Blu-ray
Recommended
4 stars
List Price
$24.99
Amazon
$13.13 (47%)
3rd Party
$5.95
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
5 Stars
Supplements
3 Stars
High-Def Extras
1 Stars
Bottom Line
Recommended

Cloverfield

Street Date:
June 3rd, 2008
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
June 3rd, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
Paramount Home Entertainment
Length:
84 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

In 1998, Hollywood attempted to revive a classic Japanese monster and deliver citywide devastation to the cinematic masses. Unfortunately, Roland Emmerich’s 'Godzilla' was the result of their efforts. Loaded with paper-thin characters, comical disaster sequences, and a relatively harmless monster, this monumental failure left a sour taste in the mouth of audiences across the world. It would take Hollywood nearly ten years to unleash another destructive lizard on New York City, this time in the form of a cryptic beastie. A viral marketing campaign for the enigmatic 'Cloverfield' appeared without warning, offering salivating creature-feature fans glimpses of massive destruction left in the path of... something.

Told entirely from the perspective of a single handheld video camera, ‘Cloverfield’ follows a pack of young New Yorkers scrambling to survive the assault of an enormous creature. The newly-formed band of survivors includes a businessman named Rob (Michael Stahl-David), his best friend and camera-toting pal Hud (T.J. Miller), his brother Jason (Mike Vogel), Jason’s girlfriend Lily (Jessica Lucas), and a resident red-shirt named Marlena (Lizzy Caplan). After witnessing the vast devastation left by the monster with their own eyes, the group frantically tries to escape the city. However, when Rob gets a desperate call from his ex-flame Beth (Odette Yustman), he decides to turn back and try to rescue her before it’s too late.

'Cloverfield' could have been awful. Its handheld camera gimmick could have devolved into a repetitive stunt, its characters could have been stale caricatures, and its story could have been underdeveloped and flimsy. Thankfully, producer J.J. Abrams and rookie film director Matt Reeves seemed to have anticipated these potential problems since they address each one early in the film. Rob’s birthday party provides the perfect framework for the logistics of the handheld documentation of the attack, a series of farewell messages to Rob allow the filmmakers to introduce characters without unnatural exposition, and Rob’s unrelenting love for a girl he can’t have allows his character to run into danger instead of away from it. I was thoroughly pleased with the connection I felt to the characters and their struggles. Deaths felt more personal than I expected, and the crumbling city sent chills down my spine.

It doesn’t hurt that the cinematography is fantastic. Don’t be fooled into assuming the film’s handheld perspective will limit the impact of the story -- each shot has been carefully plotted to generate palpable tension and entertaining thrills. Glimpses of the monster are fleeting and -- as a result -- startling. The beast appears to be literally larger-than-life because we initially can’t see its entire form from our position on the ground. Adding even greater dimension to the film is the filmmakers’ convincing vision of a ruined city. Glass falls like rain, skyscrapers shatter violently and topple to the ground, and ominous billows of smoke pour through each city block. The imagery is immediately evocative of September 11th and its similarities are played to great effect without feeling gratuitous. All in all, Reeves and Abrams know how to create atmosphere and they do so with increasing intensity at every turn.

If I have any major complaint it’s with the behemoth itself. The ‘Cloverfield’ monster was shrouded in secrecy for so long that I really began to believe I was going to see something I had never seen before -- something so indescribably bizarre and Lovecraftian in nature that its mere appearance would turn my hair white. In retrospect, I suppose I feel victim to the inevitable consequence of hype. When the film reaches its climactic conclusion, a peek at the entire beast in the morning sun struck me as funny, undermining the anxiety Reeves and Abrams had spent an hour-and-a-half lodging in my gut. I hate to say it, but the creature instantly reminded me of the pale monstrosity that made its awkward debut in 'Alien: Resurrection.'

Regardless of my expectations, I was captivated by 'Cloverfield's unwaveringly bleak tone, its cast of fairly compelling characters, and its stunning special effects. Best of all, I laughed, squirmed in my seat, and exhaled sharply on more than one occasion. 'Cloverfield' may not reinvent the genre wheel, but it offers everything Roland Emmerich’s ‘Godzilla’ failed to deliver ten years ago.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The moment I walked out of the theater back in January, I began to wonder how 'Cloverfield' would handle the transition to high-def disc. Honestly, I imagined a blurry, noisy mess akin to ’28 Days Later,’ a sub-par release that failed to provide a substantial upgrade over its standard DVD counterpart. I certainly didn’t expect a sharp and attractive transfer that renders every shard of rubble with a level of care afforded to the best BD titles on the market.

Presented with a striking 1080p/VC-1 transfer, 'Cloverfield' looks wonderful. The film’s undersaturated palette isn’t meant to explode off the screen, but the image is blessed with strong primaries and incredibly natural skintones. The orange haze of fire and the yellow smear of streetlights look especially remarkable, giving each scene a distinct (yet consistent) tone. Black levels may be slightly uneven at times (the tunnel scenes falter a bit), but dark expanses and shadows are deep and well-delineated throughout the majority of the film. Better still, the level of fine object defies the conventions of the film’s camcorder gimmick and produces a series of astonishing textures and crisp edges. Sure, there are intentional bursts of static and softness littered throughout the production, but these irregularities always register as enhancements to the tone of the film rather than distractions from the picture quality. Best of all, there isn’t any edge enhancement, major crushing, or significant artifacting to be found. There are light swarms of source noise in the darkest scenes, but nothing that undermines the overall quality of the transfer.

If any relative charge can be leveled against this transfer it’s that it doesn’t pack quite the same wow factor as glossier Blu-ray releases. As it stands, this gritty creature-feature isn’t the greatest thing I’ve ever seen crash across my screen, but it genuinely shattered my expectations. Considering its filmmakers worked overtime to make it look like something captured on a handheld camera, this Blu-ray presentation of 'Cloverfield' is an impressive sight to behold.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

’Cloverfield’ may look great in high definition, but it sounds even better. Paramount has mastered a reference-quality Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track that perfectly captures the authority and resonance of the film’s theatrical presentation. First and foremost, the actors’ lines are crisp and clean despite intentional alterations to their vocal timbre (the filmmakers have intentionally processed the dialogue to sound as if it’s been captured on a camcorder). More importantly, prioritization is flawless even when deafening chaos realistically overwhelms key elements of the soundfield. Crowd screams are suddenly muffled any time a room-shaking roar or building collapse floods the soundscape. In these moments, outstanding LFE support left me in sheer awe of the nuanced low-end pulses pouring from my subwoofer. To top it all off, my rear speakers were constantly brimming with effects neatly linked to every object on the screen, regardless of its size or significance.

Even from a technical perspective, I had a hard time finding fault with 'Cloverfield’s audio. The underground subway attack exhibits perfect channel pans, the bridge collapse features extraordinary directionality, and the high-rise climb showcases delicate acoustics and absorbing effects. Ambiance takes such a central and pervasive role in the film that I can’t think of a single moment where I was reminded I was watching a movie -- the soundfield was so involving that I remained fully immersed in the film from beginning to end. I hesitate to make such definitive declarations about a title, but 'Cloverfield' unquestionably boasts one of the strongest audio tracks I’ve heard all year.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

This Blu-ray edition of 'Cloverfield' packs in all of the special features that appear on the standard DVD. presented here in high definition. But that's not all -- this edition also includes a substantial Blu-ray exclusive (discussed in the next section).

  • Director’s Commentary -- Matt Reeves sits down to talk about the origins of 'Cloverfield,' the locations for the shoot, the stylistic direction of the cinematography, and the extent of producer J.J. Abrams involvement in the project. I was happy to find the former television director to be refreshingly candid throughout the proceedings, discussing everything fans of the film would find valuable withoutspending too much time on the technical aspects of the special effects. While this track probably won’t win over anyone who didn’t enjoy the film, it’s definitely worth a listen.
  • The Making of Cloverfield (HD, 28 minutes) -- This dry featurette is the first ina collection of peices that explore the production of 'Cloverfield.' Focusing on the cast and crew, producer J.J. Abrams, and the extensive sets and locations used in the film, this one uses interviews and behind-the-scenes footage to deliver a fairly standard EPK.
  • Cloverfield Visual Effects (HD, 23 minutes) -- This second featurette gives a complete overview of the Cloverfield beastie, the CG-enhanced destruction of New York, the creature’s miniature spawn, and the effects used to highlight the feel of the handheld camera. I appreciated all of the information in this peice, but I particularly enjoyed that it showed the cast and crew working to make the effects more realistic through their performances.
  • I Saw It! It’s Alive! It’s Huge! (HD, 6 minutes) -- This all-too-brief featurette focuses on the design of the Cloverfield monster, its history as a character, and its on-screen biology and motivations.
  • Deleted Scenes (HD, 3 minutes) -- Presented with optional director’s commentary, the four bland cuts featured in this collection wouldn’t have added much to the final film.
  • Alternate Endings (HD, 5 minutes) -- The deleted scenes may be a bust, but the two alternate endings are a blast. They’ll certainly give fans something to debate until the inevitable sequel makes its way to theaters. Like the regular cuts, the alternate endings are also presented with optional director’s commentary.
  • Clover Fun (HD, 4 minutes) -- A decent series of outtakes.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Rather than tossing together a standard trivia track, Paramount gives us a Blu-ray exclusive "Special Investigation Mode" -- a PiP feature of sorts that will intrigue fans looking to dig through the film yet again. While the film plays in a smaller window, the rest of the screen is devoted to a map that tracks the movements of the civilians, military personnel, and the monster over the course of the attack. At the same time, factoids about the locations, characters, and creatures pop up and fill in quite a few details that aren’t covered elsewhere on the disc. It may sound like a mundane exclusive (and I'm generally not a fan of trivia tracks), but I actually had a good time with this one.

Easter Eggs

Reports of ‘Cloverfield’ easter eggs have been pouring in from our faithful readers! Thanks to Michael (aka Nusilver), Eliot, Andrew Fitzsimmons, and other message board regulars for these tips.

  • Viral Videos -- From the main menu, proceed to the chapter selection menu and highlight “13-16.” If you wait for one-minute and seventeen seconds, a seventeenth chapter will appear. It leads to a collection of viral videos, the Chuai station destruction short, a semi-functional Slusho! website, a corresponding commercial, and a series of clips recorded by a character named Jami Lascano for her boyfriend Teddy Hanssen.
  • X Creatures -- Next, highlight scene 10 in the selection menu and press up to reveal a hidden “X.” Click on this button to watch a short clip of the tunnel attack in its early form.
  • Military Cast -- Head over to the audio menu, highlight the Spanish option, and press right two times to find a helicopter icon. Click on this button to watch the film’s cast members have some fun.

Final Thoughts

’Cloverfield’ may not live up to everyone’s expectations, but I really enjoyed its ambition, atmosphere, and characters. Regardless of your opinion of the film itself, Paramount has definitely made its return to Blu-ray in style. This BD edition of ‘Cloverfield’ offers fans a surprisingly strong video transfer that easily outclasses the standard DVD, a reference-quality TrueHD audio track, and a thorough collection of supplements. An easy recommend all around.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 50GB Dual-Layer
  • Region Free

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.85:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround
  • French Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • English Subtitles
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles
  • Portuguese Subtitles

Supplements

  • Audio Commentary
  • Featurettes
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Alternate Endings

Exclusive HD Content

  • Picture in Graphics Track

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$24.99
Amazon
$13.13 (47%)
3rd Party
$5.95
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»