Blu-ray
Must Own
5 stars
Overall Grade
5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
5 Stars
Supplements
5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Must Own

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Street Date:
May 5th, 2009
Reviewed by:
Review Date: 1
May 22nd, 2009
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
Paramount Home Entertainment
Length:
165 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

"I was born under unusual circumstances..." – Benjamin Button

Life isn't measured in minutes, but in moments. That's the tagline for the Academy Award-nominated film 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button,' and those words of wisdom make perfect sense. The strange tale about an odd man born in his twilight years who actually gets younger as time passes by at first seems like a rather simple and gimmicky premise, hardly enough to sustain a 160-minute runtime, but as the unique story is told magic happens. We immediately lose ourselves within the fantastical atmosphere of the film, feel gripping emotions for the characters, and even learn a very powerful message. No matter how our lives unfold, the short time we have on this earth is precious -- so we should all make the most of it without allowing a single moment go to waste.

Just as Hurricane Katrina rolls into New Orleans during the summer of 2005, an elderly woman known as Daisy (Cate Blanchett) lies on her hospital deathbed in the company of her daughter Caroline (Julia Ormond). After Daisy shares a haunting yarn about a blind clockmaker and his broken heart, she then directs Caroline to a box filled with postcards, photographs, and a diary. Upon Daisy's request, Caroline begins reading aloud from the journal -- chronicling the amazing life story of one Benjamin Button (Brad Pitt).

The narrative then travels all the way back to the day World War I ended, the very eve the wife of tycoon Thomas Button (Jason Flemyng) dies while giving birth to their son. To make matters worse, Thomas sees the baby has been born with a bizarre set of chronic and terminal ailments so he abandons the dying newborn on the doorstep of a convalescence home. There an African-American caregiver called Queenie (Taraji P. Henson) finds the bundle and decides to make him comfortable in his final stages of life. Except the decrepit enigma survives, and stranger still is the fact that as each year goes by, Benjamin's body seems to be turning back the clock.

'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' is a monumental film, receiving a whopping thirteen Oscar nominations at the 81st Annual Academy Awards earlier this year. While I'm sure a few of them may be disputable, no one can deny that so far the film is the crowning achievement in director David Fincher's career. Marking his first Academy nomination, his vision captivates with an aura of elegance and grace that galvanizes the mind. The sets are spectacularly gorgeous, the make-up work is top-notch, and the special effects are so well-integrated it's hard to distinguish the CGI creations from reality. There are scenes where homes and even entire cities have been inserted into the image brilliantly, and except for a couple of cases out on the ocean where the waves looked slightly off to my eyes, most would go unnoticed unless you've tuned into the bonus features. The film won statuettes for these three categories (art direction, make-up, and visual effects) too -- and there's no argument from me.

Then there's Brad Pitt, who proves once again that he's more than just a pretty face -- becoming a character who is quirky, eccentric, and ultimately likable. While Benjamin Button is a quiet fellow, his presence is the loudest in the film and it doesn't take us long to forget he's a work of fiction. Likewise, Cate Blanchett is excellent as Daisy, charismatic and charming, plus I don't think there is any film where she looks more beautiful than she does here. Both of the characters are extremely compelling and their chemistry is arresting.

The screenplay by Eric Roth ('Forrest Gump,' 'The Insider,' and 'Munich') is also very strong. Loosely adapted from a short story by F Scott Fitzgerald, Roth weaves a tale of fantasy forged with elements of mystery, romance, and action -- and does so in a way that's incredibly intriguing and powerfully poetic. The only thing that I thought didn't fit snugly was the accident involving Daisy. From a story perspective it worked just fine, but logically it didn't really mesh with the rest of the narrative. Benjamin's journal contained details he couldn't possibly know, so I thought this could have been hammered out a bit better.

'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' is an imaginative and emotional journey which displays the complexities of a simple yet unusual life. Some will find the story uplifting and peaceful, while others will walk away feeling saddened and melancholy. The outstanding performances, stunning visuals, masterful direction, and slick writing all fuse together to form a brilliant film, one that is nearly picture-perfect.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

Similar to Fincher's 'Zodiac,' much of 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' was shot in 1080p high-definition -- using Thompson Viper FilmStream and Sony F23 digital cameras with color correction provided by Jan Yarbrough on FilmLight's Baselight systems. In short, the point of all this techno-babble is that the pristine digital-to-digital transfer delivers a stunning reference-quality Blu-ray disc.

Right from the moment the Paramount and Warner Brothers logos are smothered by hundreds of buttons, the sharpness and level of detail is simply breathtaking. Textures of facial features and clothing are crisp and the image has exceptionally strong depth for a pleasing three-dimensional picture. The color palette varies throughout the movie -- sometimes feeling quite cold with icy blues, steely greys, and clinical whites in the hospital, while other times (such as Benjamin's early years) the image has a sepia tone using various warm shades of yellows, golds, and browns. Black levels are rock solid too -- dark and inky with fantastic shadow detailing.

Only a handful of flashback segments were captured on 35mm film, and those have all been weathered intentionally with a treatment of dirt, scratches, specks, judder, discoloration and other imperfections in order to make these scenes distinguishable from the rest of the story. That being said, I can't fault these purposely aged clips as that's how they were meant to look.

I also didn't notice any banding, artifacting, or any other eyesores. The only thing that I did catch was a very, very mild bout of noise in a couple of the scenes when Julia Ormond was on screen (maybe she's a ghost?), but honestly this was so minuscule it doesn't make a dent in the gorgeous 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 (2.40:1 aspect ratio) presentation.

It's also worth noting that the U.S. version of 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' is region-locked and therefore will only function properly in Region A PlayStation 3 and standalone players.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

The original theatrical sound mix for 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' was optimized by sound engineer Ren Klyce and although the packaging is a little ambiguous on the Blu-ray disc's exact audio specifications, it does in fact include a wonderful lossless English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track.

Alexandre Desplat's haunting and atmospheric score fills the room flawlessly, making excellent use of the rear channels. The center speaker delivers crisp and clear dialogue -- even when factoring in some of the strong southern accents and deathbed mumblings. There are periodic subtle surround effects in quieter scenes, but the track really comes alive during the World War I flashbacks and the sequences at sea on The Chelsea. As one would expect, the bass is most effective during these cases and really makes its presence known. Much like the deep, bellowing horn of the tugboat, this track will knock your socks off.

Also included are Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks in French and Spanish, as well as optional English, English SDH, French, and Spanish subtitles.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

The Criterion Collection again impresses, by spreading many hours of bonus materials across two discs here on the Blu-ray and its DVD counterpart. It should also be noted that while there also is a non-Criterion standard-definition DVD release from Paramount, it comes without any supplemental material whatsoever.

The first disc on the Blu-ray contains the feature film and a single supplement -- an audio commentary recorded in 2009 by Academy Award-nominated director David Fincher. It's a very detailed track with Fincher discussing filming trials and tribulations, camera tricks and shooting secrets, and much more. It's tough to get through in one sitting since the film is so long, but it's still a solid commentary with a wealth of information.

All of the other supplements are enclosed on a second BD-50 Blu-ray disc, with the centerpiece being a feature called The Curious Birth of Benjamin Button divided into four sections: First, Second, and Third Trimesters, as well as Birth. All four sections can be played together as a singular entity, but it's best to view them individually as they have a few inclusions unavailable in the "play all" option.

First Trimester: Beginnings

Naturally, the first section focuses on the developmental history and the pre-production stages of the project, with a few still galleries thrown in for good measure.

  • Preface (HD, 3:08) – In this short introduction, David Fincher discusses his own personal experiences with life and death and their relevance to the film's overall theme.
  • Development and Pre-Production (HD, 28:56) – Producers Kathleen Kennedy, Frank Marshall, Ceán Chaffin, and many more share insights on the film's curious development process spanning over twenty years. They cover the entire timeline in great detail from Robin Swicord's first draft in the late eighties, to big names like Frank Oz, Steven Spielberg, and Tom Cruise all been involved at some point, to finally landing in Fincher's hands.
  • Tech Scouts (HD, 12:23) – A look behind-the-scenes on location showing how certain descriptive excerpts from the script were brought to life on camera.
  • Storyboard Gallery – Here you'll find a very large collection of rough storyboard sketches and drawings for specific scenes.
  • Art Direction Gallery – Another gallery of photography highlighting the Oscar-winning set designs and props from the film.

Second Trimester: Production

The next area centers on the production process including a pair of behind-the-scenes featurettes as well as a glimpse into the costume design.

  • Production: Parts 1 & 2 (HD, 55:17) – A very thorough two-part examination of the production containing cast and crew interviews, raw footage from some of the two hundred locations used for the film, the making of certain sequences, the creation of various props, a look at some of the special effects, etc.
  • Costume Design (HD, 7:38) – An interview with costume designer Jacqueline West who made the effort to incorporate as many different arrangements and styles of buttons in her designs as possible keeping with the theme of the film.
  • Costume Gallery – This section concludes with a portfolio of photos showcasing the wardrobe designs and costumes.

Third Trimester: Visual Effects

My personal favorite area digs deep into the award–winning visual effects and makeup. This section concludes with featurettes on the sound mixing and music.

  • Visual Effects: Performance Capture (HD, 7:43) – The first of five visual effects featurettes shows the performance capture process and using CGI technology to create the various stages of Benjamin Button's life.
  • Visual Effects: Benjamin (HD, 16:55) – This one covers Brad Pitt's transformation into the odd character by taking plaster molds of his face and aging them to use as the templates for the computer models.
  • Visual Effects: Youthenization (HD, 6:21) – Using a process called Digital Cosmetic Enhancement, this snippet discusses how certain cast members were given digital treatments to appear younger on screen.
  • Visual Effects: The Chelsea (HD, 8:48) – An interesting look at the creation of the tugboat set in a studio and adding the finishing touches with CGI groundwork.
  • Visual Effects: The Simulated World (HD, 12:52) – The final effects featurette covers adding computer images to scenes from specific time periods and creating realistic overhead shots of digital cityscapes.
  • Sound Design (HD, 16:06) – Next, we get to see how sound effects were applied to certain scenes and their use to mask flaws in the recorded audio.
  • Desplat's Instrumentarium (HD, 14:53) – Rounding out this section is an interview with acclaimed French composer Alexandre Desplat with an inside look at his studio and orchestra.

Birth: Premiere

  • Premiere (HD, 4:20) – A short vignette covering the film's premiere in New Orleans, Louisiana on December 1, 2008 including clips of cast and crew reflecting on their experiences.
  • Production Stills – An additional gallery containing numerous photos from the overall production.

Besides the mammoth multi-part featurette mentioned above, the release also contains a few more odds and ends worth mentioning:

  • Stills Gallery – This section basically just gathers all of the previously mentioned galleries (Storyboards, Art Direction, Costumes, and Production Stills) into one area for convenience purposes.
  • Trailers (HD, 4:31) – The final inclusion on the second disc are a couple of theatrical trailers.
  • Pamphlet – Although this release doesn't include the usual Criterion booklet, there is a high quality glossy pamphlet enclosed with an essay The Man Who Watched The Hours Go By by film critic Kent Jones as well as a brief cast and crew credit listing.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

The only real Blu-ray exclusive is the Timeline feature common to Criterion titles which enables viewers to bookmark their favorite scenes using their remote.

Final Thoughts

'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' is a curious film indeed. It tells a very intriguing and unique story about the life experiences of a peculiar individual, and the three Oscars it won are certainly most well-deserved. However, a few minor hiccups in the screenplay are enough to bring it down a peg off the masterpiece pedestal for me. Anyhow, the Criterion Collection rolls out the red carpet for this Blu-ray release with reference-quality video as well as audio, and although the meaty supplements may be a reviewer's nightmare, they're definitely bound to be any fan's dream -- which easily makes the whole package one of the first must-own titles of 2009.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc/BD-25 SIngle-Layer Disc
  • Two-Disc Set

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/TBA

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subitltes

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Documentary

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Related reviews