Blu-ray
Worth a Look
3.5 stars
List Price
$14.98
Amazon
$8.99 (40%)
3rd Party
$4.94
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
3 Stars
HD Video Quality
4 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
0.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
2.5 Stars
Bottom Line
Worth a Look

Be Kind Rewind

Street Date:
June 17th, 2008
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
June 23rd, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2008
Studio:
New Line Home Entertainment
Length:
102 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

French director Michel Gondry first caught my attention in 2004 with the debut of his trippy masterwork, ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.’ Drenched in surreal imagery, pulsing with inventive technique, and teeming with spectacular practical effects, I preemptively labeled Gondry the next Terry Gilliam. Sadly, Gondry’s post-Sunshine efforts failed to strike the same chord. I shrugged my shoulders at his uneven follow-up, ‘Dave Chappelle’s Block Party,’ sighed my way through his next feature film, the naïve and redundant ‘The Science of Sleep,’ and was disappointed and frustrated by the latest entry in his canon, ‘Be Kind Rewind.’

When an aging businessman named Mr. Fletcher (Danny Glover) leaves his VHS-rental shop in the hands of a clerk named Mike (Mos Def), he gives the young man a single instruction: to keep a blundering conspiracy theorist named Jerry (Jack Black) out of his store. When Jerry’s fear of microwaves and the government leads him to sabotage a local power plant, an electrical mishap magnetizes his body. Vomiting uncontrollably, Jerry finds his way into Mr. Fletcher’s store and inadvertently erases all of the VHS tapes on the shelves. As customers begin returning a slew of blank tapes, Mike scrambles to fix the situation before Mr. Fletcher comes home. With a bulky camcorder, Jerry, and a local named Alma (Melonie Diaz) at his side, Mike reshoots the movies and rents the new “Sweded” versions to customers. Bracing himself for the worst, the trio of clerks are shocked when people begin to enjoy their low-budget recreations more than the original films.

At its heart, ‘Be Kind Rewind’ is actually a delightful comedy about a forgotten jazz legend named Fats Waller, a local community’s indomitable spirit, and an old man struggling to find his way in a modern world. When Gondry focuses on these more personal elements, his film sizzles and delivers a genuinely touching story about down-on-their-luck losers overcoming impossible odds. In fact, when Mos Def and Danny Glover frequent the screen, everything worked for me -- I really enjoyed watching Mike take control of his situation as Mr. Fletcher fought against a naïve belief that everything would come together in the end. However, the moment Gondry turns his attention to Jack Black, the otherwise quaint modern fairytale becomes a vehicle for the comedian’s usual schtick. Granted, Black injects the film with some decent laughs, but he also creates a thematic conflict. As a result, Gondry seems to be making two separate films: a brash farce with Black and a subtle comedy with Def.

The patchy outcome feels uneven and inconsistent at times, subverting the better material Gondry, Black, and Def have packed into the story. An ambiguous romance between Alma and Mike isn’t given any room to breathe, Mr. Fletcher’s fascination with Fats Waller isn’t properly explored, and his rivalry with another video store owner is completely overlooked even though it becomes a crucial component in the film’s climax. To make matters worse, Gondry’s clever imagination has been undermined by an all-too-revealing theatrical trailer. Anyone who’s seen the film’s preview has also seen almost every “Sweded” short the director created for the film. Ruined is the entire ‘Ghostbusters’ remake, the best ‘Miss Daisy’ bits, and many of the briefly-glimpsed remakes that fill ‘Be Kind Rewind’s Swede montages. I actually think I would’ve liked the film a bit more had I known nothing about it.

Even so, I still think ‘Be Kind Rewind’ is worth watching. Anyone who isn’t annoyed by the disjointed tonal issues I had with the film will probably really enjoy their time with the eclectic and amiable natives of Passaic, New Jersey. However, since Gondry has proven he can make brilliant, mind-bending films, this one feels like an ordinary waste of a more intriguing premise. With a tighter script, a few more leftfield surprises, and fuller character development, ‘Be Kind Rewind’ could’ve been the film promised by its theatrical trailer.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

For a flick focused on a pair of bumbling losers shooting low-budget short films, ’Be Kind Rewind’s 1080p/VC-1 transfer looks surprisingly good. While Gondry uses an even bleaker palette than he did in ‘Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind,’ primaries (particularly reds and blues) have a distinct pop that keep the image lively and stable. Contrast is also strong, boasting inky blacks and a pleasing vibrancy that isn’t hindered by crushing or blooming. Better still, sharp details keep the picture looking fresh and highlight the movie posters, hand-written signs, and antiques cluttering Mr. Fletcher’s video store. Best of all, the transfer isn’t cluttered with noise as I expected -- purists and fans won’t suffer at the hands of significant artifacting, edge enhancement, print damage, or the image-diluting DNR (Digital Noise Reduction) that’s popped up on other New Line releases.

In fact, compared to the bland and blocky standard DVD, this Blu-ray release is a godsend. There are a handful of intentional visual hiccups -- Gondry employs a few soft shots, contrast inconsistencies, and delineation discrepancies to augment the mood of the film -- and the footage of Mike and Jerry’s “Sweded” productions looks decidedly low-rent, but the remaining scenes in ‘Be Kind Rewind’ have been meticulously refined to produce a noteworthy transfer. As it stands, anyone who enjoyed Gondry’s patchwork story and his protagonists’ surreal shenanigans will fall in love with this pleasant high-def presentation.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

New Line has put together an exciting DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 surround track for ‘Be Kind Rewind’ that pushes past the film’s talkative soundscape with busy ambience and realistic acoustics. First and foremost, I was surprised by the depth of the LFE channel since I assumed the film would be fairly quiet and subdued. Low-end bass pulses frequently enhance scenes that involve Jerry’s magnetism, mechanical elements like construction equipment, and the musical score itself. Those with 7.1 audio set-ups will notice how the additional rear speakers really help recreate the fullness of bustling city streets and crowd chatter. When the filmfans of Passaic got together to watch Mike and Jerry’s Fats Waller short, my home theater became their small makeshift auditorium. Voices were placed at precise positions in the soundfield, transparent pans allowed the camera to convincingly weave through the crowd, and sound effects naturally echoed within the confined space.

I do have one nitpick, but I thankfully didn’t find anything else that significantly detracted from the audio. While dialogue was crisp and well-prioritized for the most part, I found line clarity was a bit too dependent on where scenes were shot. The ‘Ghostbusters’ library and ‘Robocop’ underpass scenes are occasionally overwhelmed by other elements in the soundfield, leaving the actors’ words slightly muddled. Regardless, ‘Be Kind Rewind’s audio track is quite impressive and does a nice job recreating the theatrical experience.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

While the DVD release of ‘Be Kind Rewind’ only included two extras, the Blu-ray edition packs in a generous helping of exclusive content (detailed at length in the next section). Unfortunately, all of the special features are presented in 480i/p standard definition.

  • Passaic Mosaic (SD, 10 minutes) -- One of the best surprises of ‘Be Kind Rewind’ is documented in this charming little featurette: Gondry culled actual residents of Passaic, New Jersey when he was casting supporting roles in his film. This short not only serves to explore the history of Passaic, it includes interviews with the director, the local amateur performers, and other key members of the cast and crew.
  • Theatrical Trailer (SD, 3 minutes) -- Had I not seen this all too revealing preview before catching ‘Be Kind Rewind’ in theaters, I would’ve probably enjoyed the film a bit more. It’s mistake is giving away most of the best “Sweded” bits.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

The BD exclusive features come in a variety of flavors and deliver plenty of behind-the-scenes information for fans of the film. The lone downside is that the disc doesn’t have a commentary of any sort -- I would’ve loved to listen to Gondry, Black, and/or Def discuss the production in detail.

  • The Making of Be Kind Rewind (SD, 33 minutes) -- This generous behind-the-scenes documentary covers every angle of the production including its writing, set design, performances, various edits, and reception. Through it all, we get interviews with all the major players as well as footage of several candid moments that occurred over the course of the shoot. All in all, this is a detailed, well-made documentary that should easily please fans of the film.
  • Booker T and The Michel Gondry (SD, 7 minutes) – Initially cut before being reinserted into the film, this scene between Danny Glover and a group of early jazz mainstays (including Booker T) is a real treat. This mini-doc not only explores the shoot, but features interviews with the musicians and a glimpse at Glover’s heartfelt reaction to working with such legendary icons.
  • A Conversation with Jack Black and Michel Gondry (SD, 6 minutes) -- This all-too-short interview still offers a lot of information about the production and the genesis of the script. Black sticks to his schtick a bit too much, but Gondry keeps things moving with anecdotes about casting, the shoot, Sweding, and the final edit of the film.
  • Fats Waller Short Film (SD, 12 minutes) -- This is the full cut of the documentary Mike, Jerry, and the town of Passaic create about jazz musician Fats Waller. Honestly, this was one of my favorite parts of ‘Be Kind Rewind,’ but their film-within-a-film was chopped up and distributed throughout the main feature. As it stands, I genuinely enjoyed the chance to watch the it in one, uninterrupted sitting.
  • Jack Black and Mos Def Improvise Songs (SD, 5 minutes) -- The comedic pair take a moment to improv several theme songs (a la Black’s ‘Ghostbusters’ riff) not included in the final film. I would rattle off the films they spoof, but the songs are much better if you don’t know what’s coming next.
  • A Tribute to Fats Waller: LIVE! (SD, 6 minutes) -- This quickie offers footage from an actual performance in France featuring a surprising jazz trio: a drum-pounding Gondry, a piano-playing Jean-Michel Bernard, and a singing/scatting Mos Def. It’s not a funny performance either. The three men hold their own and effectively demonstrate exactly why the history of jazz was such an integral component of the film.

Final Thoughts

’Be Kind Rewind’ doesn’t boast the consistent comedy or tight script I hoped Gondry would deliver, but it still manages to offer fun subplots and charming characters. While this one won’t find a home on my shelf, I’m pretty sure other people will find a lot to enjoy. Fans of the film will really enjoy this Blu-ray edition from New Line. Not only does it supply a generous selection of exclusive supplements, it offers an excellent video transfer and DTS HD MA audio track. So give it a spin and let us know what you think!

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 50GB Dual-Layer Disc
  • Region A Locked

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • Spanish Subtitles

Supplements

  • Featurette
  • Theatrical Trailer

Exclusive HD Content

  • Documentary
  • Featurettes
  • Short Film

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$14.98
Amazon
$8.99 (40%)
3rd Party
$4.94
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»