Blu-ray
Must Own
4.5 stars
List Price
$49.99
Amazon
$22.99 (54%)
3rd Party
$22.95
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
4.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
5 Stars
Supplements
4 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Must Own

Star Wars: The Force Awakens - 3D: Collector's Edition

Street Date:
November 15th, 2016
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
November 7th, 2016
Movie Release Year:
2015
Studio:
Disney
Length:
136 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Portions of this review appear in my initial review of the non-3D release of Star Wars: The Force Awakens.

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

So much of this could have gone horribly wrong. When George Lucas sold his company, Lucasfilm, to Disney back in 2012, there was a shout of both joy and worry when the Mouse House announced that they would be making a whole new batch of 'Star Wars' movies, starting with this one – Chapter VII in the series. What would Lucasfilm's newest owners do to the beloved franchise? Would they restore it to the glory days of the 70s and 80s, or would the new movies be more like the three prequels – films that have managed to alienate fans over the years, in large part due to their over-reliance on digital effects, their questionable storylines ("the taxation of trade routes" – how exciting!), and borderline acting.

Most of us took a big sigh of relief when Lucasfilm's new president, Kathleen Kennedy, announced director J.J. Abrams would be helming the new Star Wars movie. Those sighs turned to gasps of joy when J.J. made it known that not only would most of the actors from the original trilogy be returning to the roles that made them famous, but that his plan was to return to the look of those original films as well: using CGI when he needed to (and rest assured, there's still plenty in 'The Force Awakens'), but also using as many practical effects as he could. This wouldn't be a movie that just had actors standing in front of green screens. There was going to be a tangible feel to the new Star Wars film.

Well, I've said it before and I'll say it again: J.J. Abrams saved my childhood. Not only does 'The Force Awakens' live up to expectations, it surpasses them – giving fans what is clearly the best 'Star Wars' movie since 1980's 'The Empire Strikes Back'. From beginning to end, the film is a sheer thrill ride, bringing back memories of what it was like to first see the original movie while still providing viewers with a fresh new look at that galaxy far, far away. The movie is not without its problems (which I'll get to in a bit), but considering how badly it might have gone wrong, it's nothing short of a miracle so many things here go so right.

Perhaps the most anticipated thing about 'The Force Awakens' for fans was the return of the original cast – particularly Harrison Ford as Han Solo. He doesn't appear in the movie until a good half-hour in, and by that point most viewers may have forgotten he's going to be in the film at all (which makes his first appearance a nice surprise). It's not that Solo isn't a wonderful addition to the plot (of all the returning cast, Ford has far and away the most screen time – with the possible exception of Peter Mayhew as Chewbacca, who isn't always in the suit, due to Mr. Mayhew's debilitating health), it's that director Abrams does such a great job with the new characters that by this point we realize the returning players aren't necessarily needed to make this an engaging story.

Let's start with Daisy Ridley, an amazing find by the director and casting department. This is Ridley's first movie, but you'd never know it. She plays scavenger Rey, who lives on the desert planet Jakku (which is pretty much like...okay, exactly like...the old Skywalker home of Tatooine) and doesn't realize just how important she might be for the future of the galaxy. After two previous trilogies where the men have taken the reins, it's refreshing to see a woman be the main character of a 'Star Wars' movie, and one that doesn't fall into film clichés about what a female can or can't do in a movie. The character is a great role model for young females who see this film, and this first movie in the trilogy only scratches the surface of what Rey might bring to the remaining two releases.

Next up is John Boyega as the ("Traitor!") stormtrooper-turned-Resistance fighter "Finn" (taken from his trooper FN-2187 designation). A good movie always needs a character the audience can relate to, and for most viewers it will be Finn – who is thrust into action more due to his circumstances than his desire to be a hero. Boyega has to play his part just right or it could have come off as either cowardly or cornball (he's also given the responsibility for much of the film's comic relief), but like Ridley, he nails it – giving us the "everyman" that we can relate to in this new adventure.

The new trio of heroes is rounded out with Poe Dameron, played by Oscar Isaac. Believe it or not, this is a character that wasn't originally intended to stick around – which may indicate why he's somewhat removed from our main characters for much of this movie. But Isaac brings such charm and bravado to Poe (if anyone in this new cast is the "new" Han Solo, this character may be him), he's instantly likeable, and we can only hope that Isaac is given a much bigger role in future movies.

Then there's our new trilogy's primary baddie, Kylo Ren – played by Adam Driver. Another difficult role to get right, as Driver is asked both to be an ominous presence, yet still show a vulnerability to Kylo as well as an unstable personality. Ren is basically the Anakin Skywalker we should have seen in the prequel trilogy had that character been better written (and, let's be honest, better acted). I'm not sure Driver completely pulls it off, but at least he makes his villain interesting to watch, although – of course – it will be hard for any 'Star Wars' movie to ever match Darth Vader from the original trilogy.

Of course, I would be remiss if I didn't mention Harrison Ford, an actor who hasn't shied away from saying how "thin" in depth he thought the Han Solo character was over the years. We also know that it's a character he begged George Lucas to kill off in the original trilogy, just to give him some meaning and weight to the proceedings. Well, 'The Force Awakens' gives us the most on-screen Solo we've seen since 'The Empire Strikes Back', and this is very much Ford's movie. The old Solo swagger is back, but also here is a wisdom and maturity that has evolved the character over the years. While he's still the Han we know and love, he also serves very much as the "Obi-Wan Kenobi" character here – an older character with knowledge about the galaxy that leads our new heroes on their adventure. Of course, the similarities don't end there, but that would be telling!

Which brings us to the large AT-AT Walker in the room – the biggest criticism of 'The Force Awakens' (and a valid one), which is that this movie borrows a lot from the original movie, 'A New Hope'. Once again, we have a young 'nobody' from a desert world thrust into a struggle for galactic power. Once again, a little droid is holding vital information that everybody wants to get their hands on, and – most significantly – once again, the bad guys have a superweapon designed to blow up entire worlds. These similarities certainly prevent 'The Force Awakens' from being a "great" movie (although it's still a really good one), but let's also not pretend that the creators didn't know exactly what they were doing here. I mean does everyone really think that J.J. Abrams and writer Lawrence Kasdan weren't aware of how much cribbing they were doing from the original film? Obviously the intention here was to re-introduce us to this universe by reminding us what was so great about it in the first place. Whether that was the right move or not is up to each viewer to decide, but I, for one, wasn't really bothered by the fact that so much of this story is familiar territory. Now, if Chapter VIII is a carbon-copy of 'The Empire Strikes Back', then I think fans will have a more legitimate gripe.

No, 'The Force Awakens' isn't a perfect movie, but it's about the best 'Star Wars' movie we could have hoped for, especially given the fact that this franchise has been coasting off the good graces of its first two entries for 35 years with a lot of mediocre movie and TV entries in the interim (yes, I'm going to get some backlash over that statement...let the hate flow through you!). This newest film is a return to form and, for the first time in a long time, made me feel like I did when I went to the movies as a kid. It's a remarkable achievement by all involved and I can't wait to see where the story goes from here.

The Blu-Ray: Disc Stats

'Star Wars: The Force Awakens' makes the Kessel Run into the third dimension in this specially packaged Collector's Edition. The three Blu-rays and single DVD are housed inside a sturdy (and glossy) cardboard Digipak trifold which holds two discs each on the center and far right folds (once the tri-fold is open) on those full-card plastic hubs that have the top disc overlapping the bottom disc (so one needs to take the top disc out to gain access to the bottom one). The inside of the tri-fold features a picture from inside the Millennium Falcon cockpit during hyperdrive, while the other folds contain an image of Han and Chewie when they first enter the Millennium Falcon (the inside fold), Kylo Ren and Rey dueling in the snow (the front fold), and Rey and Finn running from the Tie Fighter attack on Jakku (the back fold). This thick-sized tri-fold slides inside an equally thick black slipcase that is made of sturdy cardboard but has had a layer of soft, almost rubbery-like material layered on top of it. The front of the slipcase contains a lenticular image of a blue lightsaber against a snowy wooded background.

In addition to the four discs, the package also includes a pair of inserts: one for digital versions of six different bonus features (all of which are included on this release's bonus disc as well), and the other a code for a 2D digital version of the movie. Oddly the digital code for the movie can only be revealed after removing the sealed wrap of the insert and then peeling off an image of BB-8. Is Disney/Lucasfilm that worried about people stealing codes from boxes? Even so, what does enclosing it in such a manner actually accomplish?

There are no front-loaded trailers on any of the discs in this set, although before one gets to the main menu, they'll be treated to a still image of BB-8, where viewers need to make their language selection. The main menu on all discs is the same design – a still shot of the inside of the crashed Star Destroyer on Jakku, with a tilted screen in the background showing a montage of video footage (from the movie on the movie disc(s) and from the bonus materials on the bonus disc). Interestingly, the movie's name does not appear anywhere on the menu screen. Menu selections go horizontally across the bottom of the screen.

The three Blu-rays in this set are all region-free; however, the DVD is Region 1 only.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

In a wonderful decision by director J.J. Abrams (with both Lucasfilm and Disney backing him), 'The Force Awakens' is shot on film – giving it a look that is far more in line with the original trilogy than the prequel trilogy (even though 'The Phantom Menace' was also shot on film). It was shot primarily on Panaflex Millennium XL2 35 cameras, although several scenes were shot on and for the IMAX format. The movie is presented in the 2.40:1 ratio, and in case you're wondering – no, the IMAX sequences do not 'open up'...they're also in 2.40:1 (this is true of both the 3D and 2D versions).

First my thoughts on the 3D....

I saw 'The Force Awakens' five times in theaters...once in IMAX 3D and four times in ReadD 3D, so I became pretty familiar with how this movie looked in three dimensions last winter, and I'm happy to say this home video version replicates that experience quite well.

The movie, of course, wasn't shot with 3D cameras, but is rather an post-conversion, but still looks really good. The key thing here is the depth of the image, and there's some wonderful shots that show it off, starting with the early sequence when Rey is scavenging aboard the crashed Star Destroyer. There's not much in terms of things that pop out of the screen, but there is that still shot of the Star Destroyer hovering in space that got some 'ooohs' from audience members every time I saw the movie in the theater and it has the same impact here. Those who enjoyed the 3D version in the theater should equally enjoy this home video version.

The 2D disc uses the exact same transfer as the last release...so here were my thoughts back when that version first hit home video....

I really only have one complaint about this otherwise excellent presentation of the movie, and that's that it appears to be just a tad on the dark side (if you'll pardon the annoying pun). While the daylight scenes look just fine for the most part, scenes like the opening invasion of the Jakku village, some of the Star Destroyer scenes, and the scenes where Kylo Ren addresses Snoke seem darker than they should be. I compared the Blu-ray with the digital version and they seem to be exactly the same in terms of contrast and brightness, so this appears to be exactly how the filmmakers want the movie to look – I just remember the movie being a tad brighter in the theatrical presentation. The results are negligible, but such scenes do seem to have a little less 'pop' than they should. Black levels still manage to be pretty deep, but there are a few instances of crush, particularly in those early Jakku scenes (where Kylo's outfit just appears as a black blur in a few shots).

But the above is really nitpicking on my part – something I'd be unlikely to even comment on in other reviews, but this is 'Star Wars' after all, and home viewers are no doubt going to demand a level of excellence from Lucasfilm and Disney. So with those minor quibbles aside, this is by and far an excellent looking transfer, with not a hint of dirt, debris, aliasing, banding, haloing (although J.J.'s lens flares are more frequent and evident than I remember even seeing on the big theater screen), or other problematic glitches. Perhaps the best thing here is that this film keeps the appearance of film on Blu-ray. It doesn't look over-digitized or overly sharpened. There's a warm, natural look to the movie that is pleasing to the eye. Colors are nicely saturated without being pushed to the limits or bleeding. Skin tones are consistent and facial features are well defined. I don't think it's much of a stretch to say that this is probably the best-looking of the seven available 'Star Wars' features on Blu-ray...and the good news is that there appear to be no changes or tinkering from the original theatrical version – so hang on to this one, who knows what they'll do with future releases!

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Both the 3D and 2D disc offer up the same audio options as last time around, and my thoughts haven't changed much. I did get a bit of forum feedback last time around on giving the 7.1 track a reference-quality score, and while I understand the complaints (that the surrounds don't provide as much 'oomph' or 'weight' as they should), I also stand by my opinion that the track is a proper rendition of how the film sounded in theaters.

Anyway, here's what you need to know about the audio....

Since 'The Force Awakens' was released in select theaters with Dolby Atmos audio, many fans may be disappointed to hear that the Blu-rays only contain a 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track. But, wow, what a track this is! Usually when a big budget action movie gets a Blu-ray audio track, the mix makes the mistake of pumping up the aggressive sounds so it's nothing short of an assault on one's eardrums. In such cases, said sequences are usually mixed disproportionally with dialogue, so the spoken word often sounds much lower than it should. There are no such issues here, as this 7.1 lossless track gets everything right.

The feeling of immersiveness is quite wonderful as well, as viewers/listeners are going to feel like they're right in the middle of the action. The track also makes frequent and fun use of directionality, as TIE fighters, X-wings, and the beloved Millennium Falcon will swoop from one side of the room to the other seamlessly. Even when the movie isn't involved in action, most scenes have the feeling of hustle and bustle all around, like when Poe is brought aboard the Star Destroyer early in the movie, or when Han, Finn, and Rey visit Maz Kanata's castle.

I don't consider myself a huge audiophile. As long as a track is competently produced and free of any major glitches or distractions, I'm usually satisfied with it. But I can't remember a recent audio track that was as much sheer fun as the one we get on this release. It literally adds to ones enjoyment of the movie and the overall entertainment value of this release.

In addition to the lossless 7.1 track, Spanish and French 5.1 Dolby Digital tracks are also available, as is an English 2.0 Descriptive Audio track. Subtitles are available in English SDH, Spanish, and French.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

2D Movie Blu-ray

  • Audio Commentary with J.J. Abrams – The only difference between the 2D movie disc in this release and the one in the prior release is this commentary track from the film's director. For those who haven't heard him do a track before, J.J. always provides a perfect mix between telling listeners/viewers how he shot something, why he shot it that way, plus some interesting behind-the-scenes tidbits. And while this track doesn't reveal and secrets about any of the characters on screen, J.J. at least does address why 'The Force Awakens' is intentionally similar to the original Star Wars film, 'A New Hope'.

Bonus Blu-ray

  • Secrets of 'The Force Awakens': A Cinematic Journey (HD, 69 min.) – The longest and best bonus feature on this release, this documentary (directed by Laurent Bouzereau) is broken into four parts, which can be watched all together or separately. This is basically an overview of the making of the movie, from preproduction to the completion of shooting. There are comments here from virtually every major player in the cast and crew (although Domhnall Gleeson is suspiciously absent) and a number of nice moments captured on camera. This is however, not exactly the most in-depth documentary I've seen on the making of a movie, and die-hard fans may be disappointed that there's not much inside info or revealing tidbits provided here. While a big chunk of the documentary is devoted to Harrison Ford, there's not a single mention of the injury he sustained to his leg during the filming. Make no doubt, this is a fun watch, but given how much they might have (and perhaps should have) shown about the making of this movie, one can't feel a little cheated here.
  • The Story Awakens: The Table Read (HD, 4 min.) – No, sadly this isn't the entire table read that the cast did of the script. Instead it's a brief featurette about that day, showcasing a bit of Mark Hamill's reading, but not a whole lot more. This, and the remainder of brief featurettes on this release just seem like moments that were deleted from the longer documentary (and, in fact, I wouldn't be surprised if they all were).
  • Crafting Creatures (HD, 9 ½ min.) – A look at some of the various creature designs that were made for the film – focusing primarily on the ones we see in Maz's castle and on Jakku.
  • Building BB-8 (HD, 6 min.) – A look at how the filmmakers created everybody's favorite new droid, BB-8, including how J.J. Abrams originally came up with the idea of what he should look like.
  • Blueprint of a Battle: The Snow Fight (HD, 7 min.) – A behind-the-scenes look at the shooting of the movie's climatic lightsaber duel, which wasn't shot in a real forest, but a Pinewood Studios set built to look like one.
  • ILM: The Visual Magic of the Force (HD, 8 min.) – Although J.J. Abrams insisted on creating practical effects when possible, that doesn't mean that 'The Force Awakens' is without its share of digital effects. The featurette takes a look at some of them, as created by Lucasfilm's Industrial Light & Magic.
  • John Williams: The Seventh Symphony (HD, 7 min.) – Although I think 'The Force Awakens' is Williams' weakest score among the seven 'Star Wars' movies, this segment nevertheless gives fans a look at his scoring of the movie, including comments from Williams himself.
  • Deleted Scenes (HD, 6 ½ min.) – The deleted scenes on this release include the six seen on the prior release, plus three that didn't make the prior Blu-ray. Each brief scene isn't quite finished, which means it's not been color corrected for the film and those segments involving special effects aren't in their final version, either. A timer code appears in the upper left corner of all six scenes, which can be watched all together or individually. They consist of: 'Finn and the Villager' (½ min.), 'Jakku Message' (1 min.), 'X-wings Prepare for Lightspeed' (½ min.), 'Kylo Searches the Falcon' (1 min.), 'Snow Speeder Chase' (1 min.), 'Finn will be Fine' (½ min.), 'Leia & The Resistance' (15 sec.), 'Unkar Plutt at Maz's Castle' (1 min.), and 'Tunnel Standoff' (1 min.).
  • Force for Change (HD, 3 ½ min.) – This featurette pays homage to the thousands of fans who donated for Force for Change, a charity Lucasfilm set up to donate money to UNICEF as well as other great causes over the past several years.
  • Foley: A Sonic Tale (HD, 4 min.) – A look at the sound effects of 'The Force Awakens', featuring comments from Foley Artists Denise Thorpe and Jana Vance.
  • Sounds of the Resistance (HD, 7 min.) – While the foley artist featurette looked at some of the natural sounds made for the movie, this one takes a look at some of the sounds created digitally by the folks at Skywalker Sound.
  • Dressing the Galaxy (HD, 6 ½ min.) – Yep, you guessed it. This is a featurette devoted to costume design. Included here are comments from Costume Designer Michael Kaplan.
  • The Scavenger & The Stormtrooper: A Conversation with Daisey Ridley and John Boyega (HD, 12 min.) – This interview with the new stars of 'Star Wars' was a digital exclusive for Target's version of the movie last time out...it's now available for everyone who buys this release.
  • Inside the Armory (HD, 8 min.) – This was also a digital exclusive on the earlier Target release. This one takes a look at some of the prop weapons used in 'The Force Awakens'. Included here are comments from Prop Master Jamie Wilkinson.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are no bonus materials exclusive to this Collector's Edition release.

Final Thoughts

This Collector's Edition release finally gives us the 3D version of the film (which, honestly, should have been included the first time around) and takes on a few extras to boot, the most significant of which is a commentary track from J.J. Abrams. Assuming you have a 3D TV at home, this one easily falls into the "Must Own" category.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 3D/Blu-ray/DVD/Digital HD

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 (2D)
  • 1080p/MVC MPEG-4 (3D)

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • 7.1 English DTS-HD Master Audio
  • 5.1 French Dolby Digital
  • 5.1 Spanish Dolby Digital
  • 2.0 English Descriptive Audio

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH, Spanish, and French

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary with J.J. Abrams
  • Secrets of 'The Force Awakens': A Cinematic Journey
  • The Story Awakens: The Table Read
  • Crafting Creatures
  • Building BB-8
  • Blueprint of a Battle: The Snow Fight
  • ILM: The Visual Magic of the Force
  • John Williams: The Seventh Symphony
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Force for Change
  • Foley: A Sonic Tale
  • Sounds of the Resistance
  • Dressing the Galaxy
  • The Scavenger & The Stormtrooper: A Conversation with Daisey Ridley and John Boyega
  • Inside the Armory

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$49.99
Amazon
$22.99 (54%)
3rd Party
$22.95
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»