Blu-ray
Bad Flick, Good Disc
3.5 stars
Amazon
$8.50
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
1 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3.5 Stars
Supplements
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
2.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Bad Flick, Good Disc

Mamma Mia! The Movie

Street Date:
December 16th, 2008
Reviewed by:
Peter Bracke
Review Date: 1
December 5th, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
Universal Studios Home Video
Length:
109 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

It may be uncool, but I will happily go on record saying that I like ABBA. The superswedes have concocted some great -- no, make that brilliant -- pop songs that have stood the test of time. They may have once been the '70s answer to Celine Dion (i.e., had a hip quotient of negative ten), but now it's impossible to hear classics like "Dancing Queen," "SOS," or "Waterloo" and not admire their craftsmanship, exuberance and sheer pop-ability. Yet, at the same time, there has always been a theatrical quality to ABBA's music that went unnoticed by most critics and even their ardent fans. Which is why I, for one, was not surprised when the band's catalogue of songs were used as the basis for an eventual smash stage musical, "Mamma Mia!" In hindsight it all seems obvious, a natural progression for a band whose sticky 'n' sweet pop concoctions could now easily serve as a threadbare narrative for an even more saccharine, family-friend musical theater extravaganza.

With the "Mamma Mia!" gravy train still running strong on Broadway and throughout the world, it was only a matter of time before the musical would be turned into a movie. But unlike musicals-to-movies before it that flopped (the dreadful 'The Producers' comes to mind), the big-screen version of 'Mamma Mia!' has become a true cinematic phenomenon, a movie that has grossed nearly $600 million worldwide (and counting) and once again brought ABBA's music to a whole new generation of fans. Unfortunately, unlike superior musical-to-movies like 'Hairspray,' 'Mamma Mia!' is a pretty darn awful film -- an incompetent mess that left me in awe of its absolute ineptitude.

First, the plot. Cute little Sophie Sheridan (Amanda Seyfried) lives on an isolated island with her ex-hippie mother Donna (Meryl Streep), who runs a quaint little bed and breakfast for tourists. Though Sophie is about to be married to a local stud muffin (Dominic Cooper), she's been wrecked with heartache over the absence of her father, whose identity Donna has always kept hidden. So Sophie hatches a plan: since Donna was a big ho in her youth, Sophie invites the three most likely culprits (Pierce Brosnan, Stellan Skarsgaard, and Colin Firth) to her wedding, hoping that eventually one of them will reveal himself to be dear old dad. Along the way, a host of supporting players (including Donna's aging, amorous best friends, played by Christine Baranski and Julie Walters) get involved in all the schemes and secrets, culminating in a big mountaintop wedding filled with startling surprises.

I wanted to like 'Mamma Mia!' I really did. But this film is impossible to embrace because of it's incompetence. Directed by first-timer Phyllida Lloyd (who piloted the Broadway version) and scripted by Catherine Johnson (who also penned the original stage book), 'Mamma Mia!' has to be one of the most poorly-choreographed, horribly-sung and badly-shot big-screen musicals I've ever seen. The list of cinematic offenses here is almost too long to list.

Let's start with the hideous photography. The film had the beautiful Greek isles as a backdrop, yet the filmmakers chose to shoot the majority at England's Pinewoods studios, on sets in front of blue screen, which results in an ugly, out-of-focus look to the majority of the movie. (It's like watching 'The Phantom Menace' as a musical, only with Meryl Streep instead of Jar Jar Binks.) Then there's the dancing, which has an all-over-the-place haphazardness, as if Lloyd set up a bunch of cameras, told the actors to run around and flail about wildly, and figured it would all come together in the editing. And then there is the -- oy! -- singing. The vocal deficiencies of Streep, Baranski, and most heinously Brosnan are readily apparent. I swear, when the ex-James Bond first started warbling "SOS," even my dog leapt under the couch. For god's sakes, if you're are going to hire big-name actors to sing ABBA, then couldn't you have paid for some voice lessons? Or better yet, hired real singers to dub over them?

To be fair, much of the charm of the stage version of "Mamma Mia!" lay in the silly way the ABBA tunes were incorporated into the wafer-thin story. There was fine camp appeal in waiting for the next cheesy segueway to a song, and watching how in the heck Johnson was going to snatch some sort of narrative coherence out of relatively inane tunes like "Super Trooper" or "Honey Honey." But blown up to big-screen proportions, these deficiencies go from being cute to insufferable. It feels like amateur time, and given the talent involved, it's quite dispiriting. Compared to other recent musicals, particularly 'Hairspray' and even 'High School Musical 3,' it's a shame 'Mamma Mia!' didn't receive a more skilled treatment.

Judging by 'Mamma Mia!'s worldwide grosses, however, I'm sure millions of people disagree. Perhaps the success of the film is simply inexplicable to me. Like 'Look Who's Talking' or 'My Big Fat Greek Wedding,' 'Mamma Mia!' is one of those movies where I sat in the theater feeling like an alien, with everyone around me laughing and clapping, as if they were watching a totally different movie. As much as I love ABBA, I can only recommend 'Mamma Mia!' to those who would enjoy hearing the band's music badly sung, and accompanied by dumb dancing and a totally stupid story. If that sounds like a great time to you, then by all means enjoy this Blu-ray. But I will remain content to go and spin my copy of "ABBA Gold" for the hundredth time instead.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Mamma Mia' comes to Blu-ray in a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, framed at 2.40:1. I must admit that I saw the film in the theater and thought it had an ugly visual look. The good news is that this Blu-ray accurately recreates that experience. The bad news is that, well, the film looks ugly.

On the plus side, the source is pristine. Blacks are generally rock solid except for a couple of weird nighttime sequences where the mid-range of the grayscale is blown up to improve shadow detail but results in a flattening of the image. Otherwise, the daylight exotic exteriors benefit from the bright contrast and a good amount of apparent depth. Unfortunately, colors are overdone, which results in an ugly, waxy look (the actors are all lit terribly). Detail is sometimes strong, but the use of blue screen backdrops gives a distracting, oddly out-of-focus look that I really couldn't stand. The encode itself is strong, with no obvious artifacts save for a bit of noise on solid backgrounds. I'm giving this transfer four stars because it accurately reflects the stylistic intentions of the film, even if I really didn't enjoy looking at it.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Universal offers an English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround track (48kHz/24-bit) for 'Mamma Mia!' I found it a tad disappointing. While the track is technically sound, the mix lacks a surround presence, leaving it feeling surprisingly lifeless. (Note that there is also a "Sing-Along Version" of the film included. However, it is the same DTS-MA audio track, only with subtitles providing the lyrics to all of the film's songs. There is no true karaoke soundtrack option, aka sans vocals.)

Indeed, there is little envelopment throughout 'Mamma Mia!' We get some minor island ambiance during dialogue scenes, but otherwise the mix goes front-heavy for the musical numbers. Tech specs are generally good, however, with fine low bass and a decent sense of spaciousness and depth to the upper frequency range. I did find dialogue and the singing oddly disconnected however -- there is none of the sterling clarity of the original (and recently remastered for CD) ABBA recordings. There is also a muddled quality to the mix of non-musical and musical sequences, and the mix never felt organic and wholly natural. The DTS-MA track certainly isn't awful by any means, but I expected a soundtrack a bit more exciting than this.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

'Mamma Mia!' comes to Blu-ray with a bunch of extras. Expect sugar shock to set in quickly. (Most of the video materials are presented in full 1080i/VC-1, with English, French and Spanish subtitle options.)

  • Audio Commentary - Director Phyllida Lloyd flies solo on this track. Let it be said that she comes across as a very nice woman indeed, and she's obviously excited and passionate to be helming her first movie. Unfortunately, she's also a rather slow talker, so the commentary is rather dull. Lloyd discusses at length her decision-making in many key areas, including the need to shoot much of the movie on soundstages rather than on location (a move I found disastrous), along with the casting, the extensive voice rehearsals, and of course working with ABBA maestros Bjorn and Benny. I liked Lloyd after this track, but I still hated the movie she made.
  • Featurette: "The Making of Mamma Mia!" (HD, 25 minutes) - A condensed version of the audio commentary, this breezy EPK hits all of the same beats in less than a third of the time. Most amusing are the cast voice and choreography rehearsals, particularly watching the three male leads slip into their ridiculous spandex costumes. We also get some interesting production footage of the extensive blue screen sets, though this peek behind the curtain only makes the movie seem even cheesier in retrospect. Still, a decent enough featurette.
  • Featurette: "Becoming a Singer" (HD, 11 minutes) - By far, this is the most interesting featurette. Bjorn Ulvaeus and Benny Andersson brought back most of the original ABBA session musicians to recreate the tunes, and with the help of music supervisor Martin Lowe, guide the stars through singing some pretty difficult songs. I didn't love the results as much as the filmmakers seem to, but it's fun to watch everyone stumble through some truly awful karaoke (please, Mr. Brosnan, don't give up your day job).
  • Featurette: "Anatomy of a Musical Number" (HD, 6 minutes) - This quickie dissects the "Lay All Your Love on Me" number between Amanda Seyfried and Dominic Cooper, the latter who was extremely nervous performing the song for the ABBA songwriters. Once again, the choreography is ridiculous.
  • Featurette: "A Look Inside Mamma Mia!" (HD, 3 minutes) - Finally, we have this way-too-short look at the ABBA phenomenon, and the birth of the "Mamma Mia!" musical. Why only 3 minutes!?
  • Deleted Scenes (HD/SD, 8 minutes) - Presented as one long montage, there are about a half-dozen cut scenes here, including a long introduction for the male leads, a surprisingly steamy (for a PG-13 flick) love scene between Sophie and her fiancee, and not-too-funny shenanigans with Meryl Streep, Christine Baranski and Julie Walters. Further excerpts include a barely 2-minute long series of Outtakes, plus a cut musical number, "The Name of the Game." This is one of my favorite ABBA songs, and it is weakly performed by Seyfried. (Video is presented in poor-quality 480i/MPEG-2 only, except for "The Name of the Game," which is 1080p/VC-1 and approaches the main feature.)
  • Music Video: "Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!" (HD, 5 minutes) - Funny, but this clever take-off of the original ABBA "Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!" music video is way better than anything in the actual 'Mamma Mia!' movie. There is a lesson to be learned here, I'm sure...

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Not content to merely repackage the DVD, Universal has added a host of exclusive features, too.

  • U-Control: Picture-in-Picture - The best feature of the pack is probably this PIP track. It features some of the footage found in the standard suite of featurettes, but many additional excerpts that were cut from the same batch of interview and behind the scenes material. Unfortunately, the pacing could have been improved -- there are too many gaps of dead air, which keeps this PIP from being truly top drawer.
  • U-Control: "Behind the Hits" - Essentially a pop-up discography, you can activate a graphic overlay that provides original song and album detail about all the ABBA tunes in 'Mamma Mia!' In addition to release dates, brief factoids are given about a particular song's creation, instrumentation and other interesting tidbits. I doubt any hardcore ABBA fan won't already know all of this information, but it's a fun feature nonetheless.
  • BD-Live: My Scenes Sharing - Here you can bookmark your favorite chapters for easy access even after you eject the disc from your player, or share your favorite clips with others on the web.
  • BD-Live: My Chat - Here you can watch the film simultaneously with other users who have BD-Live capable players, and chat along with the flick -- sort of like a live 'Mamma Mia!' online blog.
  • BD-Live: My Movie Commentary - Certainly the most innovative BD-Live extra yet from Universal, 'Mamma Mia!' is the studio's first Blu-ray release to allow you to record your own video commentary (webcam required), then download it to share with others on the web. Watching your commentary, it will appear as a picture-in-picture window over the main feature, much like a standard PIP track. Very cool, and very fun.

Final Thoughts

I'm sorry, I hated 'Mamma Mia!' I love ABBA, but all we get in the movie is a lame story, crappy choreography and badly-sung versions of great songs. This Blu-ray is a winner, however, with good video and audio, and a ton of extras. Any fan of the movie will love this disc, so if you are one of the millions who sang along with 'Mamma Mia!' in the theater, then by all means rush out and buy this Blu-ray.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc
  • Bonus View (Profile 1.1)
  • BD-Live (Profile 2.0)

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround (48kHz/24-bit)
  • French DTS 5.1 Surround (1.5mbps)
  • Spanish DTS 5.1 Surround (1.5mbps)

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Featurettes
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Sing-a-Long Version
  • Digital Copy

Exclusive HD Content

  • Picture-in-Picture
  • My Scenes
  • BD-Live