Blu-ray
Highly Recommended
3.5 stars
List Price
$129.99
Amazon
$37.62 (71%)
3rd Party
$25.73
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
3 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3.5 Stars
Supplements
3 Stars
High-Def Extras
2.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Star Trek: The Original Series - Season 3

Street Date:
December 15th, 2009
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
December 21st, 2009
Movie Release Year:
1969
Studio:
CBS Home Entertainment
Length:
1350 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

As much as we may look back at 'Star Trek' as an enduring cultural institution, the show had a very difficult time capturing a mass audience during its original broadcast run from 1966 to 1969. In fact, it had such low ratings that the NBC network was ready to cancel the series after its second season. 'Trek' was only brought back for one additional season due to an aggressive letter-writing campaign waged by zealous fans. The network relented, and renewed 'Star Trek' for a third year, but hedged its bets. They cut the show's budget again, and shifted it to a Friday death slot where it was guaranteed to fail. The same young, hip viewers that were the show's core audience were also the sort of people unlikely to stay home to watch TV on a Friday night. As expected, ratings continued to plummet until NBC had no choice but to pull the plug.

During this time, creator Gene Roddenberry became discouraged and stepped away from active production of 'Star Trek' to focus on developing other projects. The show's remaining producers exerted most of their efforts trying to attract (or retain) an audience, often to the detriment of core essentials like interesting storylines or quality screenwriting. The third season of 'Star Trek' is, without question, the show's weakest. Most of the series' poorest episodes are found here, perhaps most exemplified by the season premiere, the lamentable 'Spock's Brain', which is widely (and justifiably) regarded as the very worst episode of 'Star Trek'. Even the premise is just plain dumb: a race of bimbo female aliens steal Spock's brain to use as the CPU in their compound's computer system – which prompts Kirk, McCoy, and Spock's roboticized body to go fetch it back. The episode is badly written, badly acted, and ridiculously campy in ways more cringe-inducing than fun. "Brain and brain! What is brain?"

Sadly, that's far from the only dog in this pack. Other notorious stinkers include 'And the Children Shall Lead' (which puts famed attorney and occasional actor Melvin Belli in a flowery muumuu as a creepy pedophile alien who causes a bunch of annoying kids to rebel against the Enterprise) and 'The Way to Eden' (the notorious "space hippies" episode). Even an episode critical to the show's mythology like 'The Enterprise Incident', although generally better, starts off excessively contrived and is filled with illogical plotting. Erratic writing and inconsistent characterizations plague almost the entire season. Keep an eye on William Shatner's performance for a good indicator of which direction any given episode will go. The actor was smart enough to recognize a bad script, and often tried to compensate by hamming it up more, as if to distract from the deficiencies in storytelling. If Shatner seems more over-the-top than usual, that's not a good sign. When he had a good script to work from, he was more likely to reign in his performance.

By the time the year drew to a close, the show's production staff knew very well that there would be no fourth season in store for them. Unfortunately, it was not common practice at the time to produce a proper series finale that might tie up any lingering storylines or bring closure to the characters. As such, the last episode, the gender-swapping 'Turnabout Intruder', makes a very poor finale with absolutely no acknowledgment that the 'Star Trek' adventure was ending.

And yet, the third season has some good episodes too. 'Spectre of the Gun' gives us a surreal, Western-themed story that's pretty entertaining. 'Day of the Dove' has a group Klingons trying to take over the Enterprise, which is always fun, and even shows us our first (old-style) Klingon female. (She's cute enough that Chekov tries to score with her!) A number of episodes, even if flawed, have intriguing concepts, like the benign non-corporeal aliens whose appearance will drive men insane in 'Is There in Truth No Beauty?', or the aliens in 'Wink of an Eye' that move at a speed too fast for humans to detect. Others attempt to tackle relevant social issues like racism ('Let That Be Your Last Battlefield') or overpopulation ('The Mark of Gideon'). I can't think of any episode in the third season that I'd mark among the show's best, but there are a few legitimate 'Trek' classics here such as 'The Tholian Web' and 'Plato's Stepchildren', the latter of which made history by featuring the first interracial kiss ever to air on American television.

The third season collection is also where we find 'The Cage', the original 'Star Trek' pilot episode starring Jeffrey Hunter as Captain Christopher Pike. It's a fascinating, 1950s-style sci-fi tale with a notably different performance from Leonard Nimoy as Spock (the only character to survive the recasting for the subsequent pilot and series). Footage from 'The Cage' was later carved up and interspersed as flashbacks into the first-season episode 'The Menagerie', but the episode didn't air in its original version until 1988. Because the studio has insisted on presenting all of the show's episodes in broadcast order, this one is traditionally placed last and tacked onto the end of Season 3.

Once more, the wizards at CBS Digital have thoroughly restored all of the episodes (even 'The Cage') for these Remastered versions. A big part of that involves replacing many of the original, dated special effects shots with shiny new CGI. As I've mentioned in previous reviews, I find the new visual effects to be tastefully done and genuinely helpful in enhancing appreciation of the series.

The Blu-ray: Vital Disc Stats

CBS Home Entertainment (through their distributor Paramount Home Entertainment) brings 'Star Trek: The Original Series – Season 3' to Blu-ray. The studio previously released the show's first season and second season on the format earlier this year. The Blu-ray once again contains both the new Remastered versions of the episodes and the original versions with their 1960s special effects. The alternate footage is seamlessly branched from each episode, allowing you to toggle between the old and new versions on the fly by selecting the camera icon in the pop-up menu.

The third season Blu-ray packaging is very similar to the earlier two. The 6 discs are housed in a multi-disc keepcase with slipcover. However, the keepcase this time is noticeably slimmer than the others. The first disc in the set opens with two annoying promos before the menu.

An episode listing is printed on the backside of the cover art, visible through the plastic case. As before, the episodes are presented in their original broadcast order, not their production order. If you wish to watch the episodes in production order, you have to sort that out by reading the "Mission Stardate" trivia notes on the episode list. Because it was not broadcast until 1988, well after the series had been cancelled, 'The Cage' is presented as the final episode in the set. Other than 'The Cage' (which is set before Captain Kirk took charge of the Enterprise, and thus could be viewed as a prequel), the episodes in the third season have no ongoing storylines and will not cause any continuity problems regardless of which order they're viewed.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The third season of 'Star Trek' has undergone the same loving restoration as the earlier two. In fact, because the show's episodes were not remastered in chronological order, many from this season were completed at the same time or earlier than those from Seasons 1 and 2. The source elements have been dramatically cleaned of dirt, debris, and scratches. Even many original production limitations that were previously "baked in" to the picture (such as hairs or grit trapped between optical composite layers) have been digitally painted away. Some imperfections remain, and the old special effects footage (although upgraded to high-def) was obviously not restored at all. Nevertheless, when combined with the high-definition resolution and all-new visual effects (if you choose to watch them), the result is an almost revelatory new look at a familiar show.

The 1080p/VC-1 transfers are presented in the show's original 1.33:1 aspect ratio with pillarbox bars on the sides of the frame, as they should be. Although all of the episodes were restored in the exact same way, the original episodes themselves suffered from a budget cut after the first season. The production quality of episodes in the second and third seasons is generally sloppier than the first. The photography is often grainier, softer (with many missed focus cues), and not as expressively lit. This is reflected in the restorations, perhaps more so than was visible in TV broadcasts of the past. Season 3 irons out at least some of these problems in comparison to the second season. It doesn't have nearly the wide swings in picture quality from episode to episode (or even scene to scene within episodes) that we saw in Season 2. However, it's still obviously softer and flatter than Season 1. Just compare the restored version of 'The Cage' to any other episode in this set, and you can't help but be struck by the difference in production values.

Even so, for a low-budget TV series from the 1960s, 'Star Trek' looks terrific, and far better than it ever has before.

(It's also worth noting that the show's opening titles were changed to a blue font color in Season 3, rather than the yellow used in the first two years.)

The Audio: Rating the Sound

I hate to repeat myself, but the DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 soundtracks on Season 3 are every bit comparable in quality to those of the first two seasons. Since I have nothing new to add, all I can do is reiterate what I've said before. Every word still applies.

The show still isn't a slam-bang auditory powerhouse, but the remixes do a good job of cleaning up and tweaking the original material while retaining its flavor and intent. Each episode remains primarily anchored in the front soundstage, with few gimmicky or inappropriate surround effects. In many episodes, there may be one or two instances of obvious movement in the rear channels. Generally speaking, dialogue and most sound effects remain in the center channel, with the musical score spread out to a mild stereo dimensionality. The audio is clean and clear, if not particularly aggressive in envelopment or dynamic with bass. The show's theme has been freshly recorded from a new orchestration and sounds terrific.

Purists will be pleased to know that the studio has again provided the show's unrestored monaural soundtracks in Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono format. You can choose this audio over either version of the episodes. Unfortunately, it is significantly weaker in quality and fidelity.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

The Blu-ray carries over all of the bonus features found in the comparable DVD box set of these Remastered episodes, which was released in late 2008. Many of these were originally created for the non-Remastered DVD box set from 2004.

All of these supplements are clustered on the last two discs of the Blu-ray box set.

  • Preview Trailers (times vary, all SD) – Each episode contains its original TV trailer. The footage is generally in very poor condition.
  • The Cage – Extended Version (SD, 71 min.) – In order to construct the first season episode 'The Menagerie', the original film negative for 'The Cage' was taken apart and intermixed with new footage shot later. For many years, the 'Cage' scenes that didn't make it into 'The Menagerie' were thought lost. The episode was reconstructed for the first time in the late 1980s by cutting the 'Menagerie' scenes together with footage from Gene Roddenberry's personal 16mm black & white reference print of the original episode. That is the version presented here, along with a vintage Gene Roddenberry introduction and outro. Later on, a full-color print of 'The Cage' was found in the studio archives. That print was restored, and is also available on this disc in high definition, as both the original and Remastered versions. However, the restored full-color episode is missing at least one line of dialogue and (to keep the scene length the same) has an additional cutaway shot inserted. The "Extended Version" found here regularly switches to b&w throughout the episode, even for footage that was later found in color. The voice of The Keeper also changes between the b&w and color scenes, because the original voice actor was replaced. (The full-color version has a consistent voice for this character.) Otherwise, the "Extended Version" is identical in content to the non-Extended version. It's nice to have this as a curiosity, but the full-color version is still preferred for general viewing.
  • Life Beyond Trek: Walter Keonig (SD, 11 min.) – The actor tells a funny anecdote about how he was cast for the show, and talks a bit about his career outside of 'Trek'. He also shows off his extensive collection of Pavel Chekov memorabilia and comic character collectibles.
  • Chief Engineer's Log (SD, 6 min.) – This 2003 interview with James Doohan shows the late actor in ill health. (He passed away two years later.) Here he reveals that he dubbed the voices for many computer and machine speaking parts on the show, lists off his favorite episodes, and gives thanks to fans.
  • Memoir from Mr. Sulu (SD, 9 min.) – In this 2004 interview, George Takei discusses the effect of 'Star Trek' on his life. He also talks about his work for the Japanese-American National Museum.
  • Captain's Log: Bob Justman (HD, 10 min.) – This tribute to the late producer describes him as the "nuts & bolts" guy that kept the show running. Cast and crew share stories about his warmth and humor.
  • Billy Blackburn's Treasure Chest: Rare Home Movies and Special Memories Part 3 (HD, 11 min.) – More behind-the-scenes home movies from the supporting actor, stand-in, and frequent makeup tester. Footage of Shatner and Nimoy horsing around between takes is priceless.
  • To Boldly Go… Season 3 (SD, 22 min.) – An overview of the letter-writing campaign that brought the show back for a third season, the continued ratings and time slot problems, Gene Roddenberry's absence from the production, and how William Shatner ensured that the famous kiss with Nichelle Nichols didn't get cut from the episode.
  • Collectible Trek (SD, 14 min.) – A look at some memorabilia from the franchise, both licensed products and production props.
  • Star Trek's Impact (SD, 9 min.) – Gene Roddenberry's son Eugene "Rod" Roddenberry reflects back on his favorite episodes.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

There are a few Blu-ray exclusives. Disappointingly, this season does not contain "Starfleet Access" Picture-in-Picture interactive features on any of the episodes.

    Will Work in Any Blu-ray Player

  • Where No Man Has Gone Before – Alternate Version (HD, 53 min.) – As explained in the text scroll at the beginning, the show's second pilot episode was recut prior to airing. Seen here for the first time is the original edit, which has a different prologue, different opening titles, and 1960s-style Act markers after each commercial break. The episode is otherwise the same as we've always known it. The episode is presented only with its original special effects, and has not been Remastered like the other episodes. The print is a little scratchy, and the Dolby Digital 2.0 mono soundtrack is very weak.
  • David Gerrold Hosts 2009 Convention Coverage (HD, 20 min.) – The 'Trouble with Tribbles' writer visits a couple of different conventions to talk to fans in costume and third-string actors hawking their wares. He also manages to score an interview with Nichelle Nichols, but isn't particularly adept at being an interviewer.
  • The Anthropology of Star Trek: Comic-Con Panel 2009 (HD, 4 min.) – In this very dumb convention panel, an anthropologist attempts to justify some of the show's themes, and makes a case for TrekkiesTrekkers being an important worldwide subculture.
  • The World of Rod Roddenberry: Comic-Con 2009 (HD, 7 min.) – In his latest attempt to cash-in on his father's name, Gene's son "Rod" Roddenberry plugs his new 'Trek' tie-in comic series called 'Days Missing'.

    BD-Live: Requires Profile 2.0

  • dynamicHD – Just like the earlier seasons, the new box set offers access to the CBS BD-Live portal, utilizing the dynamicHD platform. Found here are 'Star Trek' cast, crew, and character bios, as well as photo galleries and text databases with information on aliens, ships, technology, and locations. A Community Forum area allows users to chat or share their own photos. Exclusive featurettes (a few minutes each) can be downloaded in your choice of SD or HD resolution. More content may become available in the future.
  • Mobile-Blu (D, min.) – With the new Mobile-Blu functionality, you may use a wireless mobile device as a remote control for your Blu-ray player, or stream exclusive pieces of video content to it. At the time of this writing, only the iPhone is supported. According to the disc menus, more devices will be added in the future.

The Cutting Room Floor: What Didn't Make the Blu-ray?

For some reason, a 7-minute featurette titled "A Star Trek Collector's Dream Come True" didn't make the transition from the Remastered DVD box set to Blu-ray. It may have been considered redundant to some of the other features in the set. Also missing are the Okudas' text commentaries on episodes 'Savage Curtain' and 'Turnabout Intruder' from the older DVD box.

Easter Eggs

The hidden Easter Eggs in this 'Star Trek' Blu-ray set are very easy to find.

  • Romulans or Klingons? (HD, 2 min.) – On Disc 1, highlight and select the red menu button without a label.
  • The Bottle Show (D, 2 min.) – Do likewise on Disc 2.
  • Birthday Shuttlecraft (D, 2 min.) – And again on Disc 3.
  • Flint's Castle (D, 2 min.) – Last one on Disc 4.

Final Thoughts

It's an unfortunate fact that 'Star Trek' took a nosedive in quality during its third season. Many of the episodes here are among the show's worst. But there are still some good ones too. Even the bad ones are usually fun. Despite its flaws, the third season remains an essential part of any 'Star Trek' fan's collection. The Blu-ray box set is on par with the earlier two seasons, and is just as highly recommended as those were.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • 6-Disc Set
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Discs
  • Bonus View (Profile 1.1)
  • BD-Live (Profile 2.0)

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.33:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 Surround
  • English Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono
  • French Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono

Supplements

  • "Where No Fan Has Gone Before": the restored, unaired alternate pilot episode
  • "To Boldly Go..." Season Three
  • Collectible Trek
  • Star Trek's Impact
  • Trailers
  • David Gerrold Hosts "2009 Convention Coverage"
  • Life Beyond Trek: Walter Koenig
  • "The Anthropology of Star Trek" ComiCon Panel 209
  • Chief Engineer's Log
  • "The World of Rod Roddenberry" ComiCon 2009
  • Memoir From Mr. Sulu
  • Captain's Log: Bob Justman
  • Billy Blackburn's Treasure Chest: rare home movies and special memories Part 3

Exclusive HD Content

  • BD-Live

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$129.99
Amazon
$37.62 (71%)
3rd Party
$25.73
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»