Heroes: Season Two
- Street Date:
- August 26th, 2008
- Reviewed by:
- Peter Bracke
- Review Date: 1
- August 24th, 2008
- Movie Release Year:
- Universal Studios Home Entertainment
- 482 Minutes
- MPAA Rating:
- Release Country
- United States
The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take
If ever there was a second season of a recent hit TV show that defined "sophomore slump," it's 'Heroes.' Not since season two of 'Desperate Housewives' nearly deep-sixed it as a cultural phenomenon has a show so famously imploded, with the middling critical and fan reaction to 'Heroes' second go-round just about obliterating its hip quotient -- what was once pegged as the all-round coolest television serial since 'Lost' suddenly seemed like this year's 'Commander in Chief.' The silver lining, however, comes from the fact that now that the dust has settled, and with the show gearing up for its much-buzzed-about third season, we can look back with a more open mind and ask the question -- was season two of 'Heroes' really that bad?
The answer is, "sort of." 'Heroes' season two is by no means terrible television, but compared to the involving first season, it is indeed a letdown. Hampered by the writer's strike (which curtailed the season to only eleven episodes, versus the usual average of about twenty-two), 'Heroes' sophomore year was marred by a feeling that its makers misjudged just about every aspect of where to take the show -- it's characters, its storylines, and its newly-introduced thematic elements. While the show's production values remained high, it just felt inert and meandering. Perhaps, then, the writer's strike was actually a good thing -- this aborted second season can thus be viewed as a sort of errant cul-de-sac for the show, rather than a dead end.
As I generally hate spoiler-filled plot synopses, it's difficult to discuss the failings of 'Heroes' in its second season without ruining the many plot developments for those who haven't seen it. Suffice to say, creator Tim Kring and his collaborators have made the arguable decision to splinter-off the show's memorable characters into their own little parallel subplots, which rarely intersect to any satisfactory degree and, even on their own terms, are only fairly engaging. One of the strongest aspects for me of the 'Heroes' first season was the sense that these burgeoning superheroes occupied the same world -- that a cohesive universe existed of action and consequence. Season two replaces integration with fragmentation, which severely damages our faith that the filmmakers know where they are taking us, and also severely cripples characters that have quickly gone from fascinating to insufferable.
In hindsight, given the buzz they generated in season one, it's surprising that season two wastes both Hiro and Claire (aka, "Save the cheerleader!") Why is Hiro banished to feudal Japan? Granted, his search for his childhood idol, the mysterious Takezo Kensei, has an enjoyable Kaizer Soze-esque excitement to it, and I enjoyed the 'Wizard of Oz'-like denouenement, but Hiro's ultimate arc in season two doesn't really seem to have anything to do with the rest of the show. Then there is Claire, who suddenly seems to find herself stranded in 'Smallville,' as she is essentially forced to repeat the same basic story as season one. Only now she's saddled with a new superhero-boyfriend and too much teen melodrama -- it gets so desperate at one point that the best the show's creators can do is give us mean-girl cheerleaders. Did Clearasil sponsor season two?
Most of the other storylines are equally squandered. Siblings Maya and Alejandro were interesting at first, but spend season two doing nothing much of consequence. The extended family of Niki, Micah and D.L. also get a new cousin, Monica, who discovers she has the power of mimicry, but the fun is mostly benign (kickboxing, really?), so these characters feel underserved, too. Even the villains are a bit of a disappointment, with Sylar returning in a different way, and only the "nightmare man" managing to do anything cool and interesting. At least newcomer Kristen Bell (of 'Veronica Mars' fame) gives the show a much-needed injection of excitement and energy, as an electro-spewing little vixen who eventually teams up with Monica. The pair seem to be the only heroes who actually want to use their powers, and with season one standout Ali Larter all but written out of the show, they give 'Heroes' its only real shot of much-needed estrogen.
It may sound as though I'm being overly hard on 'Heroes: Season Two,' and that I unanimously hated it. Not so -- even as disappointing as last year's season was -- it remains fairly engaging if taken on its own limited terms. It's still better than much of the crap that floods network TV these days. And at only eleven episodes, committing to watching the entire second season (if only to remain up to speed for season three) is hardly an outrageous time commitment. It's just too bad that a show that was such a gangbusters success in its first outing had to fall so hard so fast. I guess we'll just have to cross our fingers and hope for a rebirth in season three...
The Video: Sizing Up the Picture
'Heroes: Season Two' comes to Blu-ray as a four-disc set, containing all eleven episodes. There are four episodes on each of the first two BD-50 dual-layer discs, and the remaining three episodes are spread across the final two BD-25 single-layer discs. All encodes are 1080p/VC-1 (at 1.78:1). The quality here surprised me, as it is a fair step up from 'Season One.' The show's sophomore season may have been critically lambasted, but the production values were slightly improved.
Though 'Season One' certainly looked good for a TV-on-high-def release, 'Season Two' is brighter, better photographed, and richer in color. Blacks are nice and solid, and contrast runs more on the bold side than it did on 'Season One,' which further enhances depth. Visible detail is as strong as on some of the better theatrical features I've seen, with even long shots enjoying clear fine textures and superior sharpness. The color palette is also more impressive, with striking primaries and nice gradations across the spectrum. Hues never bleed or smear, and fleshtones are generally accurate.
These transfers do still run a tad dark (which was an even bigger problem on 'Season One'), but it's not particularly detrimental -- only shadow delineation is sometimes reduced due to black crush and occasions of low-key lighting. There's also a fair amount of grain, and it is inconsistent -- darker scenes in particular can suffer from heavy bursts that can be momentarily distracting. The encodes all appear clean, however, with no obvious artifacts save for minor (if consistent across the entire season's episodes) instances of motion jaggies. All in all, I was quite taken with these excellent transfers.
The Audio: Rating the Sound
Universal offers English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround tracks (48kHz/16-bit) for all eleven episodes of 'Heroes: Season Two.' It's not the leap over 'Season One' that the video transfers are, but it's still a nice set of mixes that far exceeds your typical TV-on-high-def audio presentation.
'Heroes' isn't really an action show despite its superhero subject matter, but when it does exploit spectacle, these mixes shine. Surround use, if not sustained for atmosphere, pumps out some noticeable discrete effects that exploit the full dynamic range. There is clear directionality with smooth pans, so localizing effects proves difficult -- these mixes rarely sound "gimmicky." Wendy & Lisa's scores still suffer in my opinion by being too low in the mix, and better dispersement to the rears would have even further enhanced these soundtracks. Dialogue remains the real star of the show, however, and it is strongly balanced throughout. Low bass -- if not a stunner -- hits some nice, deep places and supports the episodes very well. There are no other issues with the source or clarity of these DTS-MA mixes, making 'Heroes: Season Two' a strong example of how a TV-on-high-def release on Blu-ray should sound.
The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff
Universal continues to support 'Heroes' on Blu-ray with another strong set of extras. The studio has made a notable decision, however, to upgrade the audio commentaries found on the standard DVD release of 'Season Two' to PIP tracks on the Blu-ray, but not include the audio only versions here. So at first glance, it may appear that some content is "missing" from this release, but in actuality it has been repurposed. Otherwise, the remaining standard suite of extras from the DVD has all been ported to the Blu-ray. The studio has also bumped up the video to full 1080 (versus the standard-def of 'Season One'), and provides optional English, French, and Spanish subtitles on the video-based materials.
- Featurettes (HD, 80 minutes) - Spread across all four discs are five featurettes. First is "Heroes: Season 2: A New Beginning" (15 minutes). It's not very good, as it's largely promotional, and contains nothing we don't already know by watching the second season.
Disc two contains the 24-minute "Takezo Kensei: Sword Saint." This is really more of a "fake" documentary that offers a pretty clever fictional biography of Hiro's own hero of the title, complete with "historical" drawings and other art. Tacked on here is 9 minutes-worth of "Global News Interactive" clips that paint another fictional picture, this time of Richard Drucker of the Company. (Though this is a strange choice, as Drucker isn't even in 'Season 2' as far as I could tell...)
Disc three contains my vote for the best featurette, "Genetics of a Scene." Running 23 minutes, it gives a macro view of the making of the show by giving us a micro-dissection of four specific scenes of four different episodes. Directors Arkush and Beeman play the hosts, and there is a good cross-section of making-of footage, effects material, and additional cast & crew interview snippets. Though primarily focused more specifically on the directorial aspects of making 'Heroes,' this is a strong all-around production featurette.
Finally, we have the "Season 3 Sneak Peek." This 8-minute tease may be worth the price of admission for 'Heroes' fans alone, as cast and crew dangle carrots in front of us on the upcoming season's story threads and character developments. With 'Season 3' now being marketed as the "Villains" year, it boasts a good shot at easily besting the mixed results of 'Season 2.'
- Deleted Scenes/Alternate Ending (HD, 25 minutes) - There are 17 scenes in all, spread across their respective episode discs. As with 'Season One,' I didn't find much meat here. Some of these scenes are mere extensions with minimal additional dialogue. Much of this stuff also falls flat -- moments that are simply dull, or subplots that are really cul-de-sacs.
However, the big prize here is the inclusion of the alternate ending (18 minutes) to the show's closing episode. It can be found on disc four, and has been much discussed by fans as the second season was originally planned to conclude in a far different fashion. It's a shame that Universal has ruined the major change to the existing season ender right on the back of the Blu-ray box, and if not superior, than this ending is certainly ballsy. The ending is followed by an 18-minute video discussion with Kring, Loeb and co-executive producer/writer Jesse Alexander.
- Untold Stories (HD, 12 minutes) - This is a neat feature, a collection of six short clips that show us characters and stories that would have been integrated into the second season of the show had it not been shortened due to the writer's strike. There's even an intriguing final segment from Episode 13 that 'Heroes' fans will likely devour for its clues of season three. Very cool.
- Still Gallery (HD, 4 minutes) - Wrapping things up is a short montage of stills, featuring the art of Tim Sale. As on the 'Season One' Blu-ray, Sale's work is highlighted as it factors into the show's storylines involving Isaac and Peter. A thoughtful addition.
HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?
As mentioned above, Universal is presenting the audio commentaries on the standard DVD of 'Heroes: Season Two' in their original video form as picture-in-picture (with U-Control functionality). The presentation is straightforward, if nicely shot, and there is minimal editing between wide and close-ups of the participants. Otherwise, the exclusive content here is fairly minimal.
- Picture-in-Picture - If nothing else, these tracks are democratic -- there are eleven in all, one for each episode. In the interest of time (and my sanity), I sampled each for about 15 minutes just to get a general impression. Note that these PIP tracks are simply videographed interviews -- there is no behind-the-scenes footage or other making-of materials spliced in.
The four that immediately struck me where those that featured the appearance of cast members -- "The Kindness of Strangers" with creator Tim Kring and actors Dana Davis and Adrian Pasdar, "Four Months Ago..." with actor Milo Ventimiglia and executive producer Greg Beeman, "Out of Time" with director Daniel Attias and actor Masi Oka, and "Cautionary Tales" with director Greg Yaitanes and actors Kristen Bell and Ashley Crow. Pasdar and Oka are the most responsive, throwing out enough insightful stories and asking perceptive questions that I wound up listening to almost the complete commentaries of both. It's also nice to hear from Bell, the ex-'Veronica Mars' who received mixed notices by some and here gives interesting detail on what appealed to her about her character and the challenges of joining an established show with such a strong fan base.
The remaining video commentaries are more technical (read: dry), and include "Four Months Later" with Kring, co-executive producer Jeph Loeb and actor Jack Coleman, "Lizards" with executive producer Allan Arkush, co-executive producer Michael Green and Grunberg, "Fight or Flight" with Beeman and Grunberg, "The Line" with co-executive producers Adam Armus and Kay Foster, and Coleman, and "Truth & Consequences" with director Adam Kane and actor Stephen Tobolowsky.
Finally, there is the season closer, "Powerless" with Arkush and composers Lisa Coleman and Wendy Melvoin. Oddly, I expected a major track for this one with Kring and cast, but instead we mostly get Arkush and some sporadic comments (that really cover their work on the entire second season) by Coleman and Melvoin. Not a bad track, but still, a strange choice of participants.
- Hero Connections - Continuing the feature from 'Season One,' Universal again offers us evolutionary dossiers on the main characters of 'Heroes.' As the season progresses through each episode, you can toggle the U-Control icons to receive pop-up info on the various heroes and villains to chart their arcs and get other biographical data.
- BD-Live - Finally, Universal is touting 'Heroes: Season Two' as being BD-Live enabled -- or, at least one disc in the set is. At press time, the set has not streeted so there is no content available. The studio has not confirmed what content will launch when the disc hits stores, aside from the ability to share your MyScenes bookmarks, but check back here and we'll update when new content goes live.
'Heroes' doesn't avoid the sophomore slump. This is just not a great year for the show, despite some bright spots that may be enough to keep the diehards keeping the faith. (Of course, I still plan to tune in for the upcoming third season -- call me optimistic.) There's nothing bad to say about this blu-ray box set however. The video is excellent, the audio is strong, too, and there are plenty of great supplements. Whatever you may think of season two of 'Heroes,' this Blu-ray can't be beat.
- BD-50 Dual-Layer Discs
- Four-Disc Set
- Bonus View (Profile 1.1)
- BD-Live (Profile 2.0)
- English DTS-HD Lossless Master Audio 5.1 Surround
- English SDH
- French Subtitles
- Spanish Subtitles
- Deleted Scenes
Exclusive HD Content
All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More
about our gear.
Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.