Blu-ray
Worth a Look
3 stars
Overall Grade
3 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2 Stars
HD Video Quality
3 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
4 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Worth a Look

Elektra: Director's Cut

Street Date:
May 4th, 2010
Reviewed by:
Nate Boss
Review Date: 1
June 3rd, 2010
Movie Release Year:
2004
Studio:
20th Century Fox
Length:
100 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

"Elektra...like the tragedy."

Like, indeed.

With the lukewarm adaptation of 'Daredevil' in 2003, fans of the comic got what they should get in a comic book movie: a story about the main characters: Daredevil, Bullseye, Kingpin, and Elektra. Of course, fans of the comic also know that the man who created Elektra, Frank Miller ('Sin City'), also killed her. Comics being what they are, of course she didn't stay dead (few do). There was still too much to be done for the female warrior/assassin. As much hate as 'Daredevil' was shown, even its (hugely) inferior theatrical cut stacks up better than the spin-off film it would inspire, as Jennifer Garner ('Alias') would again be tapped to play the hooker with the heart of...no, sorry, the deadly yet warm hearted tragic character. Apparently, neither she nor the fine folks at Marvel or Fox learned their lesson the first time when audiences almost universally decried "do not want."

The powers of light and darkness have waged a timeless battle, one that will only end when one warrior tips the balance between good and evil. This warrior will be lured by both sides, as she is a living and breathing weapon. Elektra, risen from the dead, doesn't seem to have much light in her, as she takes odd assassination jobs, killing with a frenzy that shows her disconnect from the humanity in which she once lived. But when a well paying assignment to take out two targets doesn't sit right with the merciless anti-hero, and the job is refused, Elektra will become a target herself, as the powerful forces of The Hand seek to destroy all that is good. Elektra is forced to protect the two would-be targets, despite not knowing why The Hand wants them dead, while trying to avoid the autopsy table herself for a second time.

When I first saw 'Elektra,' I was greatly dismayed. As loathed as it is, I've always had a soft spot for 'Daredevil,' despite all its flaws, and its massively superior director's cut resides near the top in my favorite superhero film list. Elektra was a one-dimensional character in either cut of the film, with horrible development, cringe-inducing chemistry with the heroes and villains alike, and entrances so contrived that she may as well have parachuted into the film at random intervals. Her death in that film was well deserved. Bullseye on the other hand, played with a nasty, brooding appeal by Colin Farrell, was given an ending that opened the door for a return.

They brought back the wrong character.

Superheroines haven't been blockbuster material, as 'Supergirl' and 'Catwoman' proved. Part of the problem is the lack of respect given to the characters, with cheeseball writing placing emphasis more on sex appeal than feats and sacrifices implausible to the ordinary man or woman. 'Elektra' may have been one of the final nails in that particular coffin.

It's not Garner's fault. She plays the part more convincingly her second time around, as she's believable in her struggles with her own mortality, love and loss, and responsibility, and despite being a zombie, she holds back her craving for the flesh of the living, which is quite admirable. She's cold and enclosed, yet warm and open at the same time. There's even a part of her yearning for Matt Murdock, her past lover, but that scene was cut. Apparently 'Elektra' had a "no Affleck" clause. Of course, her dialogue remains painful, but that isn't exactly her fault. It's not like she asks what happens to toads when they're struck by lightning, or anything.

What makes a good action film is the villain. The best James Bond films have the more memorable villains, and the same can be said about comic book flicks. With 'Elektra,' there is no obvious lead villain. We get Kirigi (Will Yun Lee), the leader of The Hand, and his powers are a complete unknown. Behind him, there's a band of faceless ninja fodder, and a pile of superpowered beings - superpowered beings so meaningless that they're hardly even given names in the film. They just show up. Wow, a really strong/impervious guy. Scary. Gee, a guy whose tattoos come to life. Thank goodness he doesn't have one of Captain America wearing assless chaps. Then there's Typhoid, a play on the Daredevil villain Typhoid Mary, only she is never truly given a name in the film. Her powers work, and they're a doozy, as she poisons and kills everything around her, and she was at one time considered the great prize that light and darkness fight over. With so many villains, you'd think there would be at least one who could take more than a single punch without disintegrating. It's a tad anti-climactic, considering they're fighting the only person other than Jesus and Lazarus to be resurrected.

Elektra's change of heart, the one that creates the conflict in the film, isn't truly explained either, especially considering the fact she caught one of the two targets stealing from her the day before. Hell, give me the chance to take down someone who wronged me, to get away scott free with it, and get paid to do it, and I'd be halfway to my weapons cache before you could even finish the proposition. Perhaps, since Elektra is a motherless daughter, she feels for the people she is supposed to kill, as she sees a lot of herself in the daughter (Kirsten Prout). Perhaps it's just damn lazy to play "mommy" issues in a film about a ruthless assassin. 'Elektra' is full of one-dimensional characters, despite the fact that the titular character is actually fully realized. Much like Buzz Lightyear in the middle of 'Steamboat Mickey,' she doesn't quite fit in the menagerie surrounding her as such. Fight scenes can be interesting, but at times can be incredibly frustrating, while silly CG effects are overused, cheapening the entire affair.

'Elektra' was received better this second time around, but damn if it isn't still a failure of a comic book film.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Elektra' can spin its sais around all bad ass, look at me menacingly, and even run at me while screaming to try to intimidate me, but damn if I'm not going to a) hope that happens so I can get closer to Jennifer Garner than any of you without having to be named Ben Affleck, b) scream like a little girl and soil myself, c) call it out for looking straight out of 2006, or d) all of the above.

The 1080p 2.35:1 AVC MPEG-4 encode looks similar to what fans would expect with the notoriously bland MPEG-2 discs Fox used to put on the market. The problems start from the opening sequences, and continue on through the rest of the film, marring the promising moments. Delineation is problematic throughout, but at least that's consistent. Detail is just all over the place. Shots can go from beautifully sharp, where you can see stray hairs leaping from any body part (and yes, that includes Garner's chinny chin chin) or wear and tear on a pair of sais, to blurry, muddled messes, that are too ugly and prolonged to miss. Artifacting is a minor issue, while noise pops up on more than a few occasions. Skin tones are notoriously awful, as characters constantly look like they're staring at a funeral pyre, with yellows and oranges enveloping them. There's some ringing in flashbacks, but this may be an aesthetic choice, since natural shots sport fantastic edges. Shots can look overly digital to the point that 'Tron' doesn't seem too far removed, but that isn't so much a transfer issue as it is an effects issue brought to light more by the bump in resolution. Aliasing pops up a few times, mostly in the longer hair of the two female leads.

One last thing...the multiple choice question above was a trick, I'm afraid. Not because both options a and c were equally correct, but because I'd hire Colin Farrell to go all Bullseye up on her again, and that wasn't one of the choices.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

The audio for 'Elektra' is pretty damn impressive, honestly. With a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix leading the way, this subpar film feels like a blockbuster, and the mix reminded me a bit of the more recent action extravaganzas, both in strengths and weaknesses. From the very start, we get proper ambience, light movement, great use of the entire soundstage, and some light atmospheric bass action. Bullets move through rooms perfectly, with great pitch variance. The dart gun also shows off, with an even higher pitch, and just as much movement. Sais, as well as some punches and kicks, cut through the air, leaving a high pitched waft behind them. There's some (exaggerated) pronounced thuds on any fighting move impact, as though the film were some cheesy kung fu flick, with plenty of localization for each blow or impending attack.

The entire time watching 'Elektra,' I felt as though the film were designed to put me in her shoes, as the entire room is immersed realistically, and the effect worked so much better than other experiences that tried to mimic this effect. Volume spikes properly for some good jump moments and presence, and, when called for, quietness also played a solid part in this release that has dynamic range and speaker usage aced. So why not a higher score? The dialogue for the film often finds itself being left behind, as it is never anywhere near as loud or prioritized as action, leaving a somewhat lopsided balance to the whole affair. 'Elektra' will give a good home theater a proper workout, but it just isn't demo material.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Few films deserve such thorough supplement packages. Sometimes it's just beating a dead horse, or documenting the uninteresting. 'Elektra' may be one of the oddest choices to get such a superb and expansive pile of goodies, which often overshadow the quality of the film itself.

I just wish there were more effort in the menu. I don't mind the static background, but the way selections work, the selector is slow to respond to commands (on both of my players), and there is a general sense of unease to the whole thing. Go to the deleted scenes tab, and you have to press to the side to play all. If you press off, for the commentary option, it just selects commentary to on, leading you to have to fix it. Pressing up at any time resets the menu back to normal, another annoyance.

  • Audio Commentary - With Rob Bowman and Kevin Stitt. The pair discuss studio relations, how they went back and forth on editing and working with Fox to make changes to the film, location scouting in Vancouver, reveal on-set anecdotes and production stories, and discuss every facet of production for this film. Of course, they also do this in the two Relentless features found in this supplement package as well. This track has tons of coverage, but it isn't exactly amazing, or really all that enlightening, despite all the info thrown out there.
  • Relentless: The Making of 'Elektra' - Part 1: Production (SD, 87 min) - Studios, take note. If you want to be detailed in presenting your movie in your extras, this is a good start. From her death in 'Daredevil' to the creative ideas to make the film stand on its own two legs, we get to see the creative process from concept forward. We see the early days of principal photography, with early analysis of the work of each actor, plenty of talk concerning interactions between cast and crew, looks at Garner doing martial arts (with plenty of behind-the-scenes shots that give a new appreciation to the otherwise awful film), explanation on how Bowman directs (and he seems somewhat realistic in his expectations and attitude), neat looks at supporting actors, and more. Fans of 'Elektra,' this is a must see, particularly in conjunction with the next extra.
  • Relentless: The Making of 'Elektra'- Part 2: Post-Production (SD, 53 min) - Watch the editorial process, once filming has been completed, as ideas about structure are kicked around between Stitt and Bowman. The idea of just moving shots around liberally made my head hurt, as it shows a lack of real foresight and vision. That said, to see the creative process so extensively cannot be ignored, even if the duo may be frustrating. We see ADs (assistant directors) discussing their duties as they're being performed, we see Bowman complain about studio notes (suck it up, it's their money you're playing with!!!), see different title sequences (and watch the crew debate their strengths and weaknesses, including proposed chicken art!), sound design and visual effects creation (and a laid back proofing session), and on through scoring the film. Damn. Just damn. This is an extra, folks. This is a damn good extra.
  • Showdown at the Well: Multi-Angle Dailies (SD, 2 min) - Watch scenes progress from various angles, or all at once (which I prefer), from three different views on the first clip, while only two angles on the rest of the footage. Lots of sai on sword action, but not a lot of interest to be found.
  • Deleted Scenes (SD, 5 min) - With optional commentary by Rob Bowman and Kevin Stitt. A guest appearance by Matt Murdock (Ben Affleck, 'Daredevil') in a dream sequence is the only major loss, as the rest is a whole lot of nothin'.
  • Alternate/Extended Scenes (SD, 13 min) - A prolonged alternate opening sequence, random shots with unfinished SFX, and plenty of uninteresting extensions. The alternate takes on fight scenes are nice, but that's about it.
  • The Mythology (SD) - This feature has two sections. 'Elektra': Incarnations (53 min) is just what the comic fan ordered. Meet the men behind the Elektra comics and appearances in Marvel Comics, including Frank Miller of 'Sin City' fame. Miller, the man who created the Elektra character, has the most to say, and is also the most interesting. We see the origins of the character, her comic book resurrection (who doesn't revive in the comics, save for Gwen Stacey?!?!), artistic choices in coloring and drawing the femme fatale from a few different generations of creators, as well as dissections of storylines that were never used that would flesh out the character (another instance of Editor Joe Quesada screwing up at every chance), as well as character analyzation compared to other similar characters, like Wolverine (though Frank Castle, the Punisher, is also a great parallel). Comic fans, watch this. Elektra in Greek Mythology (15 min) analyzes the Greek tragedies of ancient years, with the various incarnations of the character. It's really dry and boorish. Dry, dry, dry, and even with all that, I'm not even close to describing how lacking this follow up is.
  • Trailers (SD) - There is one teaser trailer, and one theatrical trailer, both in standard def.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There is no exclusive content on this release.

Comparing Releases

The USA edition of 'Elektra' comes months after numerous other countries received their version, and there are quite a few differences. For this discussion, the Hong Kong import will be compared to the domestic release.

Most noticeably, the cuts of the film vary between releases. Each of the European releases (and the Hong Kong version) are the theatrical edition of the film, which runs 97 minutes, featuring the white and red cover art, whereas the USA release receives the extended cut of the film, which runs 3 minutes longer, and is identical to the second release (the two disc edition) DVD. The USA Blu-ray is marked Region A, but plays in any Blu-ray player, regardless of country, while the Hong Kong Blu-ray marks the Region properly as A/B/C

The menu screen and sounds are the same, but there are some drastic differences. First, there is a website link in the extras section of the Hong Kong version, and no commentary track as is found in the English release. More importantly, there are about a billion more dub and subtitle options for the film. Whereas the USA release only has English (lossless), French and Spanish (lossy) options, the Hong Kong version boasts a French DTS track, as well as Portuguese, Italian, Latin Spanish, Russian, Castilian Spanish, Czech, Hungarian, Polish, Thai, and Turkish Doby Digital mixes. Additionally, instead of just English and Spanish subs, there are also Cantonese, Mandarin, Korean, Thai, Danish, Finnish, Italian, Latin Spanish, Dutch, Norwegian, Russian, Castilian Spanish, Swedish, Bulgarian, Croatian, Czech, Arabic, Greek, Hungarian, Icelandic, Hebrew, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Slovenian, and Turkish subs. Phew, try saying all that in one breath.

Quality wise, the Hong Kong version has a slight difference in video quality, with a tad less blurriness, more cleanly defined facial features, and more defined, clean blacks. It isn't drastic, by any means, but it is apparent. I could not discern any dramatic inequalities in the lossless English tracks. Both are quite good.

Final Thoughts

'Elektra' isn't necessarily a good movie, but there are worse comic book movies out there. On my first go round with the film, I couldn't have been more disappointed, but going into it this time, with rock bottom expectations, I wasn't anywhere near as let down. The Fox Blu-ray has some pretty meh video, good audio, and a superb pile of extras. It matches up fairly nicely with the Hong Kong release as well, and offers the slightly extended cut of the film. As much as I hate to say this, 'Elektra' is worth a look.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • Region A/B/C (designated as Region A)
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English Subtitles
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Documentaries
  • Featurette
  • Deleted Scenes with optional commentary
  • Alternate and Extended Scenes with optional commentary
  • Multi-Angle Dailies

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.