Blu-ray
Skip it
2 stars
Overall Grade
2 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
3 Stars
HD Audio Quality
2.5 Stars
Supplements
0 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Skip it

Yes: Live at Montreux 2003

Street Date:
February 19th, 2008
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
February 14th, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2003
Studio:
Eagle Rock Entertainment
Length:
137 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Non-format-specific portions of this review were first published in our HD DVD review of 'Yes: Live at Montreux 2003.'

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

London, 1968. England had started to turn away from the pop-track sounds of its home brewed rock n' roll as new, progressive rock bands emerged on the scene. Progressive rock had been developing since the early '60s, but had only gained notoriety with the birth of bands like Pink Floyd. These bands weren't interested in three minute radio songs that would catch the common ear -- instead, they wanted to challenge listeners with something unique.

It was under this backdrop that singer Jon Anderson teamed with bass guitarist Chris Squire to form what would become the legendary rock group, Yes. While the band went through a series of supporting musicians in its early years, by 1972 Anderson and Squire had assembled a powerhouse lineup comprised of blues guitarist Steve Howe, keyboardist Rick Wakeman, and former John Lennon drummer Alan White.

Throughout the '70s, the five members of Yes refused to settle for music that recording labels considered a sure bet -- instead, they used a combination of classically-influenced suites and bizarre rhythm shifts to highlight their personal blend of musical styles. Their music was complex, their lyrics were cryptic, and their attitude was one of brazen stylistic rebellion. The classic lineup remained more or less intact over the next decade, until the band formally split up in 1981 to pursue individual projects and pursuits.

As rock n' roll breakups often go, however, Yes' proved short lived. Over the next two decades, the band re-formed in a multitude of different configurations with a mix of both new and old members, each attempting to reignite the flame that had propelled it in its creative heydey of the '70s. In 2002, the band's classic lineup reunited for a world tour, and in 2003, all five classic members -- Anderson, Squire, Howe, Wakeman, and White -- took the stage at the Montreux Jazz Festival.

Captured with high-def cameras, this HD DVD edition of 'Yes: Live at Montreux 2003' presents that performance from the Montreux Jazz Festival.

Upfront, I have to admit to not being a huge fan of these sorts of cash-out performances from the reunited greats of rock 'n roll. While I recognize their appeal for die-hard fans, viewed outside of the warm glow of nostalgia, it's hard not to view them as a cynical exercise.

Watching 'Yes: Live at Montreux 2003,' I still had those feelings, although it would be hard to argue that the concert doesn't deliver on the bottom line. The 17-song setlist includes a long list of recognizable favorites from the band's classic era, including the tonally disjointed "Siberian Khatru," the multi-staged "And You and I," the ridiculously popular "Heart of the Sunrise," and the harmonic masterpiece, "Roundabout." And to their great credit (unlike the grimacing reunions of other rock greats), at least all of the band members seem to be enjoying themselves.

While all the pieces may be in place for a great concert, there just isn't an on-stage chemistry linking the five band members. Anderson seems to sing in a haze and the songs are slower and more obvious than they were in their original recordings. Wakeman hardly looks up, Howe is happy to be left to his own solos, and White seems to spend more time smiling than he does pounding out the rhythms the band is known for.

Perhaps it's impossible for a seminal band like Yes to live up to the heightened expectations of a reunion concert two decades past their prime, but watching this disc, I couldn't help but feel that the intervening years had robbed the quintet of the passion that had made their music so groundbreaking. I can't deny a superficial satisfaction in seeing the classic members playing their greatest hits, but all things considered, this disc is likely to be of limited appeal to all but the band's most devoted fans.

The complete tracklist is as follows:

1) Siberian Khatru
2) Magnification
3) Don’t Kill The Whale
4) In The Presence Of
5) We Have Heaven
6) South Side Of The Sky
7) And You And I
8) To Be Over
9) Clap
10) Show Me
11) Rick Wakeman Solo Medley
12) Heart Of The Sunrise
13) Long Distance Runaround
14) The Fish
15) Awaken
16) I’ve Seen All Good People
17) Roundabout

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

Like its HD DVD counterpart (released in 2007), 'Yes: Live at Montreux 2003' is presented with an identical 1080i/VC-1 transfer that fails to drum up much excitement. Like most concerts shot on HD video, the colorful picture is lush and packed with plenty of sharp detail -- beads of sweat, textures in the clothing, and glints of light are crisply rendered on the screen, but as I watched the concert, I began to notice a number of issues that continually degrade the picture quality throughout the performance.

Banding was the first problem to pop up, and it's almost immediately followed by digital noise in the bright spotlights, pixilation on band members, and artifacting in the darkest corners of the stage. None of these hiccups are terribly distracting until Chapter 8 when the lights kick up, the primaries begin to bleed, and substantial crushing issues appear. Just watch the edges of Steven Howe's head and guitar throughout Chapters 8 and 9 -- at times, his skin seems as if it's made of Legos and the transfer has a difficult time distinguishing between his hair and the spotlight. The resulting mess is blocky and unbearably distracting.

To be sure, I've seen worse concert presentations, but I've also seen much better -- this one is decidedly middle of the road.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Sadly, the audio quality on this disc is also a disappointment. 'Yes: Live at Montreux 2003' features an underwhelming DTS-HD 5.1 surround track (1.5 Mbps), a decent Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 surround (1.5 Mbps), and a clean LPCM 2.0 stereo mix (which replaces the clunky Dolby Digital stereo track from the HD DVD version). The clear winner in this forgetable war is still the Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 mix -- it not only adds an increased stability to the treble ranges and guitar twangs, but gives Jon Anderson's voice a fuller presence in the center channel.

Unfortunately, all three tracks rely far too heavily on the front three speakers, and fail to create any convincing level of immersiveness in the soundfield. The mix seems to pump the same sound out of each channel (albeit at different volumes) and there isn't any subtlety or nuanced design to the distribution of the music. The subwoofer is also particularly subdued compared to most concert releases. In the end, the sound package should be the most impressive element on a concert disc, but this Blu-ray doesn't sound much better or more complex than a low-budget audio CD.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Mirroring the standard-def DVD and HD DVD release that preceded it, this Blu-ray edition doesn't include any supplements.

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Nothing.

Final Thoughts

As a huge fan of early progressive rock, I was really hoping for a high-def winner with 'Yes: Live from Montreux 2003.' Unfortunately, I found the concert itself a passionless affair, and this Blu-ray shares the same fate. The video presentation is technically problematic, the audio lacks punch, and there isn't a single supplement to be found. This one's for hardcore completists only.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray 25GB Single-Layer

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.78:1

Audio Formats

  • English DTS HD High Reslution 5.1 Surround (1.5Mbps)
  • English Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 Surround (1.5Mbps)
  • LPCM Stereo 2.0 (448kbps)

Supplements

  • None

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.