Blu-ray
Rent it First
3 stars
List Price
$14.98
Amazon
$5.09 (66%)
3rd Party
$2.15
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3.5 Stars
Supplements
2 Stars
High-Def Extras
0.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Rent it First

Semi-Pro

Street Date:
June 3rd, 2008
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
May 29th, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
New Line Home Entertainment
Length:
99 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Against all odds, SNL alum Will Ferrell has taken his lunk-headed jock schtick and turned it into a successful movie career. Aside from a handful of quirky dramadies like ‘Stranger Than Fiction,’ ‘Melinda and Melinda,’ and ‘Winter Passing,’ Ferrell has gravitated to overstated comedies to transform himself into Hollywood’s go-to manchild. To his credit, the formula has worked well over the last ten years, allowing the comedian to evolve from supporting bit player to leading man. Sadly, his latest jaunt into goofball comedy, ‘Semi-Pro,’ failed at the box office, disappointed audiences and critics, and falls flatter than I ever expected a Will Ferrell comedy to fall.

In 1976, a smash-hit single called “Love Me Sexy” scores singer Jackie Moon (Ferrell) enough cash to buy the Flint Tropics, a basketball team in the American Basketball Association. Sweating in the spotlight as coach, promoter, and star forward, Jackie’s newly acquired team can hardly win a game, much less work together on the court. When the ABA commissioner (David Koechner) decides to merge his top four teams with the NBA, Jackie becomes determined to fix the defunct Tropics and worm his way into the pros. To boost his team’s record, Jackie arranges bizarre promotions, nabs former Celtic Ed Monix (Harrelson), and convinces his streetballing friend Clarence (Andre Benjamin) to join. However, even when Jackie brings his team to the top of the heap, the commissioner tells him their record is irrelevant -- the NBA won’t support a team in a minor media market like Flint anyway. What follows is a jumbled montage of genre clichés that gives Jackie one last shot (quite literally) to prove he’s a decent guy rather than a complete failure.

In my humble opinion, the critically panned ‘Bewitched’ feels like an AFI top-100 comedy next to ‘Semi-Pro.’ Ferrell’s visit to the ABA collapses under the weight of a thousand stale jokes, a predictable plot, and a series of recycled gags. In fact, the entire script struck me as a phoned-in mess that failed to surprise, relying too heavily on its R-rating for the majority of its laughs. Such a low-brow celebration of locker rooms and jock straps may appeal to fans of ‘90s gross-out comedies, but those who enjoy more modern R-rated comedies (from filmmakers like Judd Apatow) will roll their eyes at the tired characterizations and the been-there-seen-that improvisation. Sure, Ferrell still invests every ounce of his soul into his character and comes up with a handful of genuinely hilarious bits (including a bear attack in the final moments of the film), but injecting some extra F-bombs into a film isn’t enough to guarantee a laugh from me. I prefer comedies that amuse my brain as much as my gut.

The most disappointing aspect of ‘Semi-Pro’ is the potential and wit buried beneath its faulty execution. Had the film smartly skewered its era like ‘Anchorman,’ toyed with fans and detractors of its sport like ‘Talladega Nights,’ or satirized the conventions of its athletes like ‘Blades of Glory,’ I would be writing a completely different review. I don’t approach a Will Ferrell comedy for academic humor, but I do expect to be hit with something I haven’t seen before. ‘Semi-Pro’ simply runs through the paces of a Will Ferrell comedy without ever finding its focus or allowing the actor to work his magic. The production honestly feels rushed -- it’s as if the filmmakers only had a few days to shoot the first draft of a script. It might have worked as a straight-to-video cash-in, but it flops as a feature film.

Don’t misunderstand, I’m as bummed as the next guy -- I usually adore Will Ferrell movies and often find myself laughing at his expressions, even when he’s simply standing in the background of a shot. ‘Semi-Pro’ was a big letdown from beginning to end and left me wondering what went wrong. It features a great cast, a fantastic parade of cameos, and a solid setup, but it never came close to living up to my expectations. While you should gauge your anticipation on your adoration of Ferrell, prepare yourself for the worst. Luckily, comedy is an extremely subjective genre and I’m sure ‘Semi-Pro’ will make someone somewhere laugh themselves silly.

(Note the Blu-ray edition of ‘Semi-Pro’ includes the 92-minute R-rated theatrical cut and an extended 99-minute Unrated cut. The differences between the two are pretty negligible, but fans of the film will be pleased to get some extra time with the Tropics. New Line has placed both cuts on a single disc, and added a second Blu-ray disc to house all of the supplemental features.)

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

’Semi-Pro’ features a quasi-pleasing 1080p/VC-1 transfer that does a decent job of bringing its flamboyant palette to life. Colors are as decadent as one would expect from the film’s ‘70s-inspired digs, skintones are properly saturated, and black levels are strong. Likewise, fine object detail looks decidedly high-def and manages to enhance the authenticity of the period costumes and locations. The curls in Ferrell’s hair are carefully rendered, fabric has a realistic textural grit, and the reach-out-and-touch-it appearance of each basketball is impressive. Better still, shots of Flint look as low rent as they should since every aging building bears an undeniably worn appearance. In that regard, the transfer strikes an appropriate visual balance between the film’s setting and comedic tone, calling to mind the high-def transfer Paramount minted for ‘Anchorman.’

However, that’s not to say this transfer is a 1080p showcase. Since the picture is entirely dependent on the film’s sometimes hazy source and fluctuating grain fields, it never feels as solid as a recent release should. As it stands, clarity takes a hit every time the filmmakers allow muddy hues to dominate their soft-focus camerawork -- a deadly combination that tends to merge the foreground and background into one layer. Add to that a series of weak contrast levels hindering the dimensionality of the picture and you have a transfer that fails to generate a satisfying illusion of depth. Unfortunately, since I didn’t see ‘Semi-Pro’ in theaters, it’s tough to judge whether these presentation mishaps are the result of directorial intent or evidence of technical deficiencies in the transfer. Either way, the overall visual experience is underwhelming compared to other recent BD releases.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Compared to the video transfer, ‘Semi-Pro’s DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track seems like overkill. Don’t get me wrong, I’m ecstatic when a studio like New Line utilizes the latest and greatest technology the format has to offer -- it’s just that an R-Rated, slapstick comedy isn’t the sort of film I’d grab to show off my audio equipment. In this case, the film’s dialogue is fantastically crisp as it’s distributed across the front channels. Prioritization is spot on, sound effects are scattered accurately throughout the soundfield, and the track’s interior acoustics are surprisingly rich considering the nature of the film. Of course, the limited soundscape didn’t give my LFE channel the workout it’s used to, but it still made an impression by boosting the doom doom of dribbling basketballs and the roar of the stadium crowds.

The biggest downside is that there’s little else to compliment -- the audio mix may be high-end, but it isn’t involving enough to separate ‘Semi-Pro’ from its genre brethren. The rear speakers don’t have a lot to do, I never felt as if I was in the middle of a real stadium, and the film’s ambient effects are too subtle or inconsistent to warrant much praise. As usual, these issues aren’t the result of a shoddy mix, but rather the product of the film’s limited sound design. In the end, this Master Audio track handles everything thrown its way, it just doesn’t have enough to work with to leave a lasting impression.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

’Semi-Pro’ ports all of the special features from the 2-disc DVD and presents all but one of them in high definition. Sadly, the content isn’t funny or interesting. When it shoots for humor it comes up short and when it tries to seriously explore the production it has a hard time maintaining its focus. Ultimately, I appreciated the studio’s technical presentation of the content, but I couldn’t have been more disappointed with the quality of the behind-the-scenes material.

  • The Cutting Room (HD, 15 minutes) -- This dead-on-arrival collection of deleted scenes and alternate takes won’t appeal to anyone who didn’t already thoroughly enjoy the film itself. The deletions are fairly irrelevant to the plot, each extended take is an improvisational bore, and the plodding alternate ending falls flat on its face. The only notable merit of this feature is that the scenes are presented with DTS HD MA 7.1 surround sound.
  • The Man Behind Semi-Pro (HD, 24 minutes) -- Unfortunately, the longest featurette on this release continues the trend and fails to establish any compelling behind-the-scenes momentum. We get a tired parade of cast and crew members that hop from one subject to the next, sometimes without providing a concise indicator that it’s ready to look into other aspects of the production. The entire featurette comes across as a sloppy mess that was cobbled together at the last minute. Even people who loved ‘Semi-Pro’ will find themselves yawning through its mediocre material.
  • Four Days in Flint (HD, 5 minutes) -- This trivial featurette documents the cast and crew interactions with the town of Flint as they were shooting the film. It would have made for a decent chapter in the disc’s lengthier look behind-the-scenes, but as a standalone feature it feels bland and incomplete.
  • Bill Walton Visits the Set (HD, 3 minutes) -- Here’s yet another aimless featurette that should have been lumped into a larger behind-the-scenes documentary. This one looks into basketball legend Bill Walton’s cameo in the film and his personal history with the ABA.
  • A Short History of the ABA (HD, 7 minutes) -- Unlike the rest of the supplemental package, this featurette is actually worth watching. It explores the humble beginnings of the American Basketball Association and its influence on our modern NBA. It uses archive footage, interviews with former players, and comments from the film’s cast and crew to create a decidedly decent (albeit short) glimpse into the history behind ‘Semi-Pro.’
  • Recreating the American Basketball Association (HD, 13 minutes) -- On the other hand, this behind-the-scenes featurette drags on for too long. While it’s a surprisingly deliberate mini-doc that focuses on the basketball training the actors underwent for their roles, it wore out its welcome after five minutes.
  • Flint Tropics Hot Talk with Dick Pepperfield (SD, 2 minutes) -- This pair of in-character skits feature an aged Ferrell reflecting on his glory days in the ABA. Thankfully, both shorts are over in an instant.
  • Love Me Sexy: The Story Behind the One-Hit Wonder (HD, 5 minutes) -- A semi-interesting (pardon the pun) look at the Will Ferrell song that Nile Rodgers transformed into an authentic sounding ‘70s tune. It was a fun but skippable addition to an the otherwise dry supplemental selection.
  • Love Me Sexy: The Music Video (HD, 2 minutes) -- A music video with Will Ferrell featuring the aforementioned ‘70s-style song.
  • Trailers (HD, 5 minutes) – Last but not least, ‘Semi-Pro’ packs in a trio of theatrical trailers that include a teaser, a mainstream preview, and a restricted, unrated trailer.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

New Line continues to add extra content to their Blu-ray releases with exclusives like “Super Agility Trainer,” a high definition BD-Java arcade game. Alas, the game is merely a basketball-themed variation of Pong that gets old after two minutes.

Final Thoughts

Will Ferrell's clunky turn in 'Semi-Pro' didn't do it for me, but the subjectivity of comedies suggest someone out there will probably love it. I found this 2-disc Blu-ray release to be a bit better than the film, offering both an above average transfer and DTS HD MA 7.1 surround track. Unfortunately, some technical flaws and a poor supplemental package fail to make this a valuable release. Give it a rent -- if you enjoy the film, this BD edition is a no-brainer.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc/BD-25 Single-Layer Disc
  • Two-Disc Set

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS HD Lossless Master Audio 7.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • Spanish Subtitles

Supplements

  • Featurettes
  • Music Video
  • Theatrical Trailers

Exclusive HD Content

  • Interactive Game

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$14.98
Amazon
$5.09 (66%)
3rd Party
$2.15
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»

Related reviews