Star Trek: Enterprise - The Complete Second Season
- Street Date:
- August 20th, 2013
- Reviewed by:
- Shannon T. Nutt
- Review Date: 1
- August 18th, 2013
- Movie Release Year:
- 1112 Minutes
- MPAA Rating:
- Release Country
- United States
The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take
Perhaps it's time for Trekkies everywhere to finally apologize to Rick Berman and Brannon Braga. For years, they have been taking the heat for 'ruining' 'Star Trek'. Never mind they both (particularly Berman) had a big hand in the success that came before – they've been vilified for overseeing what most fans felt was the worst 'Star Trek' series, and criticized for not being able to make the changes (or make them quickly enough) to keep 'Enterprise' on the air. Granted, there was a small, loyal fanbase that always supported 'Enterprise' (particularly outside the United States), but for the most part, the series has always been considered the downfall of a once great franchise.
Not long after 'Enterprise's demise, Paramount took the keys away from Berman/Braga and turned them over to J.J. Abrams. His first Star Trek movie was a blast, so much so that loyal Trekkies could ignore how it played fast and loose with the history of what came before. Another nail was hammered into the Berman/Braga coffin, and just when you thought a better crew was now navigating the 'Star Trek' franchise, it all went wrong. Star Trek Into Darkness hit theaters, and while it was certainly loaded with whiz-bang action and entertainment, it proved that J.J. and the Bad Robot team (particularly writers Bob Orci and Alex Kurtzman) didn't have a clue what Gene Roddenberry's vision of the future was all about.
Of course, hindsight is always 20/20, and it was both with the knowledge of what happened to 'Enterprise' and the bad taste of Star Trek Into Darkness still in my mouth that I tackled this review of 'Enterprise: Season 2' (note: 'Star Trek' doesn't become part of the official title until Season 3, despite the box cover). After enjoying 26 episodes that only get better as the season goes along (the Season 2 cliffhanger is outstanding), I came to the conclusion that the Berman/Braga team was really trying to get it right all along – the rest of us just weren't paying attention. Not to say Season 2 doesn't have its bumps and bruises. The resolution to Season 1's cliffhanger doesn't really entertain in the way one would hope, and there are a handful of boring to downright bad episodes (see: 'Precious Cargo'), but there's still more 'Star Trek' in any 10 minutes of 'Enterprise' than found in either of the two J.J. Abrams feature films.
Some of the noteworthy episodes in Season 2 include 'Carbon Creek', the second show of the season, which is a story about the first Vulcan visit to Earth (which happened long before the events seen in First Contact) and features Jolene Blalock playing T'Pol's great grandmother. Speaking of First Contact, the writers found a way to bring the Borg into the 'Enterprise' universe in the episode 'Regeneration', which is one of the latter episodes of the season. Then there's the episode 'Stigma', which is a not-so-veiled allegory about HIV that Braga himself (heard on the extras of this release) thinks is flat-out the best episode of 'Star Trek' he's ever done.
The season finale to Season 2 finally begins to take the show in the direction Berman/Braga wanted to at the outset – that of a serialized drama instead of a series of standalone episodes. Entitled 'The Expanse', the Season 2 ender introduces us to the Xindi – who will serve as the 'big bads' for the entirety of Season 3. The Xindi storyline is so good and takes the show in such a darker direction (with some real stakes for the main characters) that one can't help but wonder if this story had launched at the end of the first season instead of the second if 'Enterprise' would have really taken off in the ratings. Sadly, by the time Season 2 came to an end, a big chunk of previously loyal 'Star Trek' viewers had already checked out.
It was actually hard to watch Brannon Braga in some of the new bonus materials (detailed below) on this release (Berman didn't participate this time around, although his views can be found on the Season 1 set). While he does voice his opinion that many fans went over-the-top in their hatred of the show, it's also very obvious that he sees the demise of 'Enterprise' as very much a personal failure on his part. He believes this, even though it becomes very obvious that he was working for a studio that didn't give two hoots about the show or its legacy. His passion and love for 'Star Trek' is worn on his sleeve in both 'Enterprise' Blu-ray releases in a way we've never seen before from him. So, on behalf of at least this life-long Trekkie, I apologize, Mr. Braga. You were trying to get it right, and a huge part of me wishes someone that cared about 'Star Trek' the way you do was still in command of the ship.
The Blu-Ray: Vital Disc Stats
'Enterprise: Season 2' warps onto Blu-ray in packaging similar to the Season 1 Blu-ray release. Six 50GB discs come housed in a keepcase that holds two discs on each inside cover, plus two added hubs that hold a disc on either side. There are no inserts, but the reverse side of the slick (which you can see on the inside of the case) lists the episodes and bonus materials for each disc, just as the Season 1 set did. Once again, there is a slip cover included (slightly embossed, as was the one for the first season) which matches the cover of the slick.
Each disc begins with asking for the viewer to select a language (with English being highlighted as the default). The first disc in the set is front-loaded with trailers for Season 1 of 'Enterprise', Season 4 of 'Star Trek: The Next Generation', and trailers for the stand-alone Blu-ray releases of the two-part 'Next Generation' episodes The Best of Both Worlds and Redemption. There are no front-loaded trailers on the other five Blu-rays. The main menu on these discs follow exactly the same design and color scheme of the Season 1 discs, with the only difference being the footage from the episodes that play within the menu design.
The Video: Sizing Up the Picture
Although the video quality seems to be slightly improved over the Season 1 set, overall the look of Season 2 is very much on par with Season 1 and suffers from the same issues.
The slight improvement comes with the upconversion of the special effects. While almost all of the FX in Season 1 were rendered at 480i and upconverted, during Season 2 more and more effects were being rendered in 720p. From the research I've been able to do online, it seems that by the time Season 3 got underway, all new FX were being rendered in 720p, but it's difficult to pinpoint in this season just how many may have been, other than the fact that many visuals don't appear to suffer the same aliasing issues as others do. However, when it comes to the Enterprise ship herself, aliasing is almost always evident, most likely due to the fact that stock footage from Season 1 is being used in a large majority of the ship's appearances in Season 2.
As for the rest of the image, the video quality is pretty much the same as the Season 1 release. During Season 2, 'Enterprise' was still being shot on 35mm film (it would go full HD at the beginning of Season 4), so there's still a slightly grainy and film-like look to the episodes. Once again, most episodes and scenes have a fairly 'soft' look to them, with more or less muted colors and black levels that are not often as strong as one might hope. Things tend to look much better on those rare occasions when the show shoots on location as opposed to sets, but those occasions are few and far between (the second episode, 'Carbon Creek' is a great example of how good 'Enterprise' can look when it's on location and is perhaps the best-looking episode overall on this set).
The bottom line is that if you were okay with the appearance of Season 1 on Blu-ray, you'll be happy with what you get here; and if you disliked the quality of the last release, there's probably not enough of a difference here to satisfy you.
The Audio: Rating the Sound
While I was able to detect the slightest of improvements when it comes to video quality, the audio of Season 2 is almost exactly the same as Season 1 – which is to say satisfactory, but by no means outstanding.
The lossless 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track has no issues when it comes to popping, hissing, or other noticeable problems, but it also lacks the kind of immersive quality one would hope to hear. While the rear speakers are almost always active, directionality is rarely apparent. Dialogue is crisp, clean and primarily all up front. As with Season 1, everything appears properly mixed, with explosions and other action noises never drowning out or being excessively louder than the spoken word.
In addition to the DTS-HD track, 5.1 Dolby tracks are available in German and Italian, while 2.0 Dolby tracks can be heard in Spanish, French, and Japanese. Subtitles options consist of English SDH, Spanish, French, German, Japanese, Italian, Dutch, Danish, Norwegian, Finnish, and Swedish. Once again, no Klingon track or subtitles have been provided.
The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff
- Audio Commentary – Disc 1 contains the 2005 DVD commentary track for 'Dead Stop' by Michael Sussman and Phyllis Strong, the writers of the episode.
- Deleted Scene (SD, 1 min.) – A deleted scene from the 'Minefield' episode, featuring Dr. Phlox and Hoshi.
- Enterprise Moments: Season 2 (SD, 19 min.) – A 2005 featurette on the shooting of Season 2, featuring comments from Scott Bakula, Jolene Blalock, John Billingsley, and Linda Park, as well as Rick Berman and Brannon Braga.
- Enterprise Profile: Jolene Blalock (SD, 14 ½ min.) – A 2005 featurette covering the both the character of T'Pol and the actor who portrayed her, Jolene Blalock.
- Deleted Scenes (SD, 4 min.) – Two deleted scenes from the episode 'A Night in Sickbay'. The first is a nighttime Sickbay conversation between Archer and Tripp, and the second is a scene featuring Archer, T'Pol, and Hoshi.
- Inside 'A Night in Sickbay' (SD, 11 min.) – A behind-the-scenes look at the making of this episode, including comments from Scott Bakula and John Billingsley.
- Deleted Scenes (SD, 2 ½ min.) – An extended scene (with what remains in the completed episode shown in black and white) from the episode 'Dawn' (1 ½ min.), and a deleted scene from 'Stigma' (1 min.) with Archer and T'Pol.
- Text Commentary – A text-only commentary track for the episode 'Stigma' by Michael and Denise Okuda.
- Archival Interviews (SD, 5 min.) – A featurette looking back at the episode 'Stigma' with comments from Brannon Braga, Rick Berman, Jolene Blalock, and Scott Bakula.
- Photo Gallery – A user-controlled photo gallery of 50 stills, including both production photos and behind-the-scenes shots.
- Deleted Scene (SD, 1 min.) – A deleted scene from the episode 'Cease Fire', featuring Archer and T'Pol.
- Shooting 'Future Tense' (SD, 17 min.) – A behind-the-scenes look at the making of the episode 'Future Tense' with footage actually taken during the shooting of the episode. This is an archival extra (it was on the DVD set), but it's still a pretty cool one that gives viewers an idea of what it was like to be on the set and just how tedious it can be to get a single scene shot.
- Enterprise Secrets (SD, 5 min.) – First Assistant Director David Trotti talks about his experience in helping create the Klingon prison planet Rura Penthe for Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country and recreating it for the Season 2 episode 'Judgment'.
- Audio Commentary – An archival track for the episode 'Regeneration', featuring writers Michael Sussman and Phyllis Strong.
- Text Commentary – A text-only track for the episode 'First Flight' by Michael and Denise Okuda.
- LeVar Burton: Star Trek Director (SD, 7 min.) – A featurette on LeVar's directing of the episode 'First Flight', including comments from LeVar himself.
- Enterprise Outtakes (SD, 11 ½ min.) – No 'Star Trek' Blu-ray release would be complete without bloopers, and we get some entertaining (although archival) ones here.
- Deleted Scenes – (SD, 5 min.) Two deleted scenes from the season finale 'The Expanse'. In the first, Archer meets up with a girlfriend back on Earth; while the second scene has Archer talking to Hoshi in her quarters.
- NX-01 File 04 (SD, 3 min.) – Scott Bakula discusses some real-life notables who have visited the 'Enterprise' set, such as Bill Gates and 'Star Trek' alumnus Patrick Stewart.
- NX-01 File 05 (SD, 3 ½ min.) – Linda Park discusses the relationship between the characters of Hoshi and T'Pol.
- NX-01 File 06 (SD, 2 min.) – Anthony Montgomery talks about a visit to the set by Whoopi Goldberg.
HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?
- Audio Commentary – A brand-new commentary track for the Season 2 premiere, 'Shockwave, Part II' with Co-Executive Producer Chris Black (who also co-wrote this episode) and Michael and Denise Okuda.
- In Conversation: The First Crew (HD, 94 min.) – Brannon Braga chairs this wonderful roundtable (minus any table!) discussion featuring all of the original cast: Scott Bakula, Jolene Blalock, John Billingsley, Connor Trinneer, Linda Park, Anthony Montgomery, and Dominic Keating. The cast is even joined by Jeffrey Combs (who played the Andorian Commander Shran in multiple episodes) about 30 minutes in, although sadly Connor Trinneer leaves at this time (with no explanation). This bonus feature is the highlight of this release and is quite similar to the cast interview segment that was part of the Season 2 Blu-ray release for 'Star Trek: The Next Generation'. The big difference between the two is that the 'Next Generation' sit down had a professional interviewer asking the questions, while this one is moderated by Braga himself. The difference is a big one, as while the 'Next Generation' reunion was fun, it wasn't very informative. This reunion is fun and informative and tackles such issues as the dissatisfaction with the final episode, why the show was really cancelled, and if the cast would be interested in coming back and restarting the series in some form or fashion (good news: everyone's interested!).
- Season 2 Promo (SD, ½ min.) – A brief original promo for Season 2 of 'Enterprise'.
- Audio Commentaries – Two brand-new commentary tracks for the episodes 'Regeneration' and 'First Flight'. The 'Regeneration' track, which is the episode that showcases the Borg, features commentary by John Billingsley and Bonita Friedericy (who plays Dr. Rooney), who are married in real-life. The fact that they are a couple makes for a very entertaining and humorous track. The 'First Flight' commentary features co-writer Chris Black along with Michael and Denise Okuda.
- Uncharted Territory (HD, 89 min.) – This feature-length look at the second season of 'Enterprise' is divided into three parts: 'Destination Unknown' (30 min.); 'The First Crew' (29 min.); and 'Course Correction' (30 min.). The highlight of these three segments (which sadly don't come with an option to view them together as one uninterrupted documentary) is "Course Correction", during which Brannon Braga (and others) detail both the trouble they had with network tinkering (at one point, UPN wanted a weekly boy band on the Enterprise!) as well as their reaction to 'Star Trek' fans blogging and posting on the internet about the show (turns out they were reading all those complaints).
It’s amazing how one's opinion of something can change with the distance of time and a new perspective. Once seen as the downfall of 'Star Trek' on television, 'Enterprise' now serves as a reminder (or an introduction for those only familiar with the J.J. Abrams' movies) of what 'Star Trek' and Gene Roddenberry's vision of the future is all about. No, all the episodes aren't good, and some of the ones that are lack originality – but overall Season 2 of 'Enterprise' is a worthy addition to the 'Star Trek' legacy. Recommended.
- 6 BD-50 Blu-ray Discs
- 1080p/AVC MPEG-4
- English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
- German Dolby Digital 5.1
- Italian Dolby Digital 5.1
- Spanish Dolby Digital 2.0
- French Dolby Digital 2.0
- Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0
- English SDH, French, Spanish, Japanese, German, Italian, Danish, Dutch, Finnish, Norwegian, Swedish
- Audio Commentaries for 'Dead Stop' and 'Regeneration'
- Inside 'A Night in Sickbay'
- Photo Gallery
- Shooting 'Future Tense'
- Enterprise Secrets
- LeVar Burton: Star Trek Director
- Enterprise Outtakes
- NX-01 Files 04, 05 and 06
- Archival Interviews
- Text commentaries for 'Stigma' and 'First Flight'
- Deleted Scenes for 'Minefield', 'A Night in Sickbay', 'Dawn', 'Stigma', 'Cease Fire', and 'The Expanse'
- Enterprise Moments: Season 2
- Enterprise Profile: Jolene Blalock
Exclusive HD Content
- In Conversation: The First Crew
- Uncharted Territory
- Season 2 Promo
- Audio Commentaries for 'Carbon Creek', 'Regeneration', and 'First Flight'
All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More
about our gear.
Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.
Sundays and Cybèle
Ali: Fear Eats the Soul (Criterion Collection)
Ghostbusters II: 25th Anniversary Edition (Mastered in 4K)
I've Always Loved You