Blu-ray
Recommended
4 stars
Amazon
$13.26
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
3.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
4.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4.5 Stars
Supplements
3 Stars
High-Def Extras
1 Stars
Bottom Line
Recommended

The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus

Street Date:
April 27th, 2010
Reviewed by:
Nate Boss
Review Date: 1
April 13th, 2010
Movie Release Year:
2009
Studio:
Sony
Length:
122 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

To call the passing of Heath Ledger a tragedy is an understatement, as the young actor seemed to be breaking through the glass ceiling, with superb performances in rapid succession. His death, in January of 2008, left fans devastated, family broken, a daughter left with no father, Batman fanatics deeply concerned with thoughts of whether the film was completed and ready, and one project still filming.

In the hands of an ordinary director, the unfortunate accidental overdose would have ended the film, but with Terry Gilliam leading the charge of 'The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus,' that would not be the case, justified as it may have been. The lunacy of the director's filmography is almost unrivaled, and with the amazing selfless acts of three friends, Ledger's final film role would see the light of day, and, amazingly, would be somewhat coherent in the final result.

"You can't stop stories being told..."

"That's a weak hypothesis."

Doctor Parnassus (Christopher Plummer) is unique. A former monk, the thousand year old man threw away immortality in a deal with the devil (Tom Waits as Mr. Nick) for love, a love that climaxed with the birth of Valentina (Lily Cole). As is the case with any deal, there are two sides, and the time is coming near for the Devil to get his dues. The traveling theater group led by Parnassus, through which wayward souls are transported into the world of their imagination is on hard times in modern day London, and Valentina, unbeknownst to her, has only a few days left before becoming the property of Mr. Nick. A chance encounter, of sorts, that finds the troupe saving the life of a man hung beneath a bridge gives hope to the crew, though the mystery surrounding the man's background is of great concern. In a new wager with Mr. Nick, Parnassus must save five souls before the Devil claims five of his own, all the participants of the traveling Imaginarium. It seems Parnassus has the leg up, as the man soon known as Tony (Ledger), a charismatic showman who can bring in the female audience, brings attention to the almost forgotten world that is so easily attained by walking through the mirror. With time running out, it's not so much a race as it is a chess game, with everything to lose.

I was deeply concerned as to how well the film would work, considering that it was rumored that only half of Ledger's performance was filmed, and the somewhat lengthy production suspension that resulted from his departure. With Johnny Depp, Colin Farrell, and Jude Law volunteering their time (and giving all their earnings to Ledger's daughter), any non-magical film would have been impossible. Perhaps it's magic, or sheer, blind luck, that this film ever saw the light of day, instead of being shelved due to tragedy. Amazingly, the four-way performance actually works in the grand scope of the story, and adds a layer of intrigue and suspense, with some slight rewrites explaining the changes perfectly...so well, in fact, that one can easily forget that they were made out of necessity, rather than as a part of the original design.

Performances are magical, as Plummer is awesome as the old man who may or may not be a true marvel of the mind, while Cole does a solid job in just her third film role. Waits is a marvel as the devil himself, fitting the nasty, tempting, game playing trickster found in the more classic portrayals. But, despite the fact that these three players are the pivotal members of the story, the focus lies solely on the four Tonys, as it were. Ledger will be remembered, in death, for his turn as the Joker in 'The Dark Knight,' but his final performance is nothing to scoff at, as he fits the bill quite nicely. No disrespect to Ledger, but the three fill-ins do, at times, overshadow the man they're mimicking. Depp takes the first turn, and steals the show the moment he removes his mask, for his brief period of time (which was filmed in less than two days due to obligations on 'Public Enemies'). Law adds a level of child-like glee with his turn, becoming the focus of a fantasy of his own, escaping his pursuers, and his reality for a brief moment. The best performance of the entire film, though, bar none, belongs to Bullseye himself, Colin Farrell. Easily discounted for some less-than-stellar film decisions, the man can certainly act, and his body movements, expressions, and even his eyes convey the character with love and respect, filling the shoes left behind in a manner that is very much a tribute. He is given the most difficult segment of the film, emotionally, with the climax, and hits a home run that still has to touch down to Earth.

Amazingly, the use of four actors in one role works quite well, and any fill-in or double work for real world Tony (Ledger) doesn't distract. Far from it. It's mind-boggling, really, that the role was completed as much as it was, with the real world elements all being done (or near-done), to the point that just the worlds of imagination that Tony would enter would need filming, making the rewrite quite painless and natural, rather than complicated. After a short while, viewers can find themselves slipping into the worlds portrayed in the Imaginarium and accepting them, rather than reminding themselves of the auspicious circumstances that led to the changes.

'The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus' feels very much like a Gilliam film, with whimsey replacing logic, and extravagant, over-the-top, sensational special effects sometimes replacing story. In a sense, 'Imaginarium' feels like a distant cousin to 'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen,' with the heavy focus on stage plays, accepting the extraordinary and imaginative, and the diverse cast of oddball characters (as well as the potential to view the film dismissively, as a work of imagination or exaggeration, rather than the real events). The film has an interesting theme, with the plays of classic stageplay sensibilities and trickery against modern virtues of scepticism, as well as the old saying "your past will always catch up to you." Mystery makes the film work, yet at the same time, I can see the big reveals playing a big hand in giving the film great replay value, for those hidden "ah-ha!" moments that make Gilliam films work. That said, all the Gilliam magic on display here does not make up for the fact that the tools of the Python himself have gotten a bit rusty, and overly self-indulgent.

Untimely and unfortunate death could not stop this story from being told. The loss of Ledger overshadows the film, and I know that not one single person would keep this film if they could have Heath Ledger back in this world. But we're not given that choice, and must accept the hand given to us. We lost a shining star that day in January, and while this film may be an all-too blunt reminder of what we did lose (particularly with the introduction of the Tony character into the story), rather than mourn the world's loss, we should celebrate his existance and his works, just as Law, Depp, Farrell, and Gilliam do here.

The Disc: Vital Stats

'The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus' is housed on a BD50 Dual Layer Disc, with an odd Region A/B playback status (why no C?). There is a glut of pre-menu content that cannot be skipped through the top menu button, so keep that finger ready on the next chapter button!

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

Sony brings 'The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus' to Blu-ray with an AVC MPEG-4 encode at 1080p (in the 1.85:1 frame) that certainly reaches for the clouds, as it were.

Colors are beyond assorted, as this film sports a wild, ever-changing aesthetic (it is, after all, a Gilliam film) that can, at times, seem a bit schizophrenic. The result is sheer, unbridled eye candy, though, as the tones in the real world are perfectly natural, drab, muted, somewhat dingey and somber, while the world of imagination sports the pizazz, brilliant primaries, and colors that know no limits. Detail is also quite superb, as the tiniest snowflake, or even pore, are often visible quite clearly, with beautiful definition of clothing or sets (the paintwork for the traveling stage, for example). Even the white ear hairs of the devil leap (disgustingly) off his head. The picture is amazingly deep and quite enveloping, and can truly suck the viewer right into the film. Best of all, this disc is superb in its technical prowess, as DNR, edge enhancement, artifacting, banding, and aliasing are not a part of this equation.

That said, perfection is not met, despite how often it is flirted with. Black levels are often too bright for their own good, not fitting with the dark mood the film often has. While no flaw of the transfer or disc, there are a few moments where the green/blue screen work makes itself known all too well, as characters can stand out from their environments in all the wrong ways, with different lighting elements than the scenes themselves. There's an odd vertical orange line for one full shot at the 1 hour, 8 minute spot, which is amazingly out of place in an otherwise perfectly clean film. Sony did an amazing, consistent job on this one, and they deserve great amounts of praise.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

But what good is great video without great audio? The experience that is 'Doctor Parnassus' is amplified with a gorgeous DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix. Much like the video, it's perfection slightly teased, almost attained, flirted with often, but still quite solid and worthy of kind words.

The film receives a very active sound mix. Motion is solid, localization is utilized quite frequently and superbly, with lots of atmosphere and effects loading the room with damn-near non-stop activity. It's quite the circus, honestly, but it comes through amazingly clear, with little jockeying for that coveted prioritization. Bass levels are somewhat light, but they pop up from time to time when needed for light emphasis, and the effect works. Explosions, for example, are thunderous and quite fun. When the stage constructs itself, its an audio marvel how many things are going on at once.

But, alas, that is also the main (possibly only) fault with this audio mix: too much going on at the same time. On more than one occasion, the score can completely obliterate the dialogue, making a few lines extremely difficult to discern. I am still wowed by this one, and think the world of this track, but it falls just short of the best of the best.

There are a variety of subtitles available, as well as a lossy Spanish dub and a lossless Portuguese track, for the non-English speaking.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

While this glut of extras looks immense, the truth of the matter is they are all too short, and miss some of the more interesting and important points that I wish had been hit.

  • Audio Commentary - With director Terry Gilliam. Gilliam is a curious listen, as his track is more an explanation than an analysis, as he discusses who the actors are rather than what they are (including his somewhat requisite little person casting, in this case, Verne Troyer of Mini-me fame), his thoughts on video gaming (they're less than kind), the logistics of the traveling cart (which are very interesting!), interpretations and inspirations for some of the more...unique...aspects of the film, his thoughts on some of the more awkward lines in the film concerning Ledger and his introduction to the film, which can be quite unsettling, religious parallels, his insights on Parnassus's personality, and more. There are fairly few gaps in coverage, but they're there from time to time. To be fair, few men can talk for two hours straight without a few brief little gaps. A good track, that starts out very slow and bad, but eventually gets some nice comments.
  • Terry Gilliam Film Introduction (HD, 3 min) - Gilliam discusses the inspirations for the film, and his creative process, as well as his thoughts on the loss of Ledger during production.
  • Deleted Scene (HD, 4 min) - With optional commentary from Gilliam. This shot has very rough CG effects, including some not even created. Basically, it is an extension of the trip through the Imaginarium by the young boy.
  • Behind the Mirror (HD, 3 min) - An EPK brief look at the characters, through the eyes of the actors, and some crew. Entirely skippable.
  • Building the Monastery (HD, 7 min) - From early concept art from Gilliam (and damn is he an artist), to the effects work necessary to create the final product, we get a look at one of the most elaborate, and visually stunning scenes in the film. Finally something non-EPK, and something awesome.
  • Heath Ledger Wardrobe Test (HD, 2 min) - With optional commentary by Gilliam. Honestly, this is just a bit bizarre, and honestly borderline creepy, as we watch Ledger put on random bits of clothing and mug the camera. Why so serious? I like the attention given to Ledger in these extras, but this one is just a little too far, and a little too sad. Gilliam gives some interesting thoughts, such as the idea of a lost contact mid-film to further the mystery behind the character. View this one with the commentary, as there is no dialogue lost under Gilliam's voice, and the PiP showing Gilliam doesn't interfere any with the on screen prancing.
  • Interview with Heath Ledger (HD, 3 min) - Segments of an interview between Stephen Schaefer and Ledger in November of 2007. It's not too deep, but it also won't cause emotional breakdowns for fans like the wardrobe test can.
  • Doctor Parnassus Around the World (HD, 6 min) - Yep, a montage of shots from various openings and bits of publicity for the film. Visit Rome, watch Cole be an absolute stunner, shudder at her wardrobe in Tokyo, and watch Gilliam shmooze a Japanese crowd.
  • Cast & Crew Presentation on Stage (HD, 8 min) - Gilliam is very difficult to understand here at times (damn mic echo) in this extra, which is basically an interview, in as few words. While somewhat pleasant, this extra is one big headache due to camera whir, feedback screeches from the audience, and the afforementioned echo.
  • The Artwork of Doctor Parnassus (HD, 4 min) - Gilliam briefly discusses the visuals and art in the film, with artwork from Gilliam himself getting a nice focus, from the pop-up book-esque stage and Imaginarium, to the monastary, jellyfish, the balloon contraption, and the river of beauty and flith. A nice little extra to help one appreciate the work of mister Gilliam.
  • Theatrical Trailer (HD, 1 min) - The oh-so awesome trailer for the film, in high def.
  • Previews - A huge pile of movie trailers, including 'Extraordinary Measures,' 'Dear John,' 'Not the Messiah (He's a Very Naughty Boy),' 'Young Victoria,' 'Chloe,' 'Hachi: A Dog's Tale,' 'An Education,' 'It Might Get Loud,' 'Whatever Works,' 'Coco Before Chanel,' 'Soul Power,' 'The Adventures of Baron Munchausen,' 'Labyrinth,' 'The Dark Crystal,' 'A Single Man,' and 'The Road.'

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

All that, and there are some exclusives to be found, too!

  • The Imaginarium of Terry Gilliam (HD, 6 min) - A look at the Imaginarium itself, interpreted and explained by Gilliam, that eventually devolves to yet another EPK look at the production.
  • "The Drunk" Multi-Angle Progression Sequence (HD, 2 min) - One of the nastier trips in the film, we get a four-way look at the drunken trip through the Imaginarium. One can, technically, go through the feature by switching back and forth through the four different levels of production, but it is so very much cooler to watch on the original screen, which has all four playing at the same time.
  • Heath Ledger and Friends (HD, 5 min) - Gilliam hosts a look at the way Law, Depp, and Farrell filled in for their fallen friend, from filling in scenes, to the ideas and changes needed to pull it off. Actors from the film sound off on Ledger and his body of work, though sadly, the one glaring omission is Farrell, as even Law and Depp (by way of phone interview) give brief insight.
  • BD-Live - Nothing yet. In fact, due to the pop up for random Sony titles when this part of the menu is picked, one cannot even read the error message saying that it isn't up yet. Oops.
  • MovieIQ - Sony's somehwat-requisite souped up trivia track, which has filmographies, cast and crew information, and random film information.

Final Thoughts

'The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus' isn't the best Gilliam film ever made, but it's far from the worst. This film will be remembered more for the performances within, and the men and women involved, particularly Heath Ledger, but there is more to this film than what it is famous for. The performances by Plummer, Waits, and Farrell deserve praise, and the imagery found in the film is as imaginative and unique as the film itself. With gorgeous video and riveting audio, this release is definitely recommended for purchase or rental, but I can't help but wish the extras had more beef, and less fluff.

Technical Specs

  • BD50 Blu-ray Disc
  • Region A/B

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.85:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround Sound
  • Portuguese DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround Sound
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound

Subtitles/Captions

  • English, English SDH, Spanish, Portuguese, Danish, Finnish, Norwegian, Swedish

Supplements

  • Introduction by director Terry Gilliam
  • Deleted scene with optional commentary by Terry Gilliam
  • Behind the mirror
  • Building the monastery
  • Heath Ledger wardrobe test with optional commentary by Terry Gilliam
  • Interview with Heath Ledger
  • Doctor Parnassus around the world
  • Cast & crew presentation on stage
  • The Artwork of Doctor Parnassus
  • Commentary with Terry Gilliam

Exclusive HD Content

  • movieIQ+sync
  • BD-Live
  • The Imaginarium of Terry Gilliam
  • Heath Ledger and friends
  • "The Drunk" multi-angle progression sequence

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.