishes and reprises musical themes, 'Moana' exudes craft and joy in every frame. No boundaries required.

And the call isn't out there at all
It's inside me
It's like the tide, always falling and rising
I will carry you here in my heart
You'll remind me
That come what may, I know the way
I am Moana!

Vital Disc Stats: The Blu-ray

'Moana' debuts on Blu-ray in two separate high definition combo packs. The Ultimate Collector's edition includes one Blu-ray 3D, one Blu-ray with the feature film in 2D as well as all the bonus materials, one DVD, and a Digital HD redemption code that, via Disney Movies Anywhere, works with services such as iTunes and VUDU. According to the packaging, this Blu-ray will play in Regions A, B, and C. The only Pre-menu trailer (on the 2D Blu-ray) is the 'Beauty and the Beast' (2017) teaser.

'Moana' is also available also available without the 3D disc.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

[For this Blu-ray, I'm in the middle of reviewing the Epson Pro Cinema 6040UB projector, available through custom installers -- the 5040UB is the sister model -- with a 1,000,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio, HDR and HDCP 2.2, 4K pixel-shift technology, and the ability to produce 100% of the DCI P3 color space. I also have a 100" Silver Ticket STR-169100-HC 16:9 projector screen. More on both soon!]

3DTVs might be on the way out, but fortunately for 3D aficionados, studios are still producing and releasing excellent stereoscopic content in cinemas and on Blu-ray. (BTW, if you haven't watched home 3D projection, WOW, it's far more immersive than a nice 65' display.) Either way, 'Moana' looks fantastic with its extra dimension. While not quite up to 'Gravity', 'Life of Pi', or 'Avatar' standards, mind you, it's quite close.

The 3D version retains everything we admire about the 2D Blu-ray presentation -- vivid colors, finely resolved textures, and inky black levels -- but makes Moana's CGI-rendered universe feel almost real. Island, ocean, and monster-realm locations stretch endlessly toward distant horizons, improving the production's sense of scale and scope. Action sequences are more engrossing, and musical numbers more dynamic. Like many 3D movies, the net result is a window-into-another-world sensation.

On the downside, certain displays might lose some shadow detail and could present with minor ghosting, and there are a couple instances where pop-out 3D effects collide with the frame's edge, ruining the magic.

Ultimately, let's call 'Moana 3D' a 4.80-star presentation -- it's not quite as story-necessary as the best 3D, but definitely adds to the overall experience -- rounded up to 5-stars in our rating system. If you enjoy 3D, 'Moana' is another fine title to add to your collection.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

[For this review, I'm testing out the Integra DRX-R1 11.2 channel AV Receiver, which is capable of fully processing and powering up to 7.2.4 Dolby Atmos and DTS:X configurations. More soon!]

While 'Moana' offered a wonderfully immersive Dolby Atmos mix during its theatrical run, Disney Home Entertainment remains stuck in 7.1. And the results are, okay I guess, but there are a lot better 7.1 tracks in Disney's arsenal. This Blu-ray sounds a bit more like, though better than, a lesser Marvel Blu-ray. Dialogue is clear, but the mix is a touch front heavy and surprisingly quiet for my liking. I'm relatively new to the DRX-R1, mind you, and it's not fair to compare lossless and lossy sources, but I had to boost this track 5-10db versus other movies like 'Tangled' (which is far more dynamic).

Musical numbers are more enveloping but, outside of 'Shiny', don't do much with the surround environment. Side and rear surround panning is precise -- voices calling out, etc -- but not utilized often to build Moana's environments. LFE is also slightly underwhelming save for that 'Shiny' song and the lava monster sequence. Still, I've been watching the movie's musical numbers repeatedly on YouTube with my toddler and, outside improved fidelity, this Blu-ray wasn't leaps and bounds better.

That said, it's not a bad track, per se. It serves the story, first and foremost, and is actually dynamic during action-heavy sequences. It's just not overall demo material, even when up-mixed to 7.2.4 in DTS:Neural:X. For what it's worth, the best scenes, sonically speaking, are the pigmy-pirate sequence, 'Shiny', and the climax.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

[NOTE: due to an insane week and no advanced copy from the distributor, all descriptions of the bonus materials come courtesy of Disney's press release announcing 'Moana' on Blu-ray.]

The following bonus materials can be found on the DVD and Blu-rays:

Theatrical Short Film (2D & 3D): “Inner Workings” – With introduction by the filmmakers, is the story of the internal struggle between a man’s pragmatic, logical side and his free-spirited, adventurous half. Created by a small team at Walt Disney Animation Studios in a unique, fast-paced style that blends CG and traditional hand-drawn animation, the short explores the importance of finding balance in daily life.

Music Video: “How Far I’ll Go” – Performed by Alessia Cara.

Audio Commentary – With directors Ron and John.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

The following features are exclusive to the Blu-ray and Digital HD editions of 'Moana':

Maui Mini-Movie: “Gone Fishing” – When Maui decides it’s time to take charge of the ocean and catch his next meal, Moana must show him the error of his ways … with a little help from her friends!

Voice of the Islands – An in-depth look at how Pacific Island people and cultures inspired the filmmakers to create the story of “Moana.”

Things You Didn’t Know About …

Meet the stars of “Moana” in this dynamic Q&A featuring Dwayne Johnson, newcomer Auli‘i Cravalho, and famed animation directors Ron and John.

Meet the musical team behind “Moana” in this fascinating Q&A featuring Opetaia Foa‘i, Mark Mancina and Lin-Manuel Miranda.

Island Fashion – Find out how costume designer Neysa Bové took on the unique challenge of creating costumes using materials and techniques native to the islands of Oceania.

They Know the Way: Making the Music of “Moana” – Musicians Opetaia Foa‘I, Marc Mancina and Lin-Manuel Miranda take us on a personal journey through their involvement in the movie and how it changed their lives.

Fishing for Easter Eggs – Dive deep into the ocean and fish for the Easter Eggs hidden by the animators at Walt Disney Animation Studios.
   
The Elements of … – This series of four mini-docs explores the technical achievements behind some of the ground-breaking effects used in the film.

Mini Maui – Meet “Mini Maui,” Maui’s tattoo sidekick. Animated by legendary hand-drawn animator Eric Goldberg, we explore how the 2D world collides with CG animation to bring the demigod’s tattoos to life.

Water – In the movie, the ocean is a character. This piece explores how the water is given a personality, along with the technical feats of creating a believable ocean landscape farther than the eye can see.

Lava – Te K? is a creature made of lava, smoke and fire. This piece dives into the challenges of making an animated creature of massive scale brought to fiery life by character, technical and effects animators.

Hair – One of the greatest technical achievements of the film was the animation of the beautiful, curly hair on Moana and Maui. Take a look at the hair-raising detail that goes into animating each strand, adding performance to the movie that has never been seen before.

Deleted Song: “Warrior Face” – With introduction by songwriter Lin-Manuel Miranda.

Deleted Scenes – Ron and John introduce the following deleted scenes:  Race the Wind/Ties that Bind; Discussing Moana’s Future; Under the Sea; Grandmother’s Warning/Legend of Maui; Education of Moana; Father, Daughter, Boat; and Canoe Race.

“How Far I’ll Go Around the World” – Multi-language reel of the song “How Far I’ll Go.”

Final Thoughts

'Moana' is another triumph in Walt Disney Studios growing library of modern princess fairy tails, effortlessly blending Pacific Islander culture with catchy musical numbers, thrilling action set-pieces, a universally emotionally storyline, and sumptuous visuals. If you enjoyed 'Tangled' or 'Frozen', 'Moana' is definitely worth checking out.

As an Ultimate Collector's Edition, 'Moana' offers a window-into-another world 3D presentation, a reference quality 2D presentation, a good-not-great sound mix, and a bounty of special features. If you enjoy 3D, this is the release for you. Highly Recommended.

If not, get the 2D Blu-ray + DVD + Digital HD combo pack.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 3D/Blu-ray/DVD/Digital Copy

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/TBA

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1

Supplements

  • Theatrical Short Film: "Inner Workings" – With introduction by the filmmakers, is the story of the internal struggle between a man's pragmatic, logical side and his free-spirited, adventurous half. Created by a small team at Walt Disney Animation Studios in a unique, fast-paced style that blends CG and traditional hand-drawn animation, the short explores the importance of finding balance in daily life.
  • Maui Mini-Movie: "Gone Fishing" – When Maui decides it's time to take charge of the ocean and catch his next meal, Moana must show him the error of his ways … with a little help from her friends!
  • Voice of the Islands – An in-depth look at how Pacific Island people and cultures inspired the filmmakers to create the story of "Moana."
  • Things You Didn't Know About … Meet the stars of "Moana" in this dynamic Q&A featuring Dwayne Johnson, newcomer Auli'i Cravalho, and famed animation directors Ron and John. Meet the musical team behind "Moana" in this fascinating Q&A featuring Opetaia Foa'i, Mark Mancina and Lin-Manuel Miranda.
  • Island Fashion – Find out how costume designer Neysa Bové took on the unique challenge of creating costumes using materials and techniques native to the islands of Oceania.
  • They Know the Way: Making the Music of "Moana" – Musicians Opetaia Foa'I, Marc Mancina and Lin-Manuel Miranda take us on a personal journey through their involvement in the movie and how it changed their lives.
  • Fishing for Easter Eggs – Dive deep into the ocean and fish for the Easter Eggs hidden by the animators at Walt Disney Animation Studios.
  • The Elements of … – This series of four mini-docs explores the technical achievements behind some of the ground-breaking effects used in the film.
  • Deleted Song: "Warrior Face" – With introduction by songwriter Lin-Manuel Miranda.
  • Deleted Scenes – Ron and John introduce the following deleted scenes: Race the Wind/Ties that Bind; Discussing Moana's Future; Under the Sea; Grandmother's Warning/Legend of Maui; Education of Moana; Father, Daughter, Boat; and Canoe Race.
  • Music Video: "How Far I'll Go" – Performed by Alessia Cara.
  • "How Far I'll Go Around the World" – Multi-language reel of the song "How Far I'll Go."
  • Audio Commentary – With directors Ron and John.

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.