- Street Date:
- January 19th, 2010
- Reviewed by:
- Drew Taylor
- Review Date: 1
- January 18th, 2010
- Movie Release Year:
- 261 Minutes
- MPAA Rating:
- Rated R
- Release Country
- United States
The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take
Steven Soderbergh's 'Che' is a massive, sprawling, intimate, one-of-a-kind movie made by a director who knows no fear, working at the peak of his artistic prowess. To try and take the life of the Cuban revolutionary Ernesto "Che" Guevara (played by 'Traffic's Benicio del Toro), a man who helped get Fidel into power and saw to the execution of more than 500 dissenters, before leading similar guerilla campaigns around the world, and wrangle it into a "mere" four-and-a-half-hours is something approaching madness. To choose to forgo traditional funding, including any kind of American backing, and shoot the entire thing in Spanish, seems even crazier. And the not-insignificant fact that it turned out to be something of an overlooked masterpiece? Well, that might be the craziest thing of all.
'Che' is broken down into two halves. The first half, 'The Argentine,' follows Che's rise to power. His beginnings as a asthmatic young doctor, drafted into revolutionary work during the Cuban revolution, the ascension of Fidel Castro to power (toppling the Batista dictatorship), and Che's iconic trip to the United Nations in 1964. In typical Soderbergh fashion, the chronology is all jumbled up, and the effect is incredibly powerful. Is it incredibly insightful as to who Che the man was? What made him tick? Well, no. But it does give you a great sense of the events that helped shape Che the man. (By all accounts he was a cold and distant bastard.) As a single filmed account of Che's life, this could have been enough. The first part of 'Che' is meaty, thought provoking, and beautifully filmed (with a combination of digital work and 16 mm black-and-white for the U.N. stuff). In fact, it might be the greatest thing Steven Soderbergh has ever done, and this is saying a lot.
The first part of 'Che' overwhelms and envelops you. You aren't swayed, particularly, by Che's revolutionary conquests as much as you're given a first hand account in which you can appreciate the lengths of which he did what he accomplished, especially with so few compatriots and resources. It's quite clear Che isn't the nicest fellow, but his transformation from a young doctor in the South American jungle to the toast of the U.N. (in his most T-shirt ready look) is as about as compelling a story as they get. Filmed beautifully through Soderbergh's singular eye (and utilizing, for the first time, the RED digital camera, which went on to shoot 'District 9' and 'Gamer') and the jungles look as threatening and vibrant as anything in 'Avatar.' (The black-and-white stuff is just as compelling, although it's looser, handheld photography.) It's just a masterpiece, really. And you're only halfway done.
The second half of 'Che,' 'Guerilla,' chronicles Che's Bolivian campaign, a campaign that directly followed a similarly failed campaign in the Congo. This was the campaign that seemed doomed from the start and concludes with Che's capture and execution. The difference between Part 1 and Part 2 mostly has to do with the structure. While Part 1 focuses on a specific campaign (the Cuban Revolution), it's interspersed with biographical detail and context and framed around his famous jaunt to the U.N. Part 2 is simply the Bolivian campaign, free of context, political, personal, or otherwise. (The Congo campaign is never mentioned.)
By the time you're done with part 2 you really do feel like you've served under Guevera. It's a long, hard slog through perilous jungle terrain. Unlike the first half, the second half is robbed of much of the lush color pallet and has a broader aspect ratio. It feels less like a traditional movie narrative and more like an embedment. It's a long, losing battle. But one half of 'Che' doesn't quite work without the other half. And the main purpose of 'Che's second half is character development. Like the protagonist of 'The Hurt Locker,' Che is a guy who was only happy when he was in a conflict. 'Guerilla' showcases this beautifully. Even in the face of certain doom, Che keeps the campaign alive. And even if you don't agree with his methods or his politics, he's an impressive figure nonetheless. While the second half of 'Che' doesn't have the zippy charge that the first half does, it's an even deeper, more immersive experience and the movie as a whole is nothing short of a jaw-dropping work of biographical art.
I know I'm focusing a lot on the filmmaking of 'Che' but enough can't be said about the film's lead, Benicio del Toro. He won for his performance at Cannes (in a slightly different version of the movie), and it is an award he totally deserved. He doesn't have a lot to work with, given Che's gruff stoicism, and he didn't have a lot of time to experiment, either. Even though the film was being developed for the better part of ten years, the back-to-back shoots were very quick. But man, he makes the impossible possible, embodying a polarizing figure at two extreme points in his life many years apart and still manages to create a totally gripping and believable on-screen Che.
The first time I saw 'Che' it was in one marathon go, at a press screening during the New York Film Festival, and had a brief intermission where they served us lunch (don't worry, the crummy free sandwich had no affect on my diagnosis of the film). It remains one of the most impressive cinematic experiences I've ever had. And thankfully, the good folks at Criterion have put together a package every bit worthy of the film.
The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats
'Che' comes handsomely packaged as a two-disc box set, with each disc getting its own chunky Criterion wide-box (the two films share one number - #496). The disc does not automatically play when you pop in the disc. Each disc is 50GB. It should also be noted that Criterion went to pains to recreate the 'roadshow' presentation of 'Che' (which is how it was screened at Cannes and the New York Film Festival, as well as during its brief theatrical run). That means that, even though it's spread across two discs, it maintains the 'map' sections that started the films (and acted as an intermission for part two). It's really beautifully done. Great stuff. Also, these discs are Region "A" locked.
The Video: Sizing Up the Picture
This presentation of 'Che' is nothing short of jaw-dropping. In particular, the first half is one of the most gorgeous-looking Blu-ray discs I have ever seen.
Each half has its own aspect ratio, faithfully reproduced here. Part 1 has a more classically cinematic aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and Part 2 comes equipped with a squarer aspect ratio of 1.78:1. (Soderbergh was his own brilliant director of photography.) Both are 1080p transfers with MPEG-4 AVC encodes.
These are direct-from-the digital source transfers (except, of course, for the 16mm stuff in part 1) and they are totally gorgeous in every way. Just like all the peerless Pixar movies, the direct-from-source transfer leaves you with a picture quality that is nothing short of flawless.
The first half, in particular, with its lush jungle settings, absolutely pop on Blu-ray. I'd be hard pressed to say I've seen anything like it, because I just don't think that's true. Everything is outstanding – detail, clarity, skin tones, black levels (except in some nighttime scenes, which Soderbergh wanted to look a little softer), textures, and colors. There are no buggy technical issues of any kind, and while the transfer attempted to maintain a "film-like" look, there is no actual grain to interfere with the image. (Again, unless it's intentional, like the deliberately old-looking 16mm bits.) Part 2 has a more muted color pallet but all of the superlatives remain.
I dare anyone, home video enthusiast or just casual viewer, to pop in the first part and not let out an audible gasp at the gorgeousness of this transfer. Just beautiful, this one ranks up there with the best of them, a reference-quality picture if I've ever seen one.
The Audio: Rating the Sound
Just as brilliant as the transfer is the Spanish DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix on this disc. As far as I can tell, this mix is flawless.
Dialogue is crisp, clear, and strongly reproduced. The surround field is used excellently - not only in the intense battle sequences, with bullets whizzing by and trains toppling over, but in the simpler scenes, with the sound of rain hitting the leaves in the jungle - active but never overly bombastic. Additionally, the beautiful, subtle score by Alberto Iglesias (who works with Almodovar a lot) sounds incredible. The mix dazzles throughout, in the quieter scenes and in the more action packed stuff alike. And what's so great, so essential about this mix (particularly in the film's second half) is that it really does put you in the shoes of one of those idealistic grunts, following Che through some godforsaken South American jungle.
There is no hiss, no pops, no technical issues to speak of either. It's hard to describe something that is more or less perfect, because that is what we have here. It's just great.
A couple of notes about the mix: although the Spanish mix is the only one available for both parts, there is an option on the first part to have a bit of narration be in Spanish or in English. It was in Spanish for the Cannes cut and then Soderbergh (rightfully) thought it was too overwhelming and changed it to English for the Toronto and New York Film Festival premieres and subsequent roadshow presentations. I agree with the move to change this brief bit to English, although the disc gives you the option to watch it the other way around. It's really wonderful that Criterion gave us the option. (If you want to cite why they are still the greatest producers of home video content, you can point to this.) Also, both films have optional English subtitles. Since the aspect ratios are different, when you watch the first half, the subtitles will be in the black space while on the second half they will appear 'in-frame.'
The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff
There's an amazing package of extra features spread across both discs. Also included is an essay by Amy Taubin, one of the film's earliest supporters (she got behind the film after its troubled Cannes showing). Additionally, Criterion's Blu-ray-exclusive 'Timeline' feature is present. Everything else is available on the DVD box set.
- Commentary Tracks There's one commentary per half. Sadly, it isn't by Soderbergh because he's said recently that he's done recording commentaries for his own movies (he's done commentaries for movies like 'Clean, Shaven,' 'The Graduate,' and 'The Third Man'), although early materials for the forthcoming Blu-ray of 'The Informant!' have a "director commentary" listed. Oh well. We'll find out soon enough. Instead, the commentary tracks provided are by author Jon Lee Anderson who wrote the definitive Che biography "Che Guevara: A Revolutionary Life," which the films were based on (he was an indispensible resource on the movie). While the lack of Soderbergh commentary is kind of a sore spot, you won't for a second regret listening to these tracks. Literally, from the first second of this commentary track Anderson is dropping all sorts of knowledge - about what Cuba was like pre-Castro (a kind of decadent playground for wealthy promiscuous white guys), the CIA's interest and involvement with Che and everything else you could ever imagine. Anderson's book remains the go-to biography of Che, and as far as I'm concerned, these commentary tracks are just as essential as the movie, especially if you were someone who frowned on the film's lack of biographical texture.
- The Making of 'Che' (HD, 49:51) Wow. This has pretty much set the gold standard for making of documentaries, as far as I'm concerned. Produced specifically for this release, it's a comprehensive look at the troubled making of this movie. With little more than some behind-the-scenes footage and talking head interviews, it absolutely grips you. Charting the project's nearly ten-year gestation period, from when Terrence Malick was shepherding the project to Soderbergh taking over and everything that came after. It's a shockingly honest documentary, particularly when it comes to Soderbergh's comments. Throughout the documentary he seems unsure of himself, first saying that he thinks he should have done it as a ten-part miniseries. Later, he talks about the film's piss-poor reception at Cannes, adding that he doesn't think one of his films will be included in the festival for a very, very long time. But even more tellingly he talks about how 'Che's reception made him stop believing in the power of movies. "I used to believe that movies mattered," he says, his air of intellectualism cracking a bit to make way for heartache. "I don't think they matter anymore." He bemoans the film's lack of cultural impact and the media's willingness to dismiss the project even before it hit screens and makes some all-too-on-the-nose comments about the state of American film criticism. I can't stress how essential this documentary is.
- Deleted Scenes (15:31 and 5:21, HD) There are deleted scenes that accompany each section of 'Che.' (Please insert the "It's over four hours long and it has deleted scenes?" joke here.) Both of these are well worth watching, especially since they have optional commentary by Steven Soderbergh. Considering how quickly he edits, these scenes look pretty finished. Some, he explains, were in the original Cannes cut of the movie, which he then did a brief re-edit on. There's not anything earth shattering in here, but as someone who could have watched another four and a half hours of 'Che,' they're delightful just the same (and have a couple of great, human moments for the guerilla).
- Trailer (HD, 2:32) This is IFC's trailer for the roadshow presentation of 'Che.' It's okay, but not all that essential. Still, it's a nice addition nonetheless, although it would have been great to see how this prickly film was marketed around the world.
- End of a Revolution (HD, 25:52) This is another really worthwhile special feature, and one of the best in the set. It's a vintage piece of news reporting from 1967, when a producer went to Bolivia to try and get an interview with Che. By the time he got down there, Che was dead. The documentary chronicles the aftermath unblinkingly (there are several shots of Che's dead and bloodied corpse, fair warning), featuring interviews with key figures and an overview of the political climate. This is really compelling stuff and a must-watch, in my opinion.
- Interviews from Cuba (HD, 23:05 and 11:53) This is another great special feature produced exclusively for this set. Last year, Benicio del Toro and 'Che's producer Laura Bickford (who you'll see extensively in the making-of doc, she rules) went to Cuba and interviewed a bunch of people who knew a lot about Che's Cuban campaign. The feature is broken down into two parts, equally fascinating - Participants (i.e. those that actually helped Fidel and Che) and Historians (again - those looking for some context - here it is!) Both are wonderful and totally engaging.
- Che and the Digital Camera Revolution (HD, 33:21) Man, I wasn't expecting this to be as fun and captivating as it really is. This is about Soderbergh's use of the then-prototype RED camera to shoot 'Che.' They literally had to push back the start-date on production to accommodate the camera rolling off the production floor. Through interviews with Soderbergh, people at RED, as well as the technical guys who helped create the 'digital workflow' that allowed the movie to be shot and edited so quickly and efficiently. Soderbergh talks about being able to edit scenes from the night before on the way to the location the following day. That's ridiculous. This is really gripping and, thanks to some lighthearted animation, surprisingly funny.
HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?
There are no HD exclusives.
A couple weeks into this new year and Criterion's dynamic presentation of Steven Soderbergh's difficult, brilliant epic 'Che' sets the bar ridiculously high. The movie is a masterpiece, and a must-see for anyone who missed its festival screenings or roadshow presentations (don't worry - they've been reproduced beautifully here) or has an interest in history or film. This package has an outstanding, voluminous collection of top-tier special features and flawless A/V is that is nothing short of stunning. This set goes beyond great. It feels downright revolutionary. Highly recommended.
- Two Disc Set
- 1080p/AVC MPEG-4
- 1.78:1 (Part 1)
- 2.35:1 (Part 2)
- Spanish DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 Surround Sound
- Commentary by Historian Jon Lee Anderson (both parts)
- Deleted Scenes
- The Making of 'Che'
- End of a Revolution
- Interviews from Cuba
- Che and the Digital Camera Revolution
All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More
about our gear.
Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.