Blu-ray
Recommended
3.5 stars
List Price
$19.95
Amazon
$12.69 (36%)
3rd Party
$8.18
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
5 Stars
HD Video Quality
2.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3.5 Stars
Supplements
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Recommended

Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog

Street Date:
May 25th, 2010
Reviewed by:
Nate Boss
Review Date: 1
May 17th, 2010
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
New Video DVD
Length:
42 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Best. Web. Series. Ever.

The WGA strike in 2007-2008 wasn't necessarily a bad thing. Hear me out, as I now have two reasons to say this. First, the second season of 'Heroes' was mercifully cut in half, as that horrendous pile of concentrated suck (and every episode that followed, really) ruined the delicious taste the first season left in my mouth. Second, the strike opened the door for 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog,' a three part miniature film that aired over the internet, written by Zack and Jed Whedon (along with Maurissa Tancharoen), and was also written and directed by Joss Whedon. You know, the guy who gets cancelled on Fox more regularly than Fox actually produces a good program. Anyways...42 minutes, divided in three acts. A miniature cast, featuring Neil Patrick Harris, Felicia Day, Nathan Fillion, and Simon Helberg. A show that won a 2009 Emmy Award. All that, and singing, lots of singing.

It's so very, very win.

Dr. Horrible (Harris), also known as Billy, is an aspiring super villain, looking to earn entry into the Evil League of Evil, headed by the dreaded Bad Horse. He's also aspiring to win the heart of Penny (Day), a fellow laundromat customer with whom he can hardly strike up a conversation. During a daring heist of a case full of wonderflonium, a chemical needed to complete his Freeze Ray, Dr. Horrible accidentally sets Penny up to be saved by the heroic Captain Hammer (Fillion), and the pair begin to date, much to Horrible's dismay.

After failing to gain the notoriety needed to earn entry into the ELE, Dr. Horrible is left with no choice but to kill Captain Hammer, which will work in his favor two-fold, eliminating the man who constantly thwarts his attempts at criminal behavior (and kicks the shit out of Billy instead of jailing him), and eliminating his roadblock to Penny's heart. As is the case with everything Dr. Horrible touches, things won't always work as so deviously planned.

'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' is pure awesome. This has to be emphasized, especially considering the lackluster history Whedon brought to the table, one that brought forth devoted fans, but little in the way ratings. Going into this release, I was both excited and nervous, considering how great Harris has been ever since his career resurrection in 'Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle' (though his voice performance as Spider-Man in the MTV animated series was enjoyable, as well), and how thoroughly I found Whedon's works to be overhyped. Still glowing from the experience, I suddenly understand why the DVD sold so very well on Amazon.com (which was initially the exclusive distributor).

'Dr. Horrible' throws the musical genre on its head, with such a simplistic set up, no real introduction beyond the viewers seeing a random entry in Dr. Horrible's blog, and a segue from an email Q&A session to singing out of the blue, in a laundromat of all places. Dr. Horrible is about the furthest thing from Dr. Doom, as he's just trying to make a living, in a sense. His best friend, Moist (Helberg), has the power to turn everything he touches really, really wet, like that sweaty guy that's impossible to guard when you're playing basketball in the park, since you really don't want to touch him. Billy has aspirations, huge ones, but he's such an incompetent nit that he doesn't even need Captain Hammer to show up for his plans (or inventions) to fizzle.

The love story works well. The sweet and naive demeanor on display by Day, and the polar opposite hero and villain posturing towards the idealistic neighborhood girl is certainly engrossing. The way Hammer composes himself, you can't help but root for the main character, no matter his intentions, as, ironically, his heart is the purest one of the bunch. Best of all, it seems Harris is left to just do what he does best: entertain, as he leads this tiny cast in every way, with the best range in his musical performances, as well as his body language which is, as always, spot on. He's believable, with his moments of self-revelation (and his complete lack of comprehension as to the circumstances of his actions and bloggings), as well as his plight, a fight he cannot feasibly win, facing the perfect face of justice, who just so happens to be a bully.

Full of hilarious lines, superb performances (particularly by Harris, of course), and an extremely fun atmosphere that sucks the viewer right in, it's hard not to love this little quirky creation, and it's no wonder a sequel is in the works. 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' is a step in the right direction for cinema, showing that it doesn't take ridiculously huge blockbuster ensemble casts, expansive sets, or explosive special effects to be a success, as quality writing alone can win the war, and the hearts of viewers. Shoe string budgets are the easiest to recoup (see: 'Clerks,' 'Paranormal Activity'), and if the show bombs, it's not as though millions of dollars are lost and a studio crippled. A fun and merry take on the superhero genre, with the villain that's impossible to hate, and the hero that's easy to loathe, 'Dr. Horrible' is inventive and silly enough to easily stand head and shoulder above the recent crop of comedies, and while it isn't a $100 million box office bonanza, it's an attention grabber if ever there were one, for all the right reasons.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

While the show itself may be the opposite of horrible, the video for 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' is average at best. The 1080p VC-1 encode at 1.78:1 didn't really do much for me. Colors aren't the least bit bold, while reds are unintentionally fuzzy. Delineation is wimpy, and crushing occurs even in red hair that's just slightly in the shadows. Whites aren't too clean either, with the tiniest noise to the picture not helping matters. Facial features, like stubble on Harris, are a blur. Artifacting is present, though it isn't all that major (unless you watch the end credits, then it's really friggin' bad). Contrast levels are bland and far from praiseworthy. Grain levels flutter a bit, as well. All that said, there's no banding, no apparent DNR or digital manipulation, and no real edge enhancement issues. This release just seems like it's destined to look half baked.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

The packaging for 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' only indicates there is a 5.1 surround mix, and includes the Dolby Digital insignia. It's wrong, thankfully. There are two DTS options (with no Dolby in sight), with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix defaulting, and a DTS 2.0 version available as well (alongside a small variety of subtitles).

Honestly, 'Dr. Horrible' doesn't sound too amazing. I normally will snatch up any musical on Blu-ray (and at times, it burns, due to stinkers like 'Mamma Mia!'), and I can say that what is presented here lacks the presence of nearly every other musical. I can't honestly hold that against this release, though, considering the budget and reason this show even exists. Dialogue is always clear, both spoken and sung, and even in harmonies, both parts come through cleanly. That in itself is an accomplishment, considering two converging sets of lyrics, background music, and discrete effects all come through perfect in those moments. Rears get a nice bleed from musical sequences, and the tiniest, tiniest bit of ambience, that seemingly exists only to exist. Bass presence isn't too strong, but it pops up on a couple of occasions with some nice little bumps. Dynamic range isn't amazing, but there's no feedback or background distortion to distract one from enjoying this film, and this audio track. It's not amazing, but the audio for 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' easily earns a passing grade.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

The supplement package for 'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' is somewhat funny, in that the extras go from absolutely amazing to astonishingly abysmal in five seconds flat.

  • Filmmaker's Commentary - The cast and crew (who introduce themselves so fast that I'm not even going to bother trying to document who all participates) jump back and forth, and spend more time reminiscing than they do commenting. They revel in the success of the show, explain how the intricate "special effects" are done, and generally respond to the show rather than provide insight. Not the best commentary ever, really, but fans may enjoy it. I loved the film, but I really found this one painful.
  • Commentary! The Musical - Now this is the way commentaries should be!!!! This isn't even so much a commentary as it is a constantly self-referential joke/alternate track for the film, full of hilarious songs and gags. More musical than the movie itself, Commentary! refuses to talk about what's on screen, and just wants to mock the process. And it works. It's nowhere near as funny as the film, but it's most certainly the most entertaining commentary I've ever heard, and it's also the most original. The drunk-off-their-asses easter egg commentary on 'A Better Place' will always be my favorite, but this track puts the filmmaker's commentary to utter shame...especially the Ninja Rope song.
  • The Making of Dr. Horrible Featurettes (SD, 20 min) - A three part feature focusing on various parts of the creation of the film. First we focus on the forces in play that helped create the film, from idea to casting and the incorporation of various writer's ideas. Next, the musical elements of the film are dissected and explained, from lyrics creation, to recording. It's worth watching, even if it's very dry. Last up is a general interview and thoughts section, including a rare physical display of kissing one's own ass.
  • ELE Application Videos (SD, 30 min) - I'll admit, some of the zombie video fan submissions (from Myspace) for 'Diary of the Dead' weren't half bad. But asking Joss Whedon fans to create fictional characters? And mug for the camera? And best yet, sing? If you want to see people make complete asses of themselves, watch this...
  • Outtakes (SD, 2 min) - Alright, back to real extras again. Harris is the highlight as he just does "magic tricks" with his hands for the camera. The rest is just...whatever.
  • Behind-the-Scenes (SD, 1 min) - A few shots of actors and crew rehearsing on set.
  • Evil League of Evil Interview (SD, 3 min) - Almost as painful as the application videos, check out the "real" ELE. OMG WTF DIAF.
  • Teaser Trailers (SD, 1 min) - Check out the original teaser for the show.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There is no exclusive content on this release.

Final Thoughts

I love Dr. Horrible, and his completely illogical take on villainy. Joss Whedon has a rabid fan following, and for the life of me I never quite understood why. He was the Arby's value menu of film/television directors in my eyes for many years. Now...well, he might be a $3.29 sandwich, made with double the meat bladder goodness.

'Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog' is the kind of show that will either connect completely with its audience, or fall on deaf ears, perhaps even literally. Personally, I see this title replacing 'Repo! The Genetic Opera' as one of the most played Blu-rays in my household. With average video, and fairly good audio, alongside extras that are both amazing and life threateningly awful, this title is easy to recommend, especially with the low MSRP bringing some great pre-order pricing.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD25 Single Layer Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.78:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1
  • English DTS 2.0

Subtitles/Captions

  • English, Spanish, French, German, Japanese, Chinese

Supplements

  • Commentary with the cast and creators
  • "Commentary! The Musical": 42 minutes of all new music where the cast and creators ignore the movie and sing about the writers' strike... and each other
  • Behind-the-scenes featurettes on the making of the movie and the music
  • The top 10 video applications submitted by fans who want to join the Evil League of Evil
  • Three Easter eggs: blooper reel, rehearsal footage, and up-close-and-personal interviews with the members of the Evil League of Evil

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$19.95
Amazon
$12.69 (36%)
3rd Party
$8.18
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»

Related reviews