Blu-ray
Rent it First
3 stars
List Price
$19.99
Amazon
$11.45 (43%)
3rd Party
$5.97
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
3 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
2 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4 Stars
Supplements
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
0 Stars
Bottom Line
Rent it First

Sleuth (2007)

Street Date:
March 11th, 2008
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
March 3rd, 2008
Movie Release Year:
2007
Studio:
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
Length:
89 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated R
Release Country
United States

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

It's not often that an aging, established screen legend literally passes the torch to a young upstart in the industry, but I can't think of any other way to describe the handoff that's occurred between Michael Caine and Jude Law. In the 2004 remake of 'Alfie,' Law was cast in the title role that scored Caine a Best Actor nomination in 1966 original. Despite the remake's chilly critical reception, Law must have impressed Caine enough to warrant another remake and another chance to fill Caine's shoes. This time the two appear on screen together in 'Sleuth' -- a revamp of the 1972 film of the same name that saw a young Caine go toe to toe with Laurence Olivier himself.

In director Kenneth Branagh's rendition of 'Sleuth' (adapted by Harold Pinter), an eccentric novelist named Andrew Wyke (Caine) enters into a dangerous contest of wits with an unemployed actor named Milo Tindle (Law). It seems the young lothario ran off to London with Wyke's wife, but has returned to convince the old man to finalize his divorce. In spite of his cocky swagger, Milo is taken aback when Andrew agrees to his demands and offers him an enticing proposition. After his intense greed overpowers his common sense, Milo foolishly enters into a deadly game of cat and mouse with the wealthy millionaire. Yet three gunshots later, the story takes a sharp turn towards the surreal as Andrew is suddenly subjected to his own brand of torment.

'Sleuth' starts off strong with an incredibly tense first act. Caine and Law are ablaze with assurance and obsession, anchoring every scene with their daring performances. Thankfully, their sharp banter and terse retorts are merely the tip of the iceberg -- the competition that spills onto the screen belongs as much to the actors as it does to their characters. With each underhanded remark, the performers invest their souls into their characters and manage to transform a rather long-winded script into a murderous contest of wills. To their credit, Caine and Law's performances nearly make 'Sleuth' worth the film's 90 minutes.

So what goes wrong? The film downfall begins with a painfully transparent plot twist at the forty minute mark that sent me into fits of laughter. Not only did I instantly see through the filmmakers' shoddy ruse, I felt insulted by their attempts to disguise such an obvious "surprise" for an additional twenty minutes. Within seconds, I was so distracted by the ham-handed nature of the storyline's new direction that I could take nothing serious. If Andrew is such a brilliant manipulator over the course of the first act, how is he suddenly struck with such unbelievable blindness and stupidity a few days later? Are we to believe that this eccentric genius can't make a simple deduction? By the time the second act "reveal" was in full swing, I felt completely divorced from the characters, it no longer mattered who won this frivolous game of mental chess.

Although the script had legitimately roped me in with its story and dialogue, I suddenly found myself apathetic to the plight of either character. Frankly, I wished Andrew and Milo would just shoot each other and leave me wondering why the credits were rolling thirty minutes into the film. Caine's aggressive titan devolves into a sheepish cuckold, while Law's naïve dreamer abruptly becomes a calculating sociopath. Meanwhile, the script abandons a genuinely intriguing character study for a cheap plot lifted from every straight-to-video thriller on the shelves. If the film had extended its first act, eliminated its ridiculous second act, and jumped straight into the finale, I would probably be singing its praises.

The original 1972 'Sleuth' is dreadfully campy when compared to this cold, dark remake, but it at least had the good sense to maintain its narrative flow from beginning to end. Branagh's 'Sleuth' is so infatuated with the nature of its twists and turns, that it forgets to prioritize the logic of its story and the natural development of its characters. I'd like to say that I stumbled onto something special here -- that Branagh didn't settle for the same thriller clichés we've seen time and time again. Unfortunately, I have to recommend staying far away from this mangled mess of cinematic over indulgence.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

As dark and bleak as the film is somber and joyless, 'Sleuth' features a respectable 1080p/AVC transfer that renders the claustrophobic confines of Andrew's shadowy mansion with ease. The steely palette is rife with blues and grays, but skintones are quite natural and primary splashes really pop. Blue spot lights, purple jewels, and red sculptures look bold and stable in high definition, interrupting the otherwise monotonous color scheme. Luckily, the transfer's fine object detail shines, even when the imagery becomes mundane. Facial textures are remarkable -- individual pores, split hairs, and frayed stitches are clearly defined and three dimensional. There are a few instances in which certain shots aren't as crisp as the rest of the film, but this softness appears to be the result of inconsistencies in the original print rather than in the transfer itself.

'Sleuth's heavy darkness worried me at first, but I'm pleased to report that the transfer is devoid of artifacting, compression issues, and edge enhancement. In fact, my only ongoing complaint is that grain and noise frequently bunch up in scenes flooded with intense color. Skip to the last scene in the film and pay close attention to Michael Caine's close-up -- notice the garbled noise swarming in the red light on his face? This strange anomaly occurs throughout the film and serves as a constant (albeit minor) distraction. Regardless, anyone looking to pick up 'Sleuth' should be satisfied with this vivid, above-average effort from Sony.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

'Sleuth' relies on an impressive Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track (48 kHz/ 16-Bit) that packs a startling punch for an otherwise quiet, conversation driven film. Dialogue is clean and well prioritized, realistically bounding around Andrew's mansion by using each surround channel to its full potential. As it stands, echoes and ambient effects are especially convincing, allowing the listener to effortlessly immerse themselves in the audible experience. Dynamics are also an aggressive element in the mix -- low-end bass pulses punctuate the soundscape with authority, while stable violin trills embolden the psychologically strained atmosphere of the film. If I have any minor nitpick, its that the LFE channel seems a bit too eager at times. Although I'm sure it's the result of an intentional directorial decision, voices tend to sound unnaturally loud during particularly intense scenes.

All in all, the TrueHD track included on 'Sleuth' may not make this a reference disc you can pop in to wow your friends, but it's an entirely capable mix that faithfully recreates the theatrical experience. Fans will certainly be pleased.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

The Blu-ray edition of 'Sleuth' includes all of the supplemental content that appears on the standard DVD, upgraded to high definition no less. Alas, the information quickly grows repetitive and I found my finger poised on the fast forward button.

  • Commentary with Director Kenneth Branagh and Actor Michael Caine -- Caine and Branagh sit down for an excitable discussion about the production, the on-set atmosphere, the differences between the 1972 original and the new remake, and the nuances brought to the characterizations of Andrew and Milo. Unfortunately, the commentators begin a trend that will seep through every supplement on the disc -- they seem genuinely convinced that the film is unpredictable and that the second act reveal, in particular, is a real surprise for viewers. While many of their comments and anecdotes are certainly interesting (their dissection of Andrew's house, the strange sexuality at play in the remake), they tend to be infatuated with their own work to the point of losing objectivity. Fans of the film may enjoy this one, but I longed for an unbiased examination of the performances and their relation to the story.
  • Commentary with Jude Law -- The information garnered from this additional track would've been quite exceptional if Law had appeared with Branagh and Caine in a single commentary. Law's track suffers midway through the film's runtime, growing silent far too often as the actor resorts to summations of the differences between the story and the original stage and film versions of 'Sleuth.' The young actor also seems infatuated with the "shock and surprise" of the second and third acts, rather than discussing the nuances of the characters themselves. Even those who enjoyed the film will begin to grow weary of this dry, lackluster track.
  • A Game of Cat and Mouse (HD, 15 minutes) -- This standard making-of featurette covers the genesis of the project, the changes made from the original play and the 1972 film, and the development of Branagh's new take on each character. The best bits come in the form of interview clips where Caine and Law discuss the psychological profiles of their characters and the reasoning behind their performance decisions. Unfortunately, these brief sparks can't keep the featurette from delving into repetitive information covered at length in Branagh's commentary.
  • Inspector Black: Make-up Secrets Revealed (HD, 3 minutes) -- This is a quick featurette that looks at the make-up effects used in the second act of the film. It's impressive work, but the prosthetics never concealed the actor well enough to make the plot twist work.
  • Trailers (HD, 16 minutes) -- While it doesn't include the theatrical trailer for 'Sleuth,' this Blu-ray disc includes previews of 'Steep,' 'Saawariya,' 'The Jane Austen Book Club,' 'Across the Universe,' '30 Days of Night,' 'We Own the Night,' 'Closer,' and 'The Holiday.'

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Nothing.

Final Thoughts

'Sleuth' just didn't do it for me. Michael Caine and Jude Law deliver a pair of stirring performances, but fail to prevent the story from collapsing under the weight of its own pretentious twists and turns. As a Blu-ray release, the film fares a bit better -- it features an above average video transfer, an unexpectedly strong TrueHD track, and a decent collection of supplements. Even so, I would approach with caution and give this one a rent long before you shell out much of your hard earned cash.

Technical Specs

  • Blu-ray
  • BD-50 Dual-Layer Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/AVC MPEG-4

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.35:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround (48kHz/16-Bit)
  • Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround
  • Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English SDH
  • English Subtitles
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles
  • Portuguese Subtitles

Supplements

  • Audio Commentaries
  • Featurettes
  • Trailers

Exclusive HD Content

  • None

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

List Price
$19.99
Amazon
$11.45 (43%)
3rd Party
$5.97
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»

Related reviews